Chapter 6: Recantation

Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 3

Qays, Qardam b.Amr, Kab b. al-Ashraf, Rafib Abu Rafi, al-Hajjaj b.

Amr and an ally of Kab’s, al-Rabi b. al-Rabi b. Abul-Hugayq and Kinana

b. al-Rabi b. Abul Huqayq came to the Prophet® and asked: ‘Why have you turned your back on the Qiblah you used to face when you claimed

to follow the religion of Abraham? If you returned to the Qiblah in

Jerusalem we would follow you and declare you to be true.’ Their sole

intention was to seduce him from his religion. So God said: ‘We

appointed the Qiblah, which you formerly observed, only to distinquish between he who will follow the Messenger and those who will not - to test and fetch them out. In truth, it was a hard test except for those whom

Allah guided."!

The Holy Qur’an prescribes no punishment for these recanters. And history

records the punishment of no one who recanted after the change of the

Qiblah.

Surah Al-Imran, which was revealed after the victory of Badr, 2AH/ AD/624, contains the following two verses which mention the recanta- tion of some of the Jews of Medina:

O People of the Scripture: why do you confound the truth with falsehood

and knowingly conzeal the truth? (3:72)

And a party of the People of the Scripture says: ‘Believe in that which has

been revealed to those who believe at sunrise and disbelieve at sunset. In

order that they may return.’ (3:73)

Tbn Ishaq has given the names of those who hatched this plot: Abdullah b. Sayf and Adiy b. Zayd and Al-Harith b. Auf agreed to pretend to believe in the message of Muhammad® and his Companions at one time, deny it another to confuse them. The object was to get them to follow their example and give up their religion.!?

None of these three Jews was punished.

Another reference is in Al-Nisa. It says: ‘Those who believe then disbelieve, then believe again, then disbelieve and then increase in their disbelief will never be forgiven by Allah, nor will He guide them to the way.'(4.138) A recanter cannot enjoy the repeated luxury of believing and disbelieving if the punishment is death. A dead man has no further chance of again believing and disbelieving.

The sunnah, the divinely inspired behaviour of the Holy Prophet®, is the second source of the sharia. And there is no penalty for conversion from Islam in the sunnah either. The names of those who were executed by the Prophet are preserved in the sirah and the hadith and the names of people who recanted and rejected Islam in his life are also preserved. A Bedouin Arab was converted to Islam by the Prophet* and soon after suffered a fever while in Medina. He asked the Prophet* to release him from his pledge. He made this request three times and was refused three times. He left Medina unmolested.

The Prophet*, on hearing of his departure, observed: ‘Medina is like a furnace which separates the dross from what is pure.”?

Tbn Ishaq reports that the Prophet had instructed his command- ers when they entered Mecca to fight only those who resisted them. The only exceptions were the following criminals who were to be killed even if they were found wrapped within the curtains of the Kabah."*

1. Abdullah b. Sad b. Abi Sarah.

2,3,4. Abdullah b. Khatal of B. Tayam b. Ghalib and his two dancing

girls, who used to sing satirical songs about Islam. One of them was

Fartana, the name of the other is not given by Ibn Ishaq.

5. Al-Huwayrith b. Nugaydh b. Wahb b. Abd b. Qusayy.

6. Magees b. Subabah.

7. Sarah, freed slave of one of the B. Abdul Muttalib.

8. Ikrama b. Abu Jahl.!*

Abdullah b. Sad was one of the Prophet’s* scribes in Medina. He recanted and defected to the Meccan unbelievers. Since he wrote down the revelation, dictated by the Prophet®, and enjoyed a position of trust, his defection was bound to create confusion among the Quraish of Mecca about the authenticity of the revelation itself. After peace returned to Mecca, his foster brother, Uthman b. Affan, interceded with the Prophet* on his behalf and he was pardoned.'® Had there been a penalty in the Holy Qur’an for recantation, the Prophet® could not have done so. The Prophet’s* policy on intercession in respect of hadd punishment is well illustrated by the incident of the Makhzumi woman who was found guilty of theft. When Usamah b. Zayd pleaded for her, the Prophet rebuked him and said: ‘Do you intercede in respect of a punishment prescribed by Allah? Witness this: that if Fatima, daughter of Muhammad, were ever guilty of theft, I would certainly cut off her hand.’

Abdullah b. Khatal was sent by the Prophet* to collect zakat, accomapnaied by an Ansar who served him. When they stopped, he ordered his companion to kill a goat for him and prepare some food before going to sleep. When he awoke the man had done nothing, so he killed him in anger and then recanted and defected to the Meccan Quraish.'” He was executed for the murder of an Ansari Muslim by Said b. Hurayth al-Makhzumi and Abu Barzh al-Aslami.'®

One of Ibn Khatal’s two singing girls was killed for creating unrest by singing satirical songs; the other was pardoned.'®

Al-Huwayrith b. Nuqaydh was in the party of Habbar b. al-Aswad b. al-Muttalib b. Asad who overtook the Prophet’s* daughter, Zaynab, when she was travelling from Mecca to Medina. Al-Huwayrith goaded Zaynab’s camel. Zaynab was pregnant and had a miscarriage because of the attack and had to return to Mecca. The Prophet* sent a number of people with orders that if they found Habbar b. al-Aswad or Al- Huwayrith they should kill them,” but Al-Huwayrith escaped. In another report, Hisham says that Al-Abbas b. Abd al-Muttalib put Fatima and Umm Kulthum, the two daughters of the Prophet on a camel to take them from Mecca to Medina. Al-Huwayrith goaded the beast so it threw the two women.”! Finally, Ali killed him in Mecca.??

·

10 of 10 left today