Text
The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 17
(ii) The second reason which leads a majority to at t�m
.pt to destroy a mi�ority is cultural and social supe riority of the latter, which leads the majority to fear the minority. The present day Hindu-Muslim problem is not without this aspect. It is needless to investigate the why and wherefore of the existing state of things, but it can hardly be gainsaid that the Muslims do happen to hold a position of real cultural and social superiority in India. There is a total absence of untouchability. A general feeling of social equality does exist among them to an appreciable extent. Also unlike the Hindus, remarriage of widows is more or less still in vogue among them, and they have comparatively few ceremonies to observe on occasions of marriage. In short, the_ cultural and social systems of the Muslims are based on a radically different standard, and the Hindus are fully conscious of the fact that neither can they destroy the l\1uslim culture and social system, nor can themselves go ahead with their ancient traditions in the presence of such factors. This is another reason for our apprehension that the Hindus might stand in the way of our free social and cultural development.
(iii) The third reason that serves as an incentive to the majority to oppress a minority is an element of per manancy in the latter, i.e., the presence in it of some such quality as prevents it from losing its identity. Under such circumstances the majority, finding it impossible to absorb the minority, finally decides to wipe it out. This factor also does exist in the present situation. Islam enjoys a pre-eminence among the religions. inasmuch a.s it has laid down for its followers a special line of conduct relating to politics, society, manners and dealings. The Muslims, therefore, unlike the followers of other religions, cannot make any compromise in these matters and absorb themselves in any other culture. As a general rule, when the majority feels sure that there is nothing in the minority to make for its permanance, it cherishes the hope that in course of time the minority ".vill either merge itself in the majority or otherwise lose its identity, i.e., will aban- don some of its own peculiarities, and adopt some of the ways and customs of the majority, as it was the case with the ancient invaders of India. They accepted some of the deities of the Hindus, and the Hindus in turn bowed down before some of theirs. Similarly these invaders of ancient India themselves adopted a most destructive feature of the Hindu social system, viz., they entered the fold of one or other of the four castes. The Muslims, however, cannot do so, so long as Islam lives among them, and the Hind�s know full weil that so long as Islam flourishes in India, there is no chance of the l\llus lims becoming a prey to the influence of Hindu civilisa tion and culture. And hence the •::a1npaign either to oust the Musljm population from India 0r to convert them to Hinduism.
(iv) The fourth reason that tends to make the majority inimical to the minority is the presence in it of such potentialities as go to make it a progressive com munity, threatening the position of the majority and mak ing it afraid lest the minority should some day be convert ed into the majority. It, therefore, takes to repressive measures in order to bring about the annihilation of the minority. Such a condition also does exist in India. Islam being a powerful missionary religion, it has been maki�g spiritual conquests even during the days of its decline. The last few censuses bear testimony to the fact that Islam has been gaining in numbers not only by birth but also by conversion. It can, therefore, be easily realised that the Hindus cannot suffer this state of affairs to continue unchecked. In the event of the Hindu com munity coming to power, it will do its best to achieve by force what it could not do by religious propaganda ,. and no doubt, hundr.eds of measures could be devised, as would appear ostensibly just but would really aim at stopping conversion to Islam. Hence arises the necessity for safeguarding the Muslims. It may be argued here, that the party system has always its basis in the mutual opposition of the majority and the minority, and the majority has never been found to destroy the opposing minority. True, but this is due to the fact that those minorities and majorities are liable to change places. A majority of to-day may be the minority of to-morrow and vice-versa. As a result of this change of positions, there is hardly any room for mutual animosities. In India the -conditions are radically different. Our party system is not based on political differences. Its origin is in reli gious diversity. Among such parties there can be no immediate change of positions. Although it is quite prob able that a powerful religion may effectively reduce the majority to a minority and then dominate the country for good.
