Text
The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 12
s an d the min orities and
that therefore no discriminatory law
s s ho uld be introd u ced there, while others urge
uc
ws ha ve been introduced in their countries, they
must
be a
opte
all nations. In this connectio n, the
follo wing obser v
a • tions of Miss L. P. Mair may he re ad w
it h in te rest :-
• • But President Wilson did not answer the claim that the same obligations should be imposed on all States which possess minorities. That still remains unanswered and the inequality that which results from the Treaties is resented far more strongly than the interference with domestic affairs which their p1ovisions involve." ( Ibid.
Among those countries to which new minorities have been added after the war, one is Italy. No under taking has been taken from this country regarding minorities. But the plight of minorities there is enough to indicate the importance of the need for their protec tion. ( The case may well serve as an object lesson to the Mussalmans to see what is likely to be their end in case they agree to a settlement with their Hindu com patriots without adequately safeguarding their own interests.} In the newly ceded Italian territory there are parts inhabited by Germans, :'lnd parts inhabited by Serbs and Groats. How Italy, a country far more advanced than India, has treated those people '\vill be clear from an inter .. view given by Signor Mussolini to a French journalist in February, 1926. Miss Mair ,vrites this as under: ,• When I visited the South Tyrol, ( Austrian territory which Italy has obtained now wherein German population predominates), I noticed that everything there was Ger man :-Church, Schools, public functionaries, railway and post officials. Every where HothiI'g but the German language was heard and people sang songs such as in Rome would have caused their immediate arrest. Now in all the schools of this Province the teaching of the Italian language is obligatory, all post and railway officials are Italians, and we are just now about to settle there a large number of Italian families. One thousand families of ex combatants will be sent to South Tyrol with a view to promoting the amelioration of the soil. In this '\A1ay we shall succeed in ltalianising ti:e country." (Ibid. p. 209).
The detail of this Italianisation is as follows :-
, ' All laws and regulations are published in Italian only. The decree of October fs, 1925, making Italian compulsory in the Courts effectively deprives the minori ties of all rights at law. This decree forbids the use of any language other than Italian in all civil and criminal procedure, written and oral. Per sons who cannot under stand Italian cannot be empanelled. All documents, evi dence, etc., in other languages than Italian are null and void." ( Ibid. pp. 212, 213 & 214 ).
After enumerating these fact� the able authoress of '' The Protection of Minorities '' observes :-
'' Only the existence of the Treaties * * * has pro tected other minorities from a similar fate. This illustra tion of what rampant nationalism can do shows how essential the treaties were and how mistaken it was to make an exception in deference to the '' Sovereignty of Italy."
I have nothing to add to the above quotations. The necessity for protecting minorities has been universally recognised. Their plight in Italy where the question of their protection was not taken into consideration is a grim warning to other countries. It now lies with the Mussal� mans to benefit by these lessons.
When I have explained at length the
needless to refute the suggestions 1nade
Committee. But as details may help to
position, it 1s by the Nehru make it still clearer I think it desirable to point out that the Nehru c:ommittcc has supported the C:ongrcss and the Maha sabha view that when equitable lavvs will be formulated, the n1inorities will not stand in the fear of harm at the hands of 1najorities, and there �hall be no need to afford the1n special protection. The argument has all along been advanced by the Hindu community, and even in the Nehru-Report the same may be read between the lines. In fact, the Report has advanced a queer new argument. It says :- " If communal protection was necessary for any group in India it ·vVas not for two major communities, the Hindus and the Mosle--ns. It might have been neces sary for the small communities which together form 109{, of the total." ( Nehru-Report, p. 28 ).
Thus according to the Nehru Committee, minorities as a rule require no protective laws. If such laws are necessary, they are necessary for very small communities, and not for the Mussalmans. I am unable to follow the logic of this argument. The finding appears to me to be wholly contrary to reason. It may be held to be correct only if we assume the correctness of the following pro positions which is far from being the case:-
(i) Between the large minority and the majority
there are chances of friction less than those between the small minorities and the majority.
(ii) Uniform laws always lead to due administration of justice.
On my part I am not prepared to accept the correct..
ness of either of the two propositions, and I do not think any wise man will accept them to be correct. The first of the two propositions is incorrect, because the fact, that brings a majority and a minority into conflict, is not the difference of their numbers, but the presence of some such causes as create in the two parties mutua'l rivalry and animosity, and when such causes are present it is immaterial whether the minority is big o.r small, the majority tries to bring it to grief.
Of the different causes that make for a clash between minorities and majorities, the following are the most potent:-
( 1) In case the minority had held its sway over the majority in the near past and oppressed it, or created an impression in the mind of the majority that it had been so oppressed; in both these cases the majority is obses sed with the idea of avenging itself.
(2) If the minority has a culture and social order which is superior to and predominant over that of the majority, then the majority feels impelled to destroy the minority because of its constant fear that, given the opportunity to progress the, minority will obliterate its own culture and social order.