Text
The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 21
Having explained the difference between the Nehru Committee proposals and the Muslim demand, I now pro ceed to discuss whether the Muslim demand is at all a reasonable one. It is admitted on all hands, that people, with a distinctive religion and culture, should be afforded opportunities for free and unrestricted progress and de.. velopment, or else, the door is opened for disorder and troubles, and peace becomes impossible. In Europe, wherever there is a diversity of tongue and culture, separate territories have been formed aflording the people opportunities for free national development. I have already cited the instance of Czechoslovakia, where, the Rothunians have been allowed to enjoy autonomy in their internal affairs. The component states of the United
States of America are running on the same lines. They began as separate entities with different cultures and religions. It was, therefore, thought wiser to leave them alone than to break them up in order to build a united Government. The Muslim demand is, therefore, quite reasonable, and arises for the necessity of keeping alive their distinctive culture and national traditions, and of saving their national spirit from extinction. The same necessity, which impels India to seek emancipation from British influence, also impels the Muslim to seek at least partial independence in those provinces where they pre ponderate. If this need is an artificial one in the case of the Muslims, !he same is true in the case of India. But I do not intend to enter here into a detailed discus sion of this question. I propose to do so in the chapter dealing with reservation of seats, where an almost similar line of argument has been taken.
Now the only question, that remains to be considered, is the justice of the demand. To me the claim appears to be just and proper both as a matter of right, and also from the political point of view. As a matter of right, because the demand involves no infringement of others' rights. In withholding representative Government from the N. W. F. Provinces there is, on the contrary, a denial of the rights of the people of that province. As regards Sindh, the Nehru-Report itself has admitted ( 1) that the province has a separate language, (2) that its connection with Bombay is artificial, (3) that the distance from Bom bay is too great, (4) that its separation will infringe no body's rights, and (5) that in the event of its not being granted a separate Government, a great injustice will be done to its people. As regards Baluchistan, it is already a separate province, and as such there is no dang<;r t,., any co�munity in the event of representative (�ovcrnrnent being granted to it.
It is groundless to hold that the interest of the 1-findua would suffer at the hands of the Muslim majority if Sindh be made a separate independent province. If not, the same objection can be raised in respect of the Muslim minorjti<.;s
in Bombay, Madras, the United Provinces, and Behar,
where they are actually in a greater danger. For even under a federal system, the Central Government shall c<:,r tainly wield an enormous influence, and here the Hindu elements are bound to preponderate. The second objection that Bombay having spent a large amount of money in Sindh, the latter province cannot claim a separate Gov ernment. This is also untenable. It is just like the plea of those Englishmen who argue that India cannot be granted self-government as the English traders and capi talists have sunk a vast capital in the country. Had the expenditure upon Sindh been so lar�e, the Hindus of Bombay would have been foremost to demand the separa tion of Sindh. They are, on the other hand, mo8t . anxious to keep the province as a dependency. That clearly goes to shovv that the money apparently spent in Sindh is bringing in a rich harvest. The fact that Sindh could not grow in prosperity with a port like Karachi leads one to suspect that Bombay was thriving at the expense of Sindh, and so in order to maintain its pros perity jealously stood on the way to the development of Karachi. In short, if Bombay has spent directly one rupee on Sindh it has had indirectly two rupees back from that province, and here 1ies the secret of the anxiety of Bombay to keep the province under its heels. Both
the objections are, therefore, groundlc·�s, and nobody's
rights wiJI be infringed if Sindh is constituted into a separate province.
Let us now consider the political aspect of the ques tion. It would be bad politics to keep the two provinces in their present state of bondage, and real statesmanship would be to grant them independence. If the claims of Sindh be ignored, a fierce storm of agitation may well be apprehended. This has been admitted by the Nehru Report also.
And in the event of the N. W. F. Provinces and Balu chistan being denied a representative form of Govern ment, both the provinces, being situated on the border, are likely to become hot beds of foreign intrigues. A sound policy, therefore, lies in keeping the bordering pro vinces thoroughly satisfied. Otherwise such provinces afford fertile grounds for enemy's activities, and in con sequence, the country is divided against itself, thus weakening the Government. Bordering provinces kept in
tached to India ; and it is not improbable that they might join hands with other powers to secure their freedom. Evidently, therefore, it will be bad politics to deny auto nomy to the N. W. F. Provinces and Baluchistan. Such action will not only pave the way for a civil war in India, but will serve to plant in India advance ports of foreign powers.
II think I have conclusively proved that the demand for three new Muslim provinces is just, and no body stands to lose if the same is satisfied, al)d that from a political point of view also its advisability is unquestion able. The rejection of so reasonable a demand shows that the Nehru-Report is a product of communal bias. So long as the majority continues to be so prejudiced, it rannot inspire the minority with any degree of confidence.
c: I I A P T E R IX.
Reservation of Seats on Population Basis.
U, HE third demand of the Mussa1mans relates to the
right of representation in proportion to the numerical strength of each community, except :n the case of very small minorities, who Rhould be granted representation somewhat over and above their dues. This concession. if allowed, should be reciprocal, i.e., the Hindus in predominantly Muslim provinces should be granted the same concessions as the Muslims in predominantly Hindu
provinces.
In other words, this demand se ks to secure to every important community the right of representation accord ing to its numerical !Jtrength, so that one community may not deprive the other of its legitimate rights through underhand tactics.
The Nehru Committee holds it as politically un sound that the rights of any com1nunity should be de finitely fixed. The most that could be done, in their opinion, was to fix the proportionate rights of very smaH minorities. But it rlisapproves of the suggestion of giving to any community more than its due share of representation.