(v) The fifth reason for a majority to oppress a minority is the latter's attachment towards foreigners. What the majority wishes to see is that all its country men should be attached to itself. It cannot brook the sight of any community extending a friendly hand to out siders. But on account of its peculiar circumstances, a minority is sometimes obliged to keep in touch with foreigners. This makes the majority grow suspicious of its movements and fear that it might some time harm '
the majority with the help of the foreigners. In consequence, the majority fe·els always disposed to weaken the minority. There is no lack of precedents of such events. The Bulgarians were maltreated in Greece on the same grounds and in our times the Poles in Lithuania and the
Lithuanians in Poland have been suffering for the same reason. The same conditions are prevalent also in India. The Indian Muslims, in conformity with their religious traditions, consider the Mu.slims all over the world as their brethren, and feel most strongly moved by their woes and sufferings. These brotherly sentiments are reciprocated by the foreign Muslims, and even ·if they are not in a position to actively help one another, there is no doubt that they feel grieved to learn of their misfortunes. Under the circumstances the majority community in India is sure always to remain suspicious of the Muslims and ob struct their progress. This is not an imaginary fear. Do not the Hindus complain that Muslims do not regard themselves as the sons of the soi1 and are inclined to keep relations with foreigners? The Hindus may not be asking it in so many vvords, but the question, no doubt, arises in their minds-what will be the attitude of the Indian Muslims in the event of a war between India and Afghanistan, Persia or Arabia? Will they not support their brethren across the border? If they do, then cer tainly there will always be present an element of weak ness in the Government of India. God alone knows, what the Muslims will do if such a contingency arises ; but the suspicion which has 1nore than once found ex pression from the Hindu leaders will, no doubt, continue to obsess the Hindu minds, and they ,-vill naturally think it to be a service to the motherland to hamper the pro gress of the Mussalmans. I am at one with my Hindu compatriot in the opinion that the development of pat riotic sentiments within limits of justice and reason is essential for the purpose of Self-Government. But at the same time, I cannot understand how the Muslims could suppress their broader sentiments of affectionate attach ment towards the Muslims all over the world. They have acquired this mentality through centuries, and it has practically become their second nature. Nor should it be overlooked that I have qualified the sentiment of pat,. riotism by justice and reason. If, in near or remote future, India resolves to hoist the flag of • Om • on the Holy Kaba, as the Arya leaders have already declared it to be their aim, the Muslims shall most undoubtedly not sacrifice their higher obligations to patriotic considera tions.
( vi) The six ch cause of this suppresgion of a minority lies in the exploitation by the majority of the economic backwardness of the 1ninority. The majority under such circumstances is naturally afraid of losing its advantages in the event of an a'\'vakening among the minority com munity. It is anxious, therefore, to keep the minority backward. This factor also does no doubt exist now in India. Just as most of the ,vealth of Europe is due to the backwardness of Asia, so is most of the wealth of the Hindus due, directly or indirectly, to the backward ness of the Muslims. The Muslims are not traders, the· Hindus, therefore, monopolise all the advantages of trade. l\1uslims are not factory-owners, as a result, the whole profit of industry is being enjoyed by the Hindus. Muslims are few in the: higher professions, for example, law, medicine and engineering. Therefore. the Hindus are reaping the whole benefit of these professions. Muslims are neither financiers nor bankers. The banks, therefore, add only to the Hindu wealth. There are few Muslim contractors, the profit of this business also, there fore, goes to the Hindus. Muslims are backward in education. As a result, the Government posts mostly go to the Hindus, and they alone derive most of the ad vantages of the Universities. In short, in every economic field, Muslims are lagging behind, and the result is that Hindus are growing richer at their expense. The Hindus are, therefore, aware that an awakening among the Mus lims will mean loss to them as a portion of the country's wealth will then be appropriated by the Mussalmans. Under the circumstances, it is foolish to think that the Hindus will willingly and gladly allow the Muslims to go ahead. Would the Muslims give away their property to· lhe Hindus? If they would not, can they expect the Hindus to give up their property to the l\lluslims? When matters stand like this, it may be feared, and rightly feared that the Hindus in the event of coming to power.
will make every effort to perpetuate the backwardness of the l\1uslims. It ;s, therefor•�. indispensable that the Moslems should, from the very beginning, adopt such precautionary measures as may effectively prevent the Hindus from fulfilling their design, and may keep the avenues of work and progress open to the luslims.
Certain people, eitber foolishly or in order to lull the Muslims to a sense of false security. argue that there are innumerable lines of progress befcre the country, and ·therefore the ways !or the Musli1ns • progress are not barred. This is sheer nonsense. There are innumerable ways of progress before the world, but is it not a fact that European interests are obstructing the development of Indian industries? When the English industrialists, thousands of miles remote from India, cannot vie,v ,vith equanimity the industrial development of India, fearing lest it should affect their interests adverse1y .-will the Hindu traders living in India suffer to see their Muslim compatriots going ahead in the commercial field? Can they, again I ask, view with equanimity the replacement in Government offices, of their Hindu brethren by Muslim recruits, who no doubt cannot step in unless vacancies are made in the Hindu ranks? No Government Indian
or non-Indian, will create new posts, merely to accommodate the Mussalmans. Is it not, therefore. important that rules should be 1:-1ade from the beginning in order to secure the rights of the Mussa1mans?
