Text
The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 23
Now does it stand to reas::>n that the Muslims in Bombay, Madras, Burma, and Central Provinces, having little chance of returning even one Muslim candidate from their respective constituencies by their cornbined voting strength in an open election, will under a system of reservation be able to wrest from the Hindus seats in addition to those reserved for them with the help of their residual votes? For, it is evident that in these provinces, reserved seats wi11 be allotted to the Muslims in those areas only, where they are most numerous, and the . greater part of their voting strength would thus be spent in returning candidates from those reserved constituen cies. In the remaining parts of the province there will be left at the most only ten to fifteen per cent. of the total Muslim votes available fo: participation in open election. No sensible man can believe that where the ,. Muslims with their full voting strength could not return even their legitimate proportion of candidates, they would be able with their residual votes to win seat5; from the Hindus who would number 93 °,� of the population.
It is thus clear, that according to the ·ehru-Reportp in those provinces where the Muslims happen to be in a minority, they will never be able to win seats more than their share on the basis of population. With regard to the Punjab and Bengal, the Report itself states that the Muslims wil1 be able to return 30 to 40 candidates only, whereas on a population basis they would be en titled to 74 candidates. In a word, even according to the Nehru-Report there can be no safeguarding of
Muslim rights without reservation of seats ; and no poli
tical school in the world would justify that eighty million of human beings should be deprived of their legitimate rights.
Second Argument.
The second argument in favour of reservation \)f seats is that in India the division of the population into major and minor communities has, unlike Europe, its basis in religious diversity, whi1e in the West the parties have their origin in political differences and are, therefore, subject to constant changes. In the Indian groups, changes are Jess frequent. It thus happens that when one group comes to power, its rule may continue in definitely, and there is the fear that it may during its long regime injure the interests of the rival community. , For example, the party in power might show in the census a decrease in the strtngth of its rival, as is done in Europe, where a political group on capturing the Govern mental offices resorts to tactics such as recording a de crease in population against the vanquished group, or framing such electoral rules as might tend to benefit 1t at the expenses of the rival group. In order to protect the weaker parties against such tac6cs, it is necessary to have reservation of seats so as to remove mutual susp1c1on. For, it is obvious that so long as mutual dis trust prevails among the various groups, there can be no peace in 'India. Thus the system of reservation of seats is conducive, and not inimical to peace. When the Muslims apprehend that their interests are in danger, there is no reason why their seats should not be reserved even in the Punjab and Bengal. It is after all their legi timate share that they demand, and nothing more. To refuse to give them their right is to strengthen their sus p1c1on that there is something more behind, and that the Hindu compatriots do not mean well by them.
It should be borne in mind in this connection that the Nehru-Report has admitted that under a jo:nt electorate system communities are liable to suffer in their interests, and it has cited the instance of England, where the con servatives with comparatively fewer votes defeated the Labour Party that had commanded a large number of votes. The same applies to the Muslims. They have only two provinces where they enjoy a bare majority. They would be confronted with a real danger if the party with fewer votes should come off victorious over the party with larger votes.
Third Argument.
Of the eight major provinces in India, six are pre dominantly Hindu ill population, culture and custom. The Hindu preponderance is so formidable in these provinces that there is absolutely no chance for the Muslims ever to come into power. Only in two provinces, the Muslims command a majority. But the majority is not so large as to warrant a perpetual Muslim domination, and con tinual progress on the lines of their national traditions. The Mussalmans, therefore, very legitimately desire that they should have opportunities at least in these two pro vinces to progress according to their own traditions ; and the only way to this lies in the reservation of seats.
No doubt, in the absence of a reservation of seats, it is possible for a community to gain more than its legi timate proportion of seats, but it is equally possible that it may not gain even its legitimate proportion. The danger is all the more real, when the margin of difference between the two communities is so small and the minority is so strong, as is the case in the Punjab and Bengal. The Nehru-Report itself has admitted the danger of the Punjab Muslims losing their majority position. It says: ·' The Muslims being in a minority in India as a whole fear that the majority may harass them, and to meet this difficulty they have made a novel suggestion-that they should at least dominate in some parts of India. We do not here criticise their demand. It may have some justification in the present comrnunal atmosphere but we do feel that it has little to do with the prem�ses we started from, unless indeed the best safeguard that one can have is to occupy a position of domination oneself.'' ( Nehru
Report, p. 28-29.) The Muslims contend that as they
have only these two provinces where they are in a majority, they cannot afford to run the risk of their majority being converted into • • a strong minority just short of a majority." The Nehru-Report too makes a
reference to this demand of the Muslims. It says:-•· In any event they,'' ( meaning-the Punjab Muslims), •• will capture enough seats to make the;m if not a clear majority at least a strong rninority just short of a majority." ( Ibid. p. 35.)
