Text

The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 22

It must be clearly understood that protection of rights in roatters connected with elections is effected by the reservation of seats ; that is, it is definitely laid down that a certain percentage of the total number of members must go to a certain community, and constituencies are also assigned where no one other than a member of the same community could stand as a candidate for election.

Fixing of rights, in ()ther words, means assignment of

constituencies for each community from which none but a member of the same community could stand as a candidate for election.

Thus according to the Nehru-Report, the minontles, in provinces other than the Punjab and Bengal, may have seats reserved in proportion to their numerical strength, if they so desire. According to this rule, there is to be open competition between the Hindus and the Muslims over the seats in the Punjab and Bengal, without any restric tion whatsoever. If the N. W. F. Provinces, Baluchistan and Sindh are formed into separate provinces, then in these provinces, the Hindus shall have the option to have seats reserved for· themselves on population basis. and to fight for additonal seats "�ith the Muslims. In other pro vinces the Muslims also shall enjoy similar rights.

lln other words, according to the above recommenda tion, not only the demands urged by the Muslim League have been left unsatisfied, but even their present rights

had demanded safeguards for what the Muslims were already enjoying, and for additional seats the League demanded that the Muslims should be left free to fight it out with the Hindus ; the same .::oncess1ons to be granted to the Hindus in provinces where Muslims form an over whelming majority. But the Nehru Committee would give to the Mussalrnans only such representation as they are entitled to on the population basis. The result is that in the United Provinces, the Muslims are occupying at present 30% of the seats in the Council, but according to the Nehru-Report, theh representation shall be reduced to 15 % with the right to win additional seats in open contest, if they so choose. Similarly in Behar, Madras, Assam and Bombay, the Muslims form less than 10, 6t

21, and 20�� respectively of the population but they

occupy 20, 12, 30, and about 33 % of the seats respectiv�ly in the Councils. The community will have in future their n1embership reduced to the population ratios. In short, according to the recommendations of the Nehru Com.. mittec Muslim representation in the different provinces shall be reduced by one..half to one-third of its existing number ; and in exchange of this loss, the Muslims in these provinces and in the Punjab and Bengal will be given the right to contest for additional seats in the respective Councils.

The above apportionment reminds me of the story of that prudent Raja who, as the legend goes, was pleased to make a gift to his priest of a cow that had been lost a year before. The Raja's son who excelled his father in caution, suggested that the priest should be given the

lost a year ago.

The Lucknow Pact had aimed at throttling the very life out of the Muslim nction, the Nehru-Report was pro ceeded to skin the poor community altogether.

I fail to understand i.he reason why the Muslim sup porters of this Report have taken up that attitude, when they can easily see that they have been deprived of something real ; and what they have been promised in return, is a mere shado\v. In the eight Hindu provinces. Muslim representation has been reduced by nearly one half; that is, of the aggregate 24% of Muslim representa tion in all the Hindu provinces, their share has been re duced to 14 % only. It has been argued in this connec tion that the right given to the l\lluslims to contest seats other than those reserved for them has opened a new avenue of progress for them where they can successfully beat their Hindu rivals The �rgument is the outcome either of sheer ignorance, or of lack of commonsense, or of knowledge of past history.

The Nehru-Report itself falsifies the principle ex pounded by it. It has been urged, as already men�ioned, that it is advantageous for the Muslims to abandon the system of reservation of seats because in this they, in consequence of open contest, would be in a position to wrest more seats than they could claim on population basis. The Nehru Committee considers it to be a sound argument and thinks that it has been generous to the Muslim, inasmuch as it has opened to them new avenues of progress by conferring on them the right to contest seats with the Hindus. ( Vide the Nehru-Report, p. 52). It is, however, strange that in the same breath the com mittee agree that there is a possibility of the minorities being totally deprived of their rights. The Committee say :-'' After the resolution of the informal conference referred to above was passed it was pointed out to us that it would work great hardship on the lv1us1im minority who in all probability be able to elect no more than 30 or 40 Muslims from the Punjab and Bengal, and perhaps one or two from the U. P., and Behar, to the central legislature of 500 members, and that there was little chance of any of the other provinces with less than 7 per cent. of the population returning a single Muslim. The re sult, it was argued, would be that the MusEms, who form nearly one-fourth of the total population of British India, would have no more than one-tenth of representation in the central legislature. The same reasoning, it was urged, applied to the legislatures of the provinces where the Moslems • are in small minorities. We recognise the if so lt.sirt d l y tlu ru, in p1op<HI ion to their population

