Text
The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 10
One section of the Mussalmans is of opinion that the Moslems will win their object by non-co-operation. But it must be remembered that non-co-operation is a weapon, which only a big community can with advantage use against a smaller community, but not a small community against a larger body. A small community of men speci- ally of such, whose activities contribute little towards the civic or political life of the country, can hardly make any impression when pitched against a large population. In Bardoli, the strength of the non-co-operators' position consisted in their having the country behind them. The Britishers could not come over to purchase their lands in India. But if it ever comes to a conflict between the Hindus and the Muslims, the former will not suffer any of the disadvantages which Englishmen had to experi ence. They will be able to put in three Hindus for every Mussalman. Thus the idea of fighting the Hindus through non-co-operation is also not worth consideration.
The third alternative is that the Moslems should seek the co ... operation of foreign powers in order to regain their lost rights. That too is hardly feasible. Firstly, no foreign country could be expected for their sake to enter into hostilities with a neighbouring power. Is there in the near past any example of any Muslim power coming to the help of another? How then should we persuade ourselves to believe that the adjoining powers will hasten to our aid? Again it is a sheer madness to expect that an outside power will sacrifice lakhs of men and crores of rupees, and in the event of a victory will withdraw in favour of the Indian Mussalmans. The invading power will either demand the whole of the conquered territory or a portion thereof ; and I am sure that a section of the Indian Muslims themselves would oppose such a demand and refuse to admit the foreigners into their country. Thirdly, even assuming that some foreign power would feel disposed to make such an adventure, what power is there prepared to launch an attack against a vast country like India, thoroughly equipped with all the mode1·n impli- men ts of war? Afghanistan has a population of barely one crore, Persia of one crore and a half, while Indian population exceeds 33 crores. Fourthly, the fact must
be remembered that India will be given dominion status
and not complete independence. As such, it will form a part of the British Empire and in the event of a foreign power launching an offensive against India, the whole Empire will be at its back. Thus judging by the material aspect of the question, even the third alternative is an impossible dream. Moreover, it is highly immoral to wish for such a foreign intervention, an act of high treason to the nation.
Possibly there are some who think that as India will not be completely independent we will appeal to England for a restoration of our rights. From what I have stated elsewhere regarding the rights of the Domi nions, it will appear that no such thing would be possible. Firstly, because here the question would be not the Hindus encroaching upon our rights, but the question would be how to persuade the Hindus to restore us our rights which we, of our own free will, would have given away only to discover our mistake later on. Now, from the legal point of view it is evident that although Britain will have the formal right to veto the decision made by the Dominions, it will not have even the formal right to force anything new upon the dominions. Legally, there fore, Great Britain shall have no right to interfere in such matters, and even if it had, it does not stand to sense that Britain would care to exercise the right. I have a very
high opinion of Great Britain, but nevertheless, I cannot persuade myself to think for a moment that Britain will incur national loss for the sake of another party. Every sensible man can well understand that the ties that bind Britain and the Dominions together are those of senti ments, and no worldly force unites them. A Dominion has its own army, its own navy, its own administration, there being only a solitary Governor coming from Great Britain who also is a mere figure-head. And further, when the Dominions have the right to break away from Britain at any time they choose, how is it possible that Great Britain will offend, for the sake of a minority, a powerful Dominion -..vhich is the star of its diadem. Britain· s justice is limited by her national interests. When her national interests are at stake, Great Britain will not decide its policy on the merits of the case, but from the imperial viewpoint. It must not be forgotten that no one will befriend a minority unless there is some thing material to �be gained. A minority must trust to itself to safeguard its interests. In support of my con tention that the minorities are faced with utmost difficulty in obtaining justice for th<:;mselves, I would quote the views of one, who is at present the greatest authority on the subject. I mean Prof. Gilbert Murray, who accom panied the British Delegation to the Peace Conference-as an expert, and subsequently worked under the League of Nations. He is interested specially in the welfare of
the minorities, and has, in this connection, made several useful suggestions to the League '' In his introduction to '· The Protection of Minorities '' by Miss L. P. Mair, M.A., Prof. Gilhe1t Murrav writes,-11 The duty laid upon the Council has proved somewhat alarming to the timid virtue of that eminent body. To intervene on behalf of oppressed minorities is to �ourt unpopularity and cer.. tainly no member of the Council has shown alacrity either to listen to complaints or to remedy injustice.''
From the above it is clear that even the appeals of minorities fail to be effective because espousing the cause of minorities means war with majorities, and no body likes to get into trouble for the sake of others. The Muslims should, therefore, consider this door as also closed upon them. Do not the Muslims pe1ceive that, from the days the Reforms have been introduced. an increasing number of Britishers is daily becoming the partisans of the Hindus? Of the British-owned papers, with a few excep� tions, all are in favour of the Hindus. The speeches of British statesmen one and all su.pport the Hindu view� point. And if you mark the British officials, you will find them patting the Hindus on the back. What is the reason behind all these? Do the Muslims think that this is because the Hindus are in the right, and they in the wrong? If such is their conviction then all they should do is to give up this position and adopt the right attitude. But if it is not so, then they should attribute this sudden change to the introduction of the Reforms As the foundation of the representative form of Governrnent has been laid in India, the Britishers are day by day leaning towards the Hindus. But this is only the beginning. When India will attain to full responsible Government, and the Hindus will dominate in the Assembly, then it will be the most cherished object of the Britishers to win the Hindus· goodwill and favour. When we see that in Ireland the English ignored the opposition of men of their owt'. race and religion, and acceded to the wishes of people of South Ireland, how can we then expect them to support the Indian Muslims against their own best national interests ? Let the Muslims then wake up and safeguard their own interests, for what they surrender to-day, they are sure by no means to get back to-,norrow. Only two alternatives will be open to them either to give up their religion and merge in the Hindus, er to allow themselves to be gradu..
ally obliterate
d . Does either of the two
alternatives
appe al to the Muslims? If not,
then I discharge rnY. duty
by wa rning them to- day that now
is their. opportunity_ to
ecure
their rights . A mistake now made
ir
eparable disaster. They must not be
in d ependence. They must not help to repeat
enac t ed in Sp ain ; for,
one Spain is enough to make us
m ise ra ble.
I do not m ean to say that you must not make efforts
for t he freedo m of India. Now when Grea, Britain her se lf has de cided that India is entitled to representative Go vern m
en
every legitimate effort made for its attainment. Bu t what weighs heavy upon my mind and saddens my h
e
art is the though t, that the Muslims should agree to
cons titu ti onal reforms without safeguarding their own in t eres t s. The conse quences of such action are bound to be mos
bitter and disasterous. The Muslim ought not to agr e
e
to an
y
settlement unt
the proposals o f bo t
the se ctions of the Lea gue have been acc-�pted,
o the
w ise it w ill result in so serious a situation that the ver
y
tho ugh t of it makes one shudder. This also shoul d be borne in mind that