Text
The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 19
Having exposed the unsoundness of the Nehru Com mittee's proposals, I now proceed to describe the farm of Government India would have, in the event of the Moslem demand being accepted. The provinces shall form separate autonomous Governments, which, in the best interests of India as a whole and their own, shall as a body delegate to a Central Government certain powers, necessary for the administration of such All-India subjects as All-India national force ( the provinces may have forces of their own for local needs ), railways, post and te1e graphs, customs, foreign affairs, currency, etc. If the Central Government wants to get additional powers or to open any new department of work which was not pre viously foreseen, it can do so only by the provinces meet ing in a conference and deciding in accordance with cer tain prescribed rules to grant such powers to the Central
Government. Under this arrr.1ngr-,rnent, F;at:h provint:e will hav the fullcst opportunity for d<; veloprn�nt in it& own way. ·rhc Muslim provinces wiJI have no fear of inter• f ·rcncc from a f lindu Central C�ovcrnrnent, and the Hindu provinces will not havc their progress retarded. An ob j ccti on may be raised that under such an arrangement, redress wi11 be impossible in case of oppression of the Muslims in a 1-lindu province. The answer is plain. ln any case the Central Government will be dominated by the 1-lindus. The Mussalmans can have no hope of re dress from such a Government. If the Hindus would be prepared to listen to the complaints of the Mussa1mans, then the Government of the province concerned would naturally be the proper body for them to approach. By vesting the real authority in the Central Government, there will be no single province in which the Muslims will have free exercise of power.
Another advantage of this form of free Provincial Governments will be that, it will restrain the Central Gov ernment from taking any unjust action. For it will know that the expansion of its powers depends solely on the votes of the Provincial Governments. If it harassed a province where a certain religion preponderated, it would naturalJy be difficult for it to obtain more powers.
In this connection, it must also be borne in mind that, according to this arrangement, there shall be five Muslim provinces as against eight or nine Hindu pro.. vinces, thus securing for the Muslims, rights in excess of their proportion in the population, i.e., more than a third. And as regards the granting of additional powers to the Central Government, it should b� provided, as in the case of other Governments, that such extension will depend upon the vote of three-fourths of the provinces. ◄ 'This will make the Muslim position still more effective.
After having explained the necessity and the ground of the Muslim demand for federal government, and how without its being conceded, the Muslim rights can never be secure, and also how its rejection by the Nehru Com mittee amounts to a virtual refusal to protect the Muslim rights, I now proceed to consider the other aspect of the question, viz., the justice of the demand. In order to decide this, we have to consider, firstly, whether the demand irnolves the infringement of others· rights ; and secondly. whether it is detrimental to the progress and development of the country. In the event of the answer to either of these questions being in the affirmative, we shall have to consider whether the advantages accruing to the l\luslims outweigh the loss that the acceptance of their demand would entail to the country as a whole, or to any community in particular.
The first point, namely, whether the interests of any other community is likely to suffer, does not arise at all. For under a federal type of Government no community stands to lose. The Hindus, who preponderate in India, shall continue to enjoy such preponderance in the Central Government. As for the provinces, Hindus shall pre� dominate in those provinces where they are in a majority and similarly the Mussalmans in the predominantly Mus lim provinces. Thus, under this system, there will be no loss either to the Hindus or to any other community. The acceptance of the Muslim demand will, therefore, lead to no infringement of the rights of any other com munity. The demand is, in fact, not a prayer for any concession ; it is a demand for the mere protection of their rights. And if the 1-Iindus are not pr<...pared trJ grant • to the Muslims their just rights, which entail no sacrifice on the part of the Hindus, and which are rneant mer ly to afford protection to the minorities, then they should never hope to secure the co-operation of such rninorities.
