Text

The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 9

to take an active part in the war or to keep aloof. With

regard to treaties also it was mutually agreed that jf the Dominions were not consulted in respect of any treaty

with a foreign nation and they were not signatories to the same, such treaties would not be binding upon the Dominions. In 1924, the late Mr. Bonar Law, a former prime minister, addressing the Imperial conference, re cognised the right of the Dominions to sever the imperial connection any moment they chose. The Government of South Africa and Canada too have declared their right to break off from Great Britain (Encyclopredia Britanica,

XIII Edition-Supplementary List Vol I under British Empire).

The above-mentioned sketch of the constitution of Dominion Governments indicates that the Dominion form of Government is a sort of independent Government with the only difference that for the time being they recognise the sovereignty of the British Crown, and by acknowledg ing to be component parts of the British Empire, add to its prestige and derive benefit from such a connection. Nevertheless, the decision is a ).natter of its own sweet will whether a Dominion would maintain or break the Imperial connection. Secondly, the other limitation to its complete independence is, that, although in internal matters, it enjoys perfect independence having the power not only to make ordinary laws but nlso to alter its con stitution, a Dominion, so long as it maintains the imperial connection, is bound to transact all important foreign alfairs through the intermediary of the British Government.

This is the kind of independent Government demand ed by the Nehru Committee, and the whole of the !Indian people barring a negligible few, joins in the demand. The question now arises how is it possible to effect an alteration in the laws of &uch a Government? For, the problem before us is that if the dec1sjons of the Nehru Committee do not prove favourable to us, will it be possible for us to get it modified? And if so, how?

It· should be borne in mind that under such a kind of Government, there arc only three ways to change a law :

(I) By the votes of a majority in the Councils.

(2) By forcing the hands of Government by opposi

tion.

(3) By overthrowing it with the help of foreign powers.

I see that those who have endorsed the views of the Nehru Committee have placed their reliance upon one or other of these three alternative means for the removal of their future grievances. Some are of opinion that if the rights which they are going to waive to-day, should in future be found indispensable for the community's w I

fare, they would be able to regain the same through the

legislature by getting the laws changed. Another grouo while admitting its inability to carry the houses with th m, believes that, jf a necessity arises for a change in the law they would be able to set up an effective opposition to Government and force it to chang the law according to the wish of the community. 'There is yet a third group which admits that the Indian Moslems can do nothing of themselves, but with the help of the neighbouring Muslir-o kingdoms they would be able to upset any Government that would deprive them of their rights. I shall take up the three alternatives severally and show that under the conditions of a Dominion form of Government it will be impossible for the Mos Iems to regain their lost rights by any of these three courses.

With regard to the first suggestior that the Mus- 1ims will be able to secure their rights through the Coun.. cils, it must be borne in mind, that according to the are vested in the Central Government, where their repre sentation, as apportioned by the Nehru Committee, will be less than what it is now. When our present experi ence shows that in spite of our thirty per cent. representa tion in the Assembly, we fail to have our way even by joining hands with Government members, what may --Ne expect to achieve in future, when we shall be reduced to 25% only, and when the British element will be com pletely absent ; particularly when the question will be not one of general policy but of strengthening the present weak position of the Muslim community by effecting changes in the constitution. Can any sensible person even for a moment conceive that a single Hindu vote will go in favour of the Muslims over such a pro posal? Again, can any sensible man conceive that 25% Muslims will be able to force the hands of 25 �6 non Muslims and get the law passed in their favour? Specially when it is a question appertaining to a change not of the ordinary law but of the constitutional law, which it is still more difficult to bring about. The Nehru Com mittee in their report lays down the fallowing procedure in respect of future alterations in the constitutional law : -" Parliament may, by law, repeal or alter any of the provisions of the constitution, provided that the bill em bodying such repeal or alteration shall be passed by both Houses of Parliament sitting together and at the third reading shall be agreed to by not less than two-thirds of the total number of both Houses. A bill so passed at such a joint sitting shall be taken to have been duly passed by both Houses of Parliaments."

In accordance with the above rule if the Muslims should in future find that they committed a blunder in accepting the Nehru Committee•s recommendations and were rather hasty in relinquishing their demands, then in order to get their present demands restored, they would have not only to attend the meeting of the Legislature in their full strength but also to win the support of at 1east 42% that is 234 of the Hindu members to vote in favour of their demand. .Not even a crack brain will venture to hope that so many Hindu members will be prepared to support the demand of the Muslims for the restora tion of certain right� which the Hindus themselves have usurped. In fact, I have under-estimated the difficulty. For, it is absolutely wrong to assume that all the mem bers of the Legislative Body will be present on any occa sion. That is never so even in European Parliaments. Of the 700 members, some will be ill, some will have sick relatives, and others will be detained owing to urgent business. Thus a margin of 20°£ should be left for ab sentees. Under the circumstances the Muslims shall have to secure the support of 60% of the Hindu members at tending. 1I ask again is there any Mu�hm, however blind in his support of the Nehru Report, who will be bold to say that if after a lapse of ten years it appears that the joint electorate system has proved detrimental to Moslem interests, which in other words would mean that the Hindus had captured more seats than their numbers would justify, or that such Mussalmans had been re· turned as instead of serving Muslim interests, serve the ends of the Hindus, then will 60% of the Hindu members of the Parliament vote with the Muslim members in order that the Hindu community should be deprived of this advantage and Muslims be restored the right of separate representation, or that complete internal autonomy should be conferred upon the provincial Government? ,lf not, and every sensible man will th1nk such an eventuality to be impossible, then I say, when it will be impossible to regain your rights in future, then why should you not press for the same now?