From hypothesis, let us now come to facts. A study of the actual situation in India convinces us of the neces ,sity for special measures for the protection of Muslim rights. I do not think any Mussalman wi11 deny the fact that the Hindu-Muslim relations are not to#day what they ought to be, and also that communal prejudices have been influencing both the parties. Take up, for an instance, Government employment. It is a veritable Hindu mono.. poly throughout, to the prejudice of the rights of the Muslims. A Muslim. v.tho somehow or other chances to enter an office, finds tiis Hindu colleagues bent upon his removal. Recently, a Muslim �ember of the Bengal Legislative Council, put it very nicely that he wondered why a Muslim grows incompetent as soon as he is placed under a Hindu officer, while he grows efficient if placed under an Englishman. We have hundreds of such in stances also in the Punjab of capable Muslims, whose sterling worth had been recognised by English officers, suddenly turning grossly iricompetent as soon as placed under Hindu seniors. S01ne Hindus explain it away by saying that these are the tactics of Englishmen to keep the two communities hostile to each other. This does not, however, appeal to me. The point that has to be considered is whether the Hindus or the Englishmen stand to benefit by these so-called tactics. ,If the former are the gainers, then it is foolish to impute motives to the Englishmen. And moreover, does it stand to reason that for this purpose the Englishmen should make only the Hindus their tools and never persuade the Muslims to run down the Hindu subordinates and expel them from offices? Yet a third point is that, none of the many Government officials who subsequently became national leaders, ever admitted that he had ever been asked to run down his Muslim subordinates and to patronise the Hindus. The communal prejudice has outgrown all proportions and there are facts in my possession to show how Hindu officers have openly asked their Muslim subordinates whether they would tender their resignations voluntarily or await the institution of cases againts them. Unfortun. ately I have no remedy to suggest for such cases.
Similar conditions prevail in the Education Depart ment. The doors of education are being shut against the Muslims. They are freely plucked in the examinations. Heads of certain departments openly tell the Muslim candidates that they will not let them pass and will cut them down in the viva-voce. A Government scholar on reaching the final stage finds his career completely ruined. Hindus do not make purchases from Muslim shops, while untouchability in the matter of food and drink is too well known to need repetition. It is little use glibly calling each other brethren on the platforms. Just witness the plight of those labouring Muslim millions whose homes echo the cry of want. The Hindu Baniyas have been sucking the blood of the Muslim peasant. Though the Hindu cultivators are also sharing the same fate still the ultimate result of the system being the annihilation of the Mussalmans, the Hindus oppose any legislation for the prevention of such a state of things. They allow the Hindu cultivators to suffer with the Mussalmans in the hope that they will be able ultimately to redress the condition of the Hindus. Muslim papers with far larger circulation than Hindu p&pers do not receive Government advertisements, while inferior Hindu papers are full of court notices which, in fact, are the chief source of their income. Questions relating to Muslim interest are denied attention in • the Councils, while everything pertaining to Hindu interests is pressed forward. A telegram to-day brings the news that the question of separation of Sindh was not even allowed to be put before the Bombay Council. In view of these circumstances, can any one make bold to say that the Muslims do not require measures of. protection, and again, any Mussalman in his senses, afford to leave Muslim rights undefined and without reliable guarantees? Any body so doing, will be execrated by the posterity and will appear before h;s Lord as a criminal.
Demand for a Federal Government.
1 HAVE already stated, the Muslims demand a federal
type of Government for India, with fully autonomous provinces ; only such powers being delegated to the Central Government as the Provincial Governments may deem essential for good government. Subjects not mentioned in the constitutional laws, shall be deemed as vested in the provinces, which, in cases of exigencies. may, under special regulations, transfer any subject to the Central Body. The Central Government shall have no power to interfere with the internal affairs of the pro vinces. So far as I can see, the lvluslims in a body sup port this demand. At any rate, both the sections of the League do. The Nehru Committee has, however, turned down the proposal altogether, and, instead of a federal Government, proposed a unitary type of Government. In other words, under the proposed constitution, the central parliament is the supreme governing body which transfers certain powers to provinces.