As regards the second point that the demand in question may hamper the country's proriress, suffice it to say that the federal form of government is not a new experiment in any way. On the contrary. it has been tried long and proved to be the best form of Government. The British Commonwealth of Nations itself is a sort of Federation, in the free working of which, the C ·ntral Government does not interfere. The experiment. how ever, has been made with the best result in the United States of America, where from the beginning the very basis of the constitution was laid on federal lines. ·rhis country has had a career of uninterrupted progress and is to-day the wealthiest and foremost power. It is hardly a matter of 25 years, when the British Empire used to build a navy as large as the cornbined fleets of two major naval powers, but to-day even this vast Empire in the presence of the United States has to recede from the field of competition. Only recently, a Labour leader, in course of a speech declared that, it would be a mad Government that would provoke the United States of America and land itself into difficulty. 1---low can it therefore, be said, in the face of such a successful experiment, that under a federal system, a government fail to crrow
in power? This form of Government obtains in South Africa, Australia and Switzerland as well. And although in South Africa and Australia, the British constitution has played an important part in moulding the form of the � focal governments ; and Switzerland, because of the small� ness of its area, has made certain laws which cannot be operated in bigger countries, the Corm of government in all these countries is nevertheless on federal lines, and is being successfully worked. Apart from the-,e, there has come into being a new State, namely, that of Cz(•cho slovakia, where a novel experiment jg being carried on. The Government of the country as a whole is not on federal basis, but in the province of Ruthenia, the people who were afraid of oppression have been granted a com pletely autonomous Government with which the Central Government has promised never to interfere. The Mus salmans can have no objection to such an arrangement provided that the Hindus would agree. The five Mus)im provinces may then constitute a part of India on a federa'I basis, with the Hindu provinces under a strong Central Government. In that case also, the Muslims will willing. ly undertake, on behalf of the representatives of the Muslim provinces, not to interfere in those affairs of other provinces, in respect of which their provinces enjoy full autonomous powers, just as the Ruthenians under took not to vote in the Central Parliament in those affair� of other provinces, in respect of which the Central Gov. ernment did not interfere with their own Government. ( The Czechoslovakian Government, however, inspite of this undertaking, later on, very generously gave to the Ruthenians, the right to have a say in all affairs of the Central Government ).
Though it is hardly the place to discuss the form of federation that might be successfully established in India, yet, since it is possible that the present proposals will be criticised on the ground of absence of such a discus sion, I consider it necessary to say that in view of the special circumstances of India, the form of Government obtaining in the United States of America would be the one best suited to our country. The United States are similar to India, in vastness of size and diversity of races and religions of its population. It may, however, be pro vided that no province shall have the right to secede from the federation. Also, it may not be necessary, that in the casfl of India, exactly the same powers should be granted to the Central Government as is the case in the United States. Larger powers may be granted in the case of India. Only, it has to be seen that the powers of the provincial Governments regarding internal admin istration suffer no demunition.
I believe, I have successfully proved that the ques tion of federation is a question of life and death for the Indian Muslims. I have also made it abundantly clear that in a federal form of government �or India, the Hindus will have nothing to lose, and that from a political point of view, there is no harm in accepting such a form of Government. I would now conclude this chapter with this warning to the Moslems that they should bear in mind that of all their demands, this one for a federal government is the most vital. If they secure this, they will have nothing to fear even if their other demands fail to meet with acceptance. But if they fail to secure full acceptance of this demand, their lot is full of misery, God help them.
Demand for' Three New Muslim Provinces.
{t,HE second demand of the Muslims relates to the
formation of three new Muslim provinces, firstly. by extension of the Refo1ms to the N. W. F. Provinces and Baluchistan, and secondly, by the constitution of Sindh into a separate independent province.
The Nehru Committee recommends extension of the Reforms to the N. W. F. Provinces. Its references to Baluchistan, however, are aJnbiguous. From some parts of the Report, it appears that the province has been re commended for a separate Government, while elsewhere, where the question of representation has been dis cussed, no mention has been made of Baluchistan. Whether the omission was unintentional or intentional cannot be ascertained. To forget to mention a whole province is indeed strange on the pa1 t of a committee that sat specially to decide grave political issues.