Text
The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 3
The Nehru Scheme proposes two Houses of Parlia ment for India, one chamber to consist of representatives elected by the people directly and the other, the Senate, to consist, after that of the United States of America, of members representing the different Provincial Councils. Strange that the committee while upholding the principle of having two such representative bodies for the enact� ment of laws affecting transitory and minor interests, should in the matter of formulating a constitution for the country overlook the need for consulting the representa tives of the Provincial Moslem Leagues so as to give them an opportunity to present their respective view points. The All-Parties Conference could not pretend ignorance of the fact that the majority of several of the Provincial Leagues was at variance with the majority of the Central Body of the League in matters of vital im portance. How c·ould then the inclusion of the representatives of the Central Body alone be reason.. ably regarded as adequate to help to formulate the draft constitution? Take, for example, the case of any of these provinces, the Punjab, the United Province, Bengal, the
. \V. F. Prov in s or Sinclh. in each of whjch th lVlosl 1ns hold vi "W nJat ing lo th sysl<.. n1 of joint • � c to1 nte contra1y lo thos" of th,, Calcutta L agu . } low could tlu: n the (�alcnt ta L agu • b consid red, und ·r the Cll'Ctnnstnncc�, to S{"l"V<. a� th ir r pres nlative? ·r1, .\11-1 a1ties (�onf ercnct. if it ai ail 1n ant lo justify its bonafidcs, should hnv invit d all the different Provincial C'.on11uitteL'S asking th n1 in un quivoca1 t rrns to s nd not only such 1nen1bcrs as repr sented th opinions of the 1najority but as well as those, who had to urg th 1ninority vic,-v-points, so as to enable the conferenc to dispassionately arrive at some decisions after having taken a full consensus of public opinion. But the con veners of this Conference-a handful of gentle1n n pledged to proportionate representation-chose out for in vitation the few bodies already agreed to the 1-lindu vi w point, i.e .. the principles of joint representation. Of all the various associations whose na1n�s app ar on pages 20 and 21 of the Nchru-R.cport, th<1- re is not on body belonging to the oppo�itc carnp.
lt may be declared without fear of contradiction that
the quaint procedure adopted. nnn1t�ly, that of leaving severally alone an overwhchning rnajority of the Mussal n1ans, a1nply proves that the All-Parties Conference, if it at all represented any peopl'=', represented only that section of the population which was in favour of joint electorate system.
T'he All-Muslim Parties Conference, held last year at Simla-a fact conveniently glossed over by the Nehru Comrnittee,-throws additional side-light on this important issue. That committee preferred to take notice only of the Muslim Leaders' Conference held at Delhi, as a result of which the memorable Delhi proposals accepting joint electorates subject to certain reservations, were tentative ly formulated. But it very conveniently omitted to refer to what transpired at Simla where the Muslim Leaders called an All�lndia Muslim Conference to place the Delhi proposals before the community. The facts, however. were that when the D·elhi proposals, that accepted the joint electorate subject to certain reservations, provoked a good deal of adverse criticism in the country, our leaders realised that the bulk of the Moslem opinion was against such overtures. About this time was held a meeting of the Hindu Mahasabha at Nagpur, and 1\/Ir. Kelkar as President delivered a speech so bitterly hostile to Muslim demands that it made many of the l\1uslim leaders realise their mistake. Thereupon the IVloslem League convened, in September, 1927, at Simla, a meet ing of the representatives of all the I\tluslim Parties, whether members of the League or not. ,I too received an invitation and although, as a rule, I keep aloof from such gatherings, but happening at this instance to be on the spot in connection with the Anti--Blasphemy Bill. I attended the conference. From what I gathered from the discussions that ranged for full two days in support of the separate electorate, I can safely say that if votes were taken, a clear majority of 70 per cent. would have carried the day in favour of communal representation. Of those, favouring the joint electorate system, most agreed that although their personal inclinations were for it, their community, no doubtt stood solidly for the other system. All Mr. Jinnah" s efforts failed to persuade the representatives of different pro.. vinces and associations to abandon the system of separate representation. Mr. Jinnah (who was the president of the meeting·) at last declined to put the matter to vote saying that the assembly was no regular association, but he as sured the members that though personally he was in favour of joint representation, he was now fully aware that his community viewed the matter quite differently, and that when the time to arrive at a settlement with the Hindus comes, he would not omit to present to them the majority view. The scene was not without its moral.
This conference, which was composed of people re presenting all shades of thought, sat to deliberate upon the Delhi proposals which were, by far the least objec tionable, and the nearest as a compromise, to the general Muslim opinion, as compared to the Madras Congres� re solutions or the Nehru-Report, both of which came into being much later ; and yet a powerful majority of the representatives of different Muslim bodies would have nothing to do with them. Nay, even from among the authors of the proposals persons like Sir l\1uhammad Shafi turned to discountenance them. It may now be pertinently asked that when it had become evident that a clear majority of the Muslim community disfavoured the sys�em of joint representation, why the All-Parties Conference chose to shut them out of its deliberations? If it failed to invite them, its pretensions to represent all shades of opinion held no ground. And if it invited them and its invitation evoked no response, then it was evident that the major sections of an important Indian community had no confidence in the conference and would not care even to attend its sitting. No sane person would, under the circumstances, consider this All-Parties Con ference to be the representative of All-India.
