Chapter 6: Recantation
Murder in the Name of Allah, Part 4
Magees b. Subabah came to Medina from Mecca and said: ‘I come to you as a Muslim seeking recompense for my brother, who was wrongly killed.’ The Prophet ordered that he should be paid for his brother Hisham. Having received recompense, Magees stayed with the Prophet* for a while. But, as soon as he got an opportunity he killed his brother's slayer, recanted and defected to Mecca.?? Magees was executed by Numaylah b. Abdullah for killing an Ansar, on whose behalf the payment for killing his brother had already been paid.**
Sarah, who was accused of creating disorder, was not killed during the Prophet’s* lifetime.
Ikrama b. Abu Jahl fled to the Yemen. His wife, Umm Hakim, became a Muslim and asked immunity for him and this was granted by the Prophet*.5
There appears to be no evidence to show that the Prophet* punished anyone for recantation from Islam.
The death of the Prophet in 1 1 AH/AD632 confronted the young Muslim administration with a major crisis. Disorder broke out in parts of the peninsula and many tribes detached themselves from Medina by refusing to pay zakat. This movement is known as Al-Riddah. The main task of the Prophet’s successor, Abu Bakr, was to put down this unrest. His first job, however, was to send the expedition the Holy Prophet* had ordered before his death. So an army under the command of Usamah b. Zayd b. Harith was sent to the Syrian border on the second day after the proclamation of his caliphate.
After Usamah and his army had departed, most of the tribes fell away from Medina. Only Mecca, Medina and their surroundings remained loyal to the central administration. Muslim agents appointed to the rebel tribes by the Prophet® just before his death were forced to flee their posts and to return to Medina. it was a full-fledged revolt.
Having decided to fight the rebels, Abu Bakr sent messengers to some loyal tribes calling them to come to his aid. While Abu Bakr was waiting for reinforcements, Kharjah b. Hism, led by Unaynah b. Hism al-Fazari and Al-Aqra b. Habis al-Tamimi, staged a surprise attack on the Muslims. The Muslims fled in confusion, but they re-assembled and counter-attacked Kharjah’s men, who were defeated.
Before the skirmish at Dhu al-Qassa, a delegation of Arab tribes went to Medina to negotiate with Abu Bakr over the question of zakat, but Abu Bakr refused. Some early and prominent muhajirun disagreed with Abu Bakr’s decision to fight those who withheld the zakat. That these tribes were anxious to negotiate showed they had not recanted, and did not want to sever their relations with Medina, yet were not prepared to accept Medina’s control over them. The issue was not belief in Allah and His Prophet®, but the zakat (tax). A group of well-known friends led by Umar objected to Abu Bakr’s decision to fight the rebels. Umar is reported to have said to Abu Bakr. ‘What right do you have to fight these people? The Prophet has said, “I was ordered to fight people until they say there is no God but Allah. If they say this, they safeguard themselves and their property from me.”6
After the departure of the delegation from Medina, Abu Bakr gath- ered the Muslims of Medina and addressed them as follows:
‘The delegation has observed just how few of you there are in Medina.
You do not know whether they will attack you by day or night. Their
vanguard is only a stone’s throw from Medina. They wanted us to accept
their proposals and make an agreement with them, but we have rejected their request. So make ready for their attack.’ Within three days they attacked Medina.””
The war of Riddah caused a great deal of bloodshed. It was inexpli- cable to the subsequent historians of the Arabian state that after the death of Muhammad® so many wars were necessary on Arabian soil; they ac- counted for this fact by a Ridda,”* a religious movement against Islam. The jurists, who had failed to find or in the Holy Qur’an sunnah authority for the execution of Muslims accused of kufr, or war, against opposing Muslim political powers, accepted the assumption without more ado.
Discussing the legality of Abu Bakr’s war against Muslim rebels, Imam AlI-Shafi’i says: ‘Riddah is falling back from a previously adopted religion into disbelief and refusing to fulfil previously accepted respon- sibility.”° Recantation is not enough. It must be aggravated by allega- tions of the breach of an agreement. Ibn Abi al-Hadid, a scholar of a very different school, in his commentary of the Nahj al-Balaghah, clarified the matter when he said: ‘The tribes which refused to pay zakat were not recanters. They were called so, metaphorically, by the Compan- ions of the Prophet*.°
According to Wellhausen, Riddah was a break with the leadership in Medina and not with Islam itself. Most of the tribes wanted to continue worshipping Allah, but without paying tax. Caetani agrees with Wellhausen and says the Riddah was not a movement of recantation and that these wars were purely about politics. Becker, following Wellhausen and Caetani, concludes:
The sudden death of Mahomet gave new support to the centrifugal
tendencies. The character of the whole movement, as it forces itself on
the notice of the historian, was of course hidden from contemporaries.
Arabia would have sunk into particularism if the necessity caused by the
secession of Al-Riddah had not developed in the State of Medina an
energy which carried all before it. The fight against the Ridda was not a
fight against apostates, the objection was notto Islam, per se, but to the
tribute which had to be paid to Medina; the fight was for political supremacy over Arabia. *!