Text

The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 15

In the new States, tha

were formed in Europe after

e

wa r , a two- fold provision has been made to protect

e

right

o

minorities. Firstly, that the laws sha ll

ro pe

the laws shall re

m ain inviolate. To $ecur

e

the first end, the Leagu e of N ati ons ha

to hear appeals o f cases

rel ati ng to minorities. In the event of the minorities

maki n g an y com plain t to the League, it is empowered to

a p po in

a commission to investigat

e th e truth of the alleg ations. Furthe

r, the minorities have been given an effe c tiv e share in the Governmen

in orde

to enable

o

watch the

ir

own interest

r e x am ple, Rothunians who �ome of the Russian

sto

a n d possess thei

have been granted full administrative powers in the

o

y, thoug h they are no doubt subject to t

e

-known cas e in the Lahore High Court i n whic�

Ra1 pal, th e auth?r of a scurrilou s tra ct on �he life of the Prophet ?0

Is lam. was acqu

ted o n the ground that there was no provisio

law to dea l w i

Czechoslovakian Government in the 1natters of general laws and foreign policy. This arrangement has been made in a predominantly Rothunian province. In other parts, however, where they are nowhere in a majority their privileges have been protected in other ways. lln order that their national tongue, religion, and civilisation might be adequately protected, it has been provided by means of statutory laws that Government shall give grants-in-aid to their national committees to run their own schools and religious societies. Secondly, it has been arranged for the minorities to reserve Government appointments in proportion to their numerical strength, and thus a reasonable proportion of the minorities is always to be found in the Government offices, who always take care to see that Lheir communal rights are nowhere ignored. Provisions have also been made to ensure that the laws shaH remain inviolate. It has been stipulated that no Government shall alter, or annul laws pertaining to minorities without the consent of the League of Nations. Under these conditions, no Government even

if its majority should wish to change the laws, finds itself

competent to do so in view of its constitution, and inter.. national obligations; ,,nd in case it tries by force to break those laws, the other powers are there to see that it does not do so. ( Vide, the Protection of Minorities).

lln contrast to the above, strangely enough, the Nehru Committee makes no suggestion vvith regards to the pro

tection of minorities. The Nehru--Report does not recom

mend an autonomous Muslim Government in predomin

antly Muslim provinces similar to that granted to the

Russians in Rothunia, nor in areas where Muslims are in

minority has it been provided that it shall be left to their own committees to solve their educational, religious and cultural problems, nor even has it been guaranteed that a re-distribution of provi . ..1ces shall not take place in such a way as to adversely affect the majority position of the Muslims in any of the provinces. Again, nowhere has assurance been given that the few Muslim demands, that have been partially accepted now, shall remain intact even in the future. It has been laid down that • • Parliament may, by law, repeal, or alter any of the provisions of the con�titution. Provided that the bill embodying such repeal or alteration shall be passed by both Houses of Parliament sitting together and at the third reading shall be agreed to by not less than two-thirds of the total num ber of the members of both Houses." ( J,

p. 123); ,.vhile in the same la,,v it has been recommended

that Muslims should get only one-fourth of the seats in the Central Legislature ( Ibid. p. 54 ).

Under these conditions even if no :\1uslim vote \vere to go over to the Hindus, and in addition even if five or six per cent. of the Hindu members were to pitch them selves against their co-religionists, even then, the Hindus can at any time withhold the rights that they are now con ceding to the Mussalmans; and it is in no way impossible for the Hindus to command two-thirds of the total votes. According to the Report, only 66l per cent. votes are required to effect a change in the constitutional law, and the Hindus are proposed to have 75 °;) of the seats. Wi1l it then be difficult for the Hindus to effect a change in the constitution at any time they like, and leave the Muslims disillusioned?

I think it has now been made abundantly clear that it makes no difference vv hether a majority is big or sma11,

if there is a danger to its rights being infringed then there

is always the need for protectvc 1neasures. And I have also explained the causes which lead a majority to oppress a minority. I have also shown that mere laws are not enough. Two other conditions are . essential. First to ensure that the laws should be properly enforced, and one of the means to this end is that, in areas ,-vhere the minorities preponderate in the :r,opulation, the Govern ment should be left entirely in their hands, and where they do not so preponderate there they should at least have the right to appeal, and matters affecting their corn-· munal life should be left to be dealt ,vith by their com munal committees ; and in Government appointments they should be represented in proportion to their number. Secondly, it should be provided that the constitutional laws relating to minorities shall not be altered except under conditions which will ensure the consent of the minority concerned to such alteration.

Muslim Demands and the Nehru-Report.

•1 N the light of my criticism of the Neh�u-Report, the

politically minded section of the public cannot but agree that the Report is not at all a satisfactory solution of our present problems ; nor can the Muslims accept it without vitaJly endangering their future. But as people at large are not, generally, so well acquainted with, or interested in political matters that they might be expected to apply principles to facts, I consider it necessary to review. in detail, the whole position '"?ith regard to Muslim -demands and the Nehru--Report.

As already stated, the Musiim demands are, as fol lows:-

( 1). The future Government of India shall be of a federal type, i.e., the Central Government should derive its powers from the provinces, and not the latter from the former. With the exception of those subjects, re garding which, for the purpose of joint administration. the provinces might delegate their po\\rers to a central authority, the residual powers should vest in the

·

10 of 10 left today