Text
The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 11
Khilaf a tis ts or others, are made a basis of any agreement, the n th e Mu
ture alter atio n of the present decisions. In tha t case the
ir
rights will be adequatel y protected. Thereafte r i f th e
sa
u
to amend the Ia\ivs, because
t will be the Hindus,
an d no t the Muslims, who will benefit by such ainen
an d the Hindus wi ll not therefore oppose suc h
e.
Do Minorities Need Special Laws 'l
\1 HIS question has long engaged public attention.
We have instances of such protective laws under the Roman Empire for the benefit of the Jews-provisionally for a few years ; and under Islamic rule from the very outset for the benefit of the non-Muslims. After the conquest of Constantinople, Muhammad II enacted special laws for the protection of Christian subjects, most of which remained in vogue until February, 1926, when the Turkish Government replaced Islamic Laws by the Swiss Civil Code, in their country. But the question of minorities was recognised as an international problem for the first time in 1814 when the Congress of Vienna established the new Government of the United Nether lands. As there existed in this country two different languages and two different religions, a document was drafted in the interest of minorities known in history as the " Eight Articles."
Article, 2, was to the effect that " there shall be no change in the articles of the Fundamental Law which assure to all religious cults equal protection and privileges, and guarantee the admissibility of all citizens, whatever be their religious creed, to public offices and dignities.·• ( The Protection of Minorities, p. 36 ).
Article 4-" All the inhab,tants of the Netherlands thus having equal claim to all commercial and other rights of which their circumstances allow without any hindrance or obstruction being imposed on any to the profits of others." ( Ibid. p. 30 ). In as much as up to that tim e the diversity of re lig i on s was
co nsider
e
to be
e so le caus e of conflicts, the re
the t reaty is
confined
o rit
er
mean s also. Fo r instance, in the N e ther
e
es truction o f the minorit y wa s attem
uppre
sion o f it s tongue . Accordingly, i nI 8
at the tim e of the establishment of the kin gd o m of Greece ; in
the tim e o f the separatio n of the Ion ian is la n
n 1 8 56
at the time o f separatio n of Rllma ni a ; an d in
e Congress o f Berlin, regard in g Ser v ia, Mont e negr o, and
Bulgaria, the need fo r the pr otec ti on of minor ities
recognise d and law s were forrn ala te d to s afe
ir
interests.
After the Great War whe n fr
es
in Europe, special undertakin g
e
obtain
ed
Poland, Lithuania, Lativia, Es t ho nia, Austria, Hung ary , Rumania, Czechoslovakia, and Jugos lovakia.
Every effor t was made in these treatie
to s af e
of the minorities from cncroach� ne nt b
y
e ma
or
es.
From the facts narrate
� bove. it is c le a r tha t th e question of protection of minor iti es h
as fo rcen tur ies past engaged public attention, and n
wo
have acknowledged its importa nce . A
t present it is uni versally admitted tha
t minorities, pa rti cularl
y
im
ortant
minorities, require specia
safeg u ar d
onl
y
differ
ence o
views on the subject, th at n
o w pre vails, is t
a t some nations contend that in th
e i r co
u
the
e
is no conflict between the ma joriti e