The second alternative is that the Muslims should get their wrongs redressed by force. With regard to this I would simply ask whether the Muslims feel that strength in themselves. Tow day the Britishers are ruling in India and their number hardly exceeds a few lakhs. Both the Hindus and Muslims are agreed that power should be wrested from the English, but nevertheless, has our united strength so far proved effective in changing the Govern ment? If it has not, then what show of power will the Mussalmans be able to make when India will be governed by Indians and the advantages of keeping intact the existing fabric of its Government will accrue not to a few lakhs but to a population numbering as many as 26 crores?

Further it should also be borne in mind that the army will be under the control of the Central Government. To imagine that Muslim soldiers will desert the Govern ment that pays them and support their community is un thinkable. Even at present one can easily see that they stand for the British Government and not for the Indians. In fact, it is the sentiment of loyalty that upholds the soldier's spirit, and he is never easily persuaded to revolt against his Government. Besides, the modern organisa tion of the army is such that it is impossible for any one unit to break out into revolt, because no one unit is com plete in itself. The army, as a matter of fact, is com posed of six or seven parts, all of which during an operaw tion are mutually inter-dependent and each, fully aware of the fact that in the event of desertion it will meet sure annihilation. Apart from this, aeroplanes, tanks and guns of modern types, have altogether changed the form of wars, a single aeroplane being capable of devastating a

,,, holt ount.ry, and a siugl tank al lt, to challt.ng a whole 1rn1y. In , horl', wnr to clny dc.p nds not so much on 1nan' s p rsonal slr ngth and hrav ry as on tht. mechan. is1n� of war. And vc ry nnl11rnlly chivalry and courage ,vithout th 111 hnnis1ns of war cannot now give th<. san, ad 1antng ns th y did in the past. '"['hus r<·volts in these day!.'., nrc not th, affairs of a particular s ction of peopl but of the country as a whole. Men carry on th ir activiti s in s er 't, inciting the whole country; and the arn1y. the office--bcarers. and the civil population, all rise sin1ultaneously against the Government. Only a few high officials are left to deal with the revolt. But the l\tlussaln1ans can never expect to bring about such a state of things in India for the obvious reason that the major part of the population is Hindu, and naturally their sym pathy will go with the Government. Moreover, the l\1ussalmans should bear in mind that the Hindus are not all what they call the Baniyas. The Pt1njab Mussalmans have been labouring under the false impression that these

a matter of fact the Sikhs also socially form a part of the Hindus, though from religious standpoint they are nearer to the Moslems than to the Hindus. B(-sides, on account ot certain other political considerations, the Sikhs, unless and until some leader of exceptional ability should rise among them, are compelled in political matters to join hands with the Hindus. Their population is confined to the Punjab, where they have relatively the same status as the Muslims have in the whole of India. But under the special conditions of the Punjab where the Muslims form only a very narrow majority, the Sikhs cannot be granted any special concessions. And it happens that the Moslems have become an obstacle in the path of the Sikhs. Hence it is that they are obliged to come to an understanding with the Hindus, and notwithstanding a11 overtures from the part of the Moslerns and their support, and Hindu opposition in the matter relating to Gurdwaras, the Sikhs are keeping hand-in-glove with the latter. Besides the Sikhs, among the Hindus themselves, there are martial classes, such as the Jats, the Rajputs, the Dogras, the Poorbees, the Mahrattas and many other tribes of Southern India. Even the Gurkhas who follow Buddhism, consider themselves a part of the Hindu religi our community. In face of these facts, i: is simply suicidal to deceive ourselves by entertaining the idea that the Hindu population preponderates, it is only natural that pride in the fact that Muslim element is prepondering in the army. This is nothing but a diplomatic move on the part of the British Government. In a country where the Hindu population preponderates, it i3 only natural that the Government should in order to strengthen themselves follow the policy of enlisting a comparatively large num ber of the smaller communities in their army. But in a free India there will be no such necessity. On the con trary the majority community in order to strengthen their position will think of enlisting in the army a larger number of their own co-religionists. The Sikhs, the Oogras, the Rajputs the Mahrattas, the Gurkhas, the Poorbees and the Southerners number from 50 to 60 millions. These could easily furnish men for the army. The idea that we could secure our rights by force is a devilish misconcep tion of which the sooner we disabuse our minds the • better.

·

10 of 10 left today