Text
The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 14
of all complaints. If victuals, suitable for adults alone
were provided in a house where there are both children
and adults, it will certainly not be justice. Similarly, if a child were forced to�move in a crowd of men in a fair. it \.Yould never be right. In order to ensure fairness and justice, conditions must be made suitable to the strength of the child. To give him justice he should be carried on the shoulder, and given diet suitable to his age.
Having nov. proved that uniform laws do not necessarily lead to justice, and that very often they actually defeat the ends of justice, I would now proceea to sho,v that such a contingency is not merely imaginary, but that in the world we have actual instances of men trying to injure particular communities by the enactment of ostensibly equal laws. For instance, the enactment of the East African immigration Laws created quite a stir in India, when it was urged that though the la\.v was ostensibly meant to apply uniformly to all. it '\Vas actually intended to harm the Indians. Similarly. when the ne,v Government of Czechoslovakia legislated that landed pro perty of any individual owner exceeding 500 acres should be confiscated and should change hands. it appeared on the surface to be an equitable law, but it really aimed ¼t the ejection of the pre-war big German property owners. The Czecks themselves were mostly factory owners, and threfore there was little danger of any loss to them arising from the new law. The Germans raised a loud protest but their protest fell on deaf ears. The Government con- . tended that the law was just inasmuch as it affected th� Germans and the non-Germans alike. ( V ide the Protection
of Minorities, p. 120). Similar action V.as taken by the
Rumanian Government in Transylvania where the Magayrs were in possession of the land. ( Vide, Ibid p.' /44).
Thus, it is clear from historical examples also that ostensibly un1f orm laws have often a definite purpose behind them,-that of harming a particular community or preventing it frorn enjoying it.s lcgitirnate rjghts. 'The authoress of " 1'hc /Jroleclion of Minorities " al�o shares the snrne view. She writes :-
"'fhc i1l-treat1nenls of rninorities may range from the crude forms of massacre and mass expulsion to more re fined methods, of which the most popular js the restric tion of the free use of the mother tongue. r:ducation, laws and regulations for the administration of justice are the most obvious means to this end." ( Ibid. p. 29 ).
From the above it is abundantly clear that in our times majorities oppress the minoritie5 through the refined process of enacting laws, which are ostensibly uniform, but which result in the annihilation of a particular community.
It is thus clear that in framing a constitution for India it is not sufficient to see that the laws are the same for the Hindus and the Muslims, but what is im portant is to know how the laws will affect each of the two communities. If it is proved that laws ostensibly uniform are actually disastrous to the Moslems by either directly injuring their interests, or preventing then1 from enjoying their legitimate rights, then it wiil be necessary by all means to alter the san1e.
The other aspect of this question is that jf laws are framed with a view to satisfy the needs of different parties, would that not suffice to meet the ends of jus tice? My answer to this question also is the same, an emphatic no. No nation can be safe by the mere passing of equitable laws, rather it needs two more neces,. sary conditions; namely:-
( I) That adequate provision shall be made to see that the law in question is administered according to its spirit. Most excellent laws are but dead letters when they are not enforced according to the intentions of the framers. A physician may have in stock any amount of quinine pills but the whole lot js of no use if it is not .administered to the patients. A iaw in itself is absolutely nothing ; it is essential that a good law should also be enforced in the right spirit. Its result depends upon its proper enforcement. Even if the rights of minorities are protected by mea::1s of legislative action, but a proper enforcement of such a legislation is not provided for, there is no prospect of peace for the minorities. The League of Nations, in dealing with the question of pro tection for minorities, has also admitted that law alone is hardly worth while unless its operation in the manner intended can be properly watched. As an example, there is the case of Esthonia. When the League dem3.nded an evidence of its treatment of the minorities, the Esthonian Government at first refused to produce such .evidence and contended that the League was entitled to interfere only in the case of an infringement of the laws for the protection of the minorities. In his note on the reply of the Esthonian Government, the representative of the League, who was appointed to deal with the case, observed that the views of the Esthonian Government, if accepted, "would give the Council no power n to interfere with their actions until they proceeded to modify the constitution affecting the Minority. But if. without making any such change, the Esthonian Government con tinued to oppress the minorities, there would be no remedy open to the League. ( Vide, Official Journal of
the League of Nations, for November, 1922.) The League
supported the views expressed by its agent, and rejected Esthonia' s reply with the remark that it did not ensure the safety of the minorities.
The incident shows that aH reasonable people the
world over are agreed that the mere justness of a parti- c ul a r law docs not constitute a sufficient guarantee; it j
eq u ally irnp ortant that provision should bF; made for its
du e enforceinent . The Rajpal case* is of recent o�cur.
re nce. AU the nc·wspapers that are now united in thei
supp ort of the Nehru- f {eport, ag re< ·d that the object o
the la w in this case had been defeated. The same door
is open still
and it is essentia
that it should be closed.
(2
The second essentia
is that the law in question
sho uld be made safe agains
future alteration fo
o bvio us reason, that it is quite easy for a majorit
to frame laws desired by a minority in orde
to win their
con fid ence, and later or to repea
the same when Self
Go v ernmen t has been attained
for, those who can make
a la w ca n also unmake it.