Text
The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 16
provinces.
(2) Reforms shall be extended to the N. W. F. Pro vinces; and, Sindh and Baluchistan shall be constituted into separate and independent provinces.
(3) All communities shall be allotted seats, in local bodies, according to their respective numerical strength, except in the case of very small minorities who may be given a few extra .'3eats.
(4) In the central legislature, Muslim representation
hall in no case be less than what they are entitled to no"' : in fact. in orde-r to safeguard their interests ade quately. it should be increased to one-third of the total nu111ber of seats.
l5) Con1n1unal electorate iystem shall continue, that is. every con1munity shall choose its own representatives.
ln the event of the afore-mentioned four demands being satisfied. one group from among the Muslims will be prepared to substitute separate electorate by joint elec torate system ,�tith reservation of seats.
(6) Government �hall not interfere with religion, religious propaganda ai1d conYeJ sions, and further it shall enact no la,v relating to religion, social life or culture, as ,,·ould affect '"·holly or mainly any particular religious community.
In order to ensure the strict enforcement of the above-mentioned conditions, it has been urged by the l\lussalmans that,
( i) each community shall b� allotted governmental posts on population basis ; and that.
(ii) for introducing changes in the constitution of the Indian Government, it shall be provided that in the matter -of the laws pertaining to the rig-hts of minorities and pro lection thereof, no changes shall be introduced without the consent of the minorities themselves.
From what I have studied of the constitutional law of the Czechoslovakian Republic, where the situation is more or less the same as it is in India, and further, from what I have seen of the Hindu activities during the past few weeks, I have decided to urge a further point, name ly, that it should be definitely laid down that the Central Covernment shall have no power to modify the terri- torial limits of any province, the decision in such matte resting with the province concerned.
Having enumerated these demands, I now proceed to discuss them severally, to see if they are legitimate, and if so, whether they are also essential. For, when deciding between rival claims, one has first to .see, whether or not, a claim has its basis in right; for, no one is justified, for the sake of his own interest, to force another to for ego his right. In the second place, it is equally important to see if the exercise of the right is also necessary ; for, it is not easy to decide a claim, unless the extent of da�age to the disputing parties, both in the event of its acceptance or rejection, has been properly ascertained. As often as not, a sacrifice may be demanded of one to his disaster, while another per son. already master of the position, may be benefitted by it.
II think it wise to examine, at the very outset, if th conditions in India are such, as necessitate special pro tective measures for the Moslems, and if their continu ance as an isolated ininority is a necessity. I believe that it is a fact admitted by every Muslim, that under the present conditions, the community cannot do without special safeguards. I have already stated that, of the many causes which tempt a majority to oppress a minor ity, there are six main ones. Let us now examine if anY of the same exists in our country.
A minority stands vitally in need of protective mea-
sures under the following circumstances:-
(i) Where the minority community held swaY
over the country in the near or remote past, and the majority community believe, or are led to believe, that the minority had beer1 oppressing it during its regime, it has been often found that the majority community upon its coming into power has. invariably tried to settle its old scores, whether real or imaginary, \vith the minority. Illustrations are not want ing in history. The Buddhists, as past records show, were completely annihilated by the Hindus in India, and so were the >. luslims by Christians in Spain. In our own days similar scenes have been repeated in Greece, Servia, Rumania and Bulgaria. vvhere the Turks pariicularly, and the l\luslims generally, have fall en victims to the reprisals of the Christians, merely on the imaginary ground of their past oppression over their fore-fathers. Again, Germans are being harassed in Poland, part of which was for a long time under German domination. For the same reason. the German land-holders are being oppressed also in Czechoslovakia ; IVlagayrs are being maltreated in· Ru.mania ; l\1agayrs and Austrians in Yugoslavia ; and Austrians in Italy.
These instances are before us. They warn us that one community does often harass another on account of imaginary or real grievances. We may now see that the same dangerous mentality prevails among the Hindus. To begin with, the Britishers in order to consolidate their ow-n domination had to paint the Muslim Emperors in very dark colours, so that Indians might forget their memories and attach themselves to the British Govern ment ; and now, follo"ving them, the Hindus with a view to strengthen the bonds of their nationality have, with very few exceptions, inost vigorously taken up the work of concocting stories of alleged oppression by Muslim Emperors. They have been trying to instil into the· minds of their younger generations, that it was the Muslim conquerors who destroyed the religion, culture, civilisa� tion and intellectual life of the Hindus, and that were it not for them, the Hindus would have been one of the
1oremost people of the present time. Most of the Hindus, both men and women, are to-day burning with a spirit of vengeance against the Muslims on account of the imaginary wrongs committed by them. They most sin cerely believe, that the Muslims alone were responsible for their national downfall, and are convinced of the justice of rearing the foundation of their national progress upon the Muslims' ruin. The following incident would give an indication of the extent of this dangerous attitude. A relative of mine employed a Hindu laciy, there a convert to Christianity, to coach his children. She hailed from remote Mysore and was a highly educated woman. She was so much prejudiced against the Moslems that while teaching history to her pupils ,,vhenever she came across the story of any Moslem King she would skip over the pages, and when press�d by the boys, she would curtly say that she knew best which part was to be taught first and which was to be taught last.
The present mentality of most of the Hindus can be best gauged by that of this woman who was a highly educated lady and had been to England several times. Why are they so much wroth against our dead kings? For no other purpose than to awaken their own people. And can the Mussalmans afford to shut their eyes to the dangerous awaken1n� that ¼"ill result from such ment ality? Certainly not. They are quite justified to demand such special measures as will save their national exist ence from destruction? And no doubt, the responsibility for such a state of things lies in part '1vith the Britishers, .although not to the same extent as with· the Hindus.