Text

The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 20

In the matter of Sindh, the Nehru-Report lays down that it shall be constituted into a separate province pro vided, (i) that its financial condition is such as to enable the province to undertake its burden, or the people under take to bear the financial charges cons!dered adequate by the Nehru Committee, (ii) that no new difficulty arises which may be found insurmountable, and (iii) that they also hint ( though they have tried to conceal it ), that the con stitution of Sindh into a separate province does not neces sarily mean that it shall be a fully independent province. They write :-· • We might add that the separation of an area and the formation of a new province does not neces-· sarily imply a separate economic life. Nor does it mean a duplication of all the organs of government. For in stance it is quite possible for one High Court to serve more than one province." ( Nehru-Report, p. 68.)

As a result of the acceptance of the Muslim demand, the Punjab, Bengal, Sindh, Baluchistan and the N. W. F. Provinces shall form five separate independent provinces. But according to the Nehru-Report, as I will explain later on, the Muslim element at least in Bengal shall be weakened ; the N. W. F. Provinces shall get complete in dependence ; regarding Baluchistan the committee is silent, while the independence of Sindh is doubtful, in asmuch as the conditions laid down are such that, I have reasons to suspect that Sindh shall never be made indP pendent, and if it :is at all separated. its independence will be merely nominal.

,In the first place, the fear of ·' some instrumount able difficulties.'· expressed by the committee is in itself a hint to the Hindu agitators to keep quiet for the pr� sent inasmuch as the matter lies in the hands of their own kith and kin, who would be able in future to create any amount of " difficulties."

I do not understand this fear of '' insurmountable difficulties '· in connection with the separation of Sindh, whereas they do not apprehend any such .. difficulties " with regard to the separation of Karnatic. And, in fact, throughout their recommendation for future government in India they have nowhere else used such expression. Its use in this particular occasion is, therefore, a clear anticipation of formidable Hindu opposition to the Muslim demand.

An argument of the same type is ebodied in the

suggestion that, Sindh could be separated provided the country's financial condition permitted such a change, or the people undertook to bear the burden. Here is another obstacle. For, it is possible that the financial commission deputed to make enquiries might decide that the province is utterly unfit financially for a separate Government. And, if the people volunteered to bear the responsibility, a costly form of Government might be proposed, which it would be beyond their means to carry on. In fact, the Commissioners have already turned down their joint Hindu-Muslim prayer " to cut their coat according to their cloth." ( Ibid. p. 69.)

From the above, it is clear that every effort will be made to prevent separation of Sindh, and these assur ances are a mere eye�wash. Let me not be accused of undue suspicion. As it is not a private affair, but a national settlement, it is of paramount importance to scan and consider every word and phrase. One, who does not do so, is a traitor to his people. Turkey, Arabia, Persia and Egypt have suffered serious losses through their sheer folly of not scrutinising the terms of pacts, and treaties, and it will be really unfortunate if lessons of the past were lost on the Muslims.

The third point, to which the committee has hinted at, is that it is not necessary to grant full autonomy to Sindh ; for autonomy does not necessarily imply a separate economic life, nor does it mean a duplication of all the organs of Government. II fail to understand how a pro vince, without fiscal autonomy, can be called independ ent, while the very object of autonomous Governments is the attainment of economic and civic freedom,-poli tical freedom being only a means to the end. As without the latter, there is neither economic nor civic freedom, peoplo naturally agitate for their political emancipation. To make a province economically dependent on another province means that there is no real autonomy for it.

From what the committee has said about Sindh, it pains me to find that, the provnice would be refused independence on the ground of .financial incapacity, but if the people undertake to bear the burden, then such an unweidly machinery of administration would be recom mended that it might not be possible for them to carry on; and when, as a consequence, the people of Sindh would be despaired of an autonomous Government, they would be offered as an alternative the form of Govern.. ment contemplated in the passage :-'' We might add that the separation of an area and the formation of a new province does not necessarily imply a separate economic life. Nor does it mean a duplication of al1 the organs of Government. For instance, it is qu·te pos sible for one High Court to serve more than one pro vince." ( Ibid. p. 68.) It is clear that� a disappointed people with little hope of getting the ,vhole, will be glad to strike a bargain ; and as a result, Sindh will be left with a sort of semi-independent Government.

I have already pointed out that the Nehru Com mittee has left a door open to reduce the Muslim majority in Bengal into a minority. The following quotation from thei..t Report makes my contention clearer :-

" Our colleague, Mr. Subhas Chandra Bose, is how ever satisfied that the Oriya speaking areas should be amalgamated and constituted into a separate province, if this is financially possible. He is further of opinion that the demand for the amalgamation of the Bengali speaking tracts in Assam, and Behar and Orissa is a , reasonable and legitimate one." ( Ibid. p. 63 & 64.)

The committee has, very cleverly, avoided entering into a discussion of the de�and, urged by Mr. Subhas

Chandra Bose; obviously, it was afraid of provoking pub lic prot�sts. But by urging this view, they have simply left the door open for further developments. In the Report they observe that the redistribution of provinces should be made on • • linguistic consideration '' and according to the wishes of the majority of the people." They have also agreed that the language of these people is Bengali, and also that they desire an amalgamation with Bengal. When we read the above with the opinion of the committee, '' that their must be a redistribution of provinces,'' we may clearly perceive this underlying intention to bring about such a change in Bengal, that would strengthen the Hindu element as against the Muslim population.

This observation of the Report does not exclude even the Punjab. And whether or not, such idea was in the minds of the compilers of the Report, the fact is that a movement in the direction is now already afoot. The Punjab national party has already endorsed this view of the Nehru Committee with the proviso that the western districts should be annexed to the N. W. F. Provinces, and the Meerut division should be annexed to the Punjab. In other words, the nationalist party agrees to the pro posal of the Nehru�Report on condition that the Muslim majority in the Punjab should be smashed, and replaced by a Hindu majority. One cannot say if this movement is going to make a headway. At any rate, it has already entered the sphere of practical politics, and if the central Hindu majority feels disposed to effect such a redistribu tion, there is hardly anything to prevent it fro� doing so.

It thus comes to this that where the Muslims had pressed for the formation of five independent Muslin1 provinces, such as, the Punjab, Bengal. Sindh, Baluchis .. tan, and the N. W. F. Provinces, the Nehru-Report pro- poses to make Sindh a semi-independent province ; and indicates its intention of converting the Bengal Muslim majority into a Hindu majority which, according to its own dictum, cannot be rejected. Further in the Punjab there has already been started a movement which, it is not in the power of the Muslims, to check. Thus, what the Report gives to the Mussalmans is, in short, a semi independent Sindh, a Hindu Bengal, and a Hindu Punjab. There remains the question of the N. W. F. Provinces. and Baluchistan. The case of the latter has been left ambiguous. Even if it is granted independence, th-e Muslims shall have only two minor provinces, viz., the N. W. F. Provinces, and Baluchistan, which would only serve as a route for a most pathetic retreat reminding the Muslims that, as a punishment for their blindly throw ing away what God had given them, they should now withdraw themselves by the same way through which they came.

·

10 of 10 left today