The Nehru Committee objects to the demand on the ground that it amounts to an admission that it is impos sible to safeguard the rights of the minorities without letting them occupy a position of domination, and that such a proposition is unjust on the very face of it. The committee, therefore, sum;marily dismisses the 1\,Iuslim de mand as an unjust one. So far as I can understand. the committee have put an interpretation on the Musl�m demand that at least the intelligent section of the fVIuslim public has never had this in its mind. I remember having heard, on the occasion of the last Unity Conference at Simla, one Hindu delegate (he was addressed as doctor, and if I am not mistaken, it was Dr. Nandlal, Bar-at-law) deprecating the Muslim proposal on the ground that it did not appeal to him that when a Hindu in the Central Province struck a Muslim, a Muslim in the Punjab should in retaliation strike a Hindu. No Muslim, I believe, had understood the demand in that way. In offences of a national character the whole of the community, to which the culprits belong. is treated as the offender, but it is neither reasonable nor justified to inflict indiscriminate punishment or to retaliate as has been suggested. But I ask the Hindus what would they answer to the Muslims, if they should make to them the following proposals at a time when the country's fate is going to be decided :- • • You aspire after the freedom of India and so do we. You are fully aware of the fact that you cannot do without us. You also know that from a fair]y long time our mutual relations are strained. We have a grievance that in every branch of life our rights have been disregarded. Why not try this remedy? India is a large sub-continent with such a diversity in tongues that in some cases the difference is much wider than between those of two in dependent states of Europe. !In certain provinces the Hindus happen to preponderate, and in some the Mus lims. Let us agree that in a province where a certain community preponderates it should be allowed to have the larger share in the Government. That would restore mutual confidence. Each community would feel inclined to reciprocate the trust placed on it by the other. And as a consequence all would peacefully co-operate towards promoting the weal of the country.''
There is nothing unjust or unwise in such a sugges tion. Why should it at all be interpreted to imply a threat that if a Hindu in the C. P. were to beat a Muslim in his province, a brother Hindu shall suffer punishment in the Punjab or vice versa, and justice would thus be maintained-through fear of retaliation. The demand has, in fact, its origin in the suspicion in the Muslim mind that the Hindus attempt to keep the Muslims under sub jection everywhere, and in places where he cannot reason ably do so, to invent such device as would afford him opportunities to come into power. This naturally sets the Muslim athinking that when India is going to be parti tioned into provinces, why are the Muslim� denied the opportunity for untrammelled progress :n those provinces, where they form the majority of the population. He sus pects some ulterior motive behind this denial, and whether his suspicion is right or wrong, nonetheless it stands in the way of mutual understanding.
�t cannot be urged in this connection that the avenues of progress for minor communities have been left open not in the Muslim provinces alone, but that in every province there is scope for any minority to rule the the majority. In reply I may well ask whether there is any major province, except the Punjab and Bengal, where it may be reasonably expected that the majority and the minority communities would alternately come into power. If there is none, there is hardly a point of analogy. In the Punjab and Bengal, we have a minority that could manage through its superiority in wealth, education, and organisation, if not to monopolise the Government for good, at least to change places frequently with the major. ity. But in Madras and Bombay, the C. P., the U. P., Behar and Bur�a, the Muslim minority ( which nowhere exceeds 15 % of the population } is foredoomed to remain a perpetual minority with no effective voice in the Gov ernment of the country. Equity, therefore, demands thc1t seats should be reserved for the Muslims in the Punjab and Bengal, and then, they should be exhorted to trust the Hindus in other provinces in the same ,vay as they did trust them in these provinces. and to disabuse their minds of all suspicions.
The Nehru-Report has laid particular stress upon this point. It says :-' • We cannot have one community do mineering over another. We may not be able to pre vent this entirely but the object we should aim at is not to give dominion to one over another but to prevent the harassment and exploitation o-f any individual or group by another." ( Ibid. p. 29.) But the question is,-have the committee precluded the chances of class domina tion? In Madras, Behar, and other places, the committee itself feel:, apprehension that the Hindu domination will b_e of a permanent nature, as the fv1uslims in those pro,