l Icr is the evidenct· of n HC"port that has bt•( n 1n<ld so 1nuch of. It admilH that n tninority' s position is by no means st'curc under a joint cl( clor-ale syst 1n. Nay, it goes further. and aclinits tht\l th 'r • is th • possibility of the Muslims of Madras, Bornbny, Burn1a, and Central Provine s not being c.blc to return cvt n one candidat ; and of th . Musli1ns of the lJ J>. and B har, wh r th y should 1 ct about 22 represental ivc s, they n1ay b • able to return only two or thrc� 111< rnhc rs.

I do not here 1n an to discuss th rn rits or clen1 rits of the joint electorate sy�te1n. What I nn1 trying lo dis cover is whether the Mussalmnns, according to th reco1n mendations of the Nehru Co1nmitt e, have secured the proportion of r<: presentation they want d, or, at any rate, wheth r they have b t!n R8S\ll'cd of maintaining their present position. I inte11d to show on the basis of the Report itself that it is altog ·th r out of th qu stion for the Muslirns to xp ct nn incr ased repr s ntation. On the contrary, the MuslirnR cannot hope to rnaintain even their present proportion of r pres ntation.

To understand the matter clearly it must be borne in mind that, at present Muslim representation in the Legislative Assembly is 29 per cent., and in the future Parliament the Nehru Committee propose an aggregate number of 500 seats, of which, the Mussalmans would get 125 only on population basis, while in proportion to their present represent�tion they are entitled to 150 seats. According to the original demand of the Calcutta League, Muslims would have received one-third of the total seats, that is 166 seats. No,v I propose to show the proportion of representation the Muslims would command under the Nehru scheme.

The Nehru-Report admits that the Muslim of Bengal and the Punjab would be able to return from thirty to forty members to the Central Legislature. Let us grant that the Muslims would be singularly fortunate in elect ing what the Report considers to be a maximum number of members for the Punjab and Bengal, i.e., forty. Let us also grant that the Muslims in Sindh, N. W. F. Pro vinces, and Baluchistan would be able to return the full proportion of members even in the face of Hindu opposi tion. The total population of these three provinces amounts to 61 ,26,000, of which only 5% are Hindus. The Muslim population of 58,22,000 will be entitled to eleven seats only. In the U. P., Behar, Assam, Madras, Central Province, and Bombay (excluding Sindh), the Muslims are 71, 35, 15, 25, 5 and 12 lacs respectively. In Burma the actual figure of the present Muslim population is not before me, but judging from the census of 190 I when it was 3 lacs and 46 thousand we may reckon it at 5 lacs at ffl'C!>st. These figures make an aggregate of 1 crore and 68 lacs, on the strength of which the Muslims would be entitled to 33 seats; thus giving them a total number of 84. seats. Add to the above calculation- the Muslim population of the Anda1nans, Coorg, Aj1neer-Marawar, The total is not likely to exce�d 1,75,00,000 giving an additional number of two seats only, which rneuns an aggregate of 86 seats. These figures eloquently speak for themselves. The Muslim League had demanded 166 seats. Under the present Government system, the Muslims are already in possession of 150 seats. And on population basis they are entitled to J 25 seats. Und,.:r the Nehru Scheme it is estimated that their share would be reduced to 86 seats only. The Mussalmans may wel1 ponder over these figures.

It must be remembered that the Nehru-Report has

been prepared by those Hindus who are straining every nerve to win over the Mussalmans. When their own estimate of our future position j� so hopeless, :t is useless to argue further. It is vain to contend that the Muslin1s in those provinces where they are in minority will be able to win more seats than they are entitled to by their number. The Nehru Committee at any rate do not agree to this view. It says :-· • There was little chance of any of the other provinces with less than 7 per cent. of the population, (meaning-Bombay, Madras, the C. P., Burma, etc.), returning a single l\lluslim • • to the Central Parliament. ( Ibid. p. 51 ). In the U. P. and Behar, the co1nmittee was of opinion that the Muslin1s n1ight succeed in securing one or two seats.

·

10 of 10 left today