But from the facts, quoted above from the Nehru Report, it would appear that the All-Parties Con ference did not properly represent even that section of the Muslim opinion which found utterance in the Calcutta
Muslim League ; for this Report has confessed that the Calcutta League had issued instructions to its members that unless its resolutions had been first accepted, they were not to join the Committee's deliberations. The question arises, did the Calcutta League ever revoke this decision? From the Report it does not appear that it ever did. Does it not follow then that the Leaguers served on the sub-committee, formed in pursuance of the Bombay Conference Resolution, not in conformity to but in defiance of the same instructions, which laid strong emphasis on an unqualified acceptance of the Calcutta Resolutions by the Nehru Committee, as a condition pre cedent to their participation in any deliberation connected with the constitutional question?
No meeting of the League was held to reverse the decision during or after the Bombay Conference. How could then the members of the League go out of their way and act contrary to their explicit instructions? Here again the question arises,-did the Nehru Committee fully accept the Calcutta League proposals? They have themselves admitted that they did not ( vide the Nehru Report, p. 25 ). The Muslim delegates also admit the same. How could then the representatives of the League in justice to the League's decision, sit and work conjointly ,vith the committee? And if inspite of the League's inscruction3 they did not withdraw from the Nehru Committee after it had given its verdict against the Calcutta proposals they had ipso /acto ceased to be delegates of the League. The inference is clear that the Nehru Committee did not represent even that section of the League which is under the presidency of Mr. Jinnah, and hence it remained all the more unrepresented by the Muslims. And this is perhaps what led lv1essrs. Muhammad Y akub, Shaukat Ali, Hasrat Mohani, Shafi
Daudi, and so many other prominent Muslim leaders and Khilafatists to oppose the Nehru Committee.
The reason, why I choose to dwell on the point in detail, is because I feel pained to see millions of Indians being driven in this matter like so many dum� cat �le_ A handf, ll of people assembles here or there and publishes their decisions in glaring headlines as the pro nouncements of the Leaders of the Nation. No one steps out and raises his little finger in protest and asks '' \v'h0 made you our leaders?'' Perhaps nowhere under the sun are the people at large treated with so much humi liation, indignity and contempt. It is assumed that the country is the property of a noisy few, at liberty to deal with it as they like to do. My as·:onishment knew no bounds when at the last Unity Conference I noticed soree of the gentlemen assembled there, actually upbraiding the rest for their not showing due regard to the:r leaders meaning their own worthy-selves. Several times I felt impelled to ask, '� Well sir, who made those gentlemen the leaders of the rest? '' But the dictates of propriety restrained me. I, however, did avail myself of the occa sion and delivered in Simla a lecture on the subject and drew attention to the deplorable conditions obtaining in our country. These attributed not to a lack of leaders but to a dearth of fol1owers. I said that in our country every body who dabbles in politics, assumes the role of a leader, whether or not, there is a fallowing to be counted upon. Prior to this on the occasion of the arrival of the Simon Commission, I had suggested the formation of Moslem Associations in every town and village, com prising of members of every shade of opinion, in order to serve as media for the ventilation of collective views and Prevent the noisy few from passing off their own views as the public opinion of the Mussalmans. •
But to revert to the subject, I once again challenge the pretensions both of the All-Parties Conference and of the Nehru Committee, and assert that neither the forrner was the representative of All-India Muslim public nor the latter of any section of it. The first was a conference of men of a particular shade of opinion and it appointed a committee from which Moslem representatives were practically excluded. lt was this committee which published a report which now passes by the name of an All-India Committee Report. It may, however, be urged
mittee or both were representative bodies or not, and that what it really matters is the report itself. If the report pays due regard to the legitimate rights of all com munities, there is no reason why it should be rejected. Cer tainly not. I would gladly accept it if it would answer that description. But before entering into a consideration of the merits of the Report I cannot help saying that the mutual distrust, which has been the main cause of the present Hindu-Muslim tension, is not likely to abate and would rather be aggravated at the thought that while, in framing a constitution for the country, no regard has been paid to the question of Moslem representation, what chance is there of Moslem feelings be�ng respected, when local laws will come to be enacted in future.
Now as the report is before us, let us proceed to examine both its merits and its demerits. Its perusal, however, I am grieved to confess, leaves me sorely dis appointed. I am led to the conclusion that the scheme, expounded by the committee, cannot be of any b,�nefi.t to the country. At any rate, it spells disaster for the Mussalmans.
Demands of the Lahc're Muslim League.
_6EFORE discussing the proposals made in the Nehru--
Report I propose to deal' with the demands of the Muslim community-what these are and why they are made. I have already stated that there are from the politi cal point of view two parties among the Muslims. Of these two groups, the party consisting mostly of the Punjab and U. P. Muslims holds, as their fundamental demands, that, in framing a future constitution for India. the following essentials must be kept in view :-