Text
The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 24
ces
seen t at by making this concession in favour of Muslim minoritie� we are not introduc{ng the anomalies arising out of reservation for majorities. ./\ minority must remain a minority whether any seats are reserved for it or not and cannot dominate the majority.··
From the above quotation 1t 1s clear that the Nehru Committee think that in Bombay, Madras, the U. P., etc., the Mussalmans shall continue in a minority posi tion for all times to come, which in other words means that in those provinces the Hindus shall always hold the reins of Government. This is exactly what is meant by • • one- community domineer�ng over another.•· And when such domination of one community over another shall prevail in some of the provinces without causing any harm whatsoever, what reason is there that a similar situation should not be created in the Punjab and Bengal?
If the permanent preponderance of representation of a
particular community is bad, it is so everywhere ; but if it can be tolerated in Bombay and Madras, it can cer tainly be tolerated in the Punjab and Bengal as well.
It should be noted here that the Nehru Committee has itself been so much obsessed with communal senti ments that it has viewed the Muslim demands through the same communal goggles, and has in consequence committed the blunder of reading in the Muslim demand an ambition to rule in the Punjab and Bengal to the com plete exclusion of the non-Muslims. That is not the Muslim demand at all. All that they demand is that whereas in the predominantly Hindu provinces, Hindu representation on the legislative bodies would necessarily remain a permanent majority, similarly the MusEm repre sentation in the Punjab and Bengal, where they form the majority of the population, should exceed that of the other communities ; and further as the Muslim majority
1n these provinces is not so large as to be secure of its position without special safeguards, it should be so provided by law that this right of the Mussalmans might not be infringed by any other community by any means, fair or foul.
It is clear that here is no question of domination at all. Such a question could, no doubt, arise if the Muslims had demanded that the Hindus should be given the ex clusive rule in the predominantly Hindu provinces, and the Muslims in the predominantly Muslim provinces. On the contrary, the Muslims demand, that they should have a majority of representation in the predominantly Muslim provinces in the same way as the Hindus in the predomin antly Hindu provinces. A majority of representation does not necessarily signify that the reins of Government should also remain exclusively in their hands. We may see that even now under the system of separate elector ates which is so much traduced on all sides, there is no exclusively Muslim party in the Punjab Council. There is a Zemindar's party, which includes both Muslim and Hindu members. There are the Khilafatists who are hand and glove with the Swarajists. Thus in the Punjab and Bengal, it is easy for the Hindus to have a substan tial share in the Government of the country by winning to their side only 6 per cent. of the Muslims. It cannot be held that the Muslims and the Hindus will never co operate so long as representation continues on the lines of religious division. For, religion is not synonymous
with politics. Religion is related to civilisation and cul ture. People of different religions do co-operate with one another in political matters. And if such co-operation is possible under the present circum::;tances in spite of acute differences, there is no reason why it should not be possible in future. It is foolish to think that all Muslims would agree to one political creed ; and when such an agreement is not possible among them, they cannot evidently form a purely Muslim party to hold sway either in the Punjab, or in Bengal; it will of necessity have to include Hindu elements in its rank. The question of domination, therefore, does not arise at all. This fear of the Nehru Committee is thus a figment of their own imagination caused by their strong communal bias. They have attributed to the Muslims what was by no means signified by their demand. The fact is that there is a possibility,-nay, a certainly of communal domination in the predominantly Hindu provinces, where the Hindu majority is so large that, even if divided into sections, it would still succeed in setting up a Hindu class-rule. I admit that there are similar chances for the i\luslims in the N. W. F. Provinces, Sindh, etc. But these pro vinces are so small that they are not likely to influence the Indian situation to any considerable degree.
There are other cogent reasons for laying so much stress upon a �ajority representation for the 1\1uslims in the Punjab and Bengal Councils. I have already proved that in the Punjab and Bengal, the Muslims with a bare majority cannot manage to rule the country to the com plete exclusion of other communities, even if they are granted a reservation of seats. In both of these pro vinces, the parties in power are sure to include Hindu elements. In spite of thi�. there is no doubt that what ever party might be in power, the Government in these provinces, shall have a considerable proportion of the Muslims in its personnel, which no future Government of those provinces under any circumstances would be able to ignore. Having elucidated this point, let us for a moment leave the communal view-point and consider whether or not it is good for the country that the Muslims should have no voice in its administration, or that their share should be next to nothing. Every student of poli tics is well aware that a good legal code a.lone is not enough to run a good government ; a proper appl:ca tion of the same is equally necessary. It is clear that the administration of India will be divided into Provincial Governments, and while it will be necessary for the Cen tral Government to have an Executive Council, it will be similarly necessary for the Provincial Governments to confer occasionally in a Council on matters relating to general administration. According to the Nehru Com mittee it is quite possible that, in the Punjab and Bengal, all the members of Government may at one time be Hindu, and at another time Mussalmans. Now the ques tion will arise how will the Muslim view-point be repre �ented in the deliberations of the Executive Council during the Hindu regime? Of course, no body can expect that small provinces like Sindh, and the N. W. F. Provinces will be able to fulfil this need. Thus, even from a broad national view-point it is imperative to ensure the inclusion of Muslim elements in the Governments of the Punjab and Bengal by means of legi.$lation, and the only way to do so is to grant reservation of seats for the Moslems.
Fifth Argument.
The Nehru Committee also agree that different com munities have distinct cultures of their own, and are desirous of national development according to their re spective traditions, and that in spite of living together in the same land under the same political organisation, the divergence in culture may continue to exist . The
Report says : -• � The only methods of giving a feeling of security are safeguards and guarantees and the grant, as far as possible. of cultural autonomy." ( Vide p. 28.) Thus, the committee admit that different communities have different cultures, and it is not unreasonable fer them to demand guarantees for their preservation. Ac cordingly the Mussalmans, anxious as they are to restore an atmosphere of mutual confidence, demand that in addition to having a hand in the administration of the country and a proportionate representation in the pro vinces, they should have opportunities for cultural pro gres� in the Punjab and Bengal in complete accord with their past traditions. This is hardly an occasion to dis cuss how a community, when making progress, lays the foundation of its culture on a few fundamental principles, and in its tradition and development it assumes a line different from other communities. It gradually de velops into a distinct culture of its own, and guards it more jealously than even its liberty. Nations seldom fight so violently for their political interests as they do in defence of their cultures. The latter is of the nature of an abstraction, and therefore admits of no specific definition, although its existence and importance cannot be denied. Every nation, because of its religious beLefs or its environments, develops a particular mentality, which chalks out the lines of its progress. Its philosophy, civilisation, intellectual and economic development,-all move within the same orbit, and culminate in a corporate national self-expression. In other words, metaphorically speaking it is a sort of mental soil, in which the different branches of knowledge like plants of all kinds, manifest their distinctive colours. Just as in different soils, d"ffer ent fruits and flowers manifest distinctive features of their own, so peoples, living under different cultural influences, develop distinctive features and characteristics of their own. Nations develop such a natural affinity with their own cultures that, if dissociated from them. they wither away and die like plants of a particular country, trans planted in a foreign soil.
Science is uniform all the world over. But the Englishmen, the Germans. the French and the Russians,-all of them devote themselves to this in their own particular ways. The Indians' chief complaint against the Engli�hmen is that the latter have westernised their Eastern culture and have rendered them degenerated. In short, next to religion, culture is the dearest thing to a nation. It is to the nation as the breath of its life. A community, without a distinct cul ture of its own, is a life-less group doomed to merge sooner or later with other communities, for its existence brings no benefit to the world. Just as different scientists, working in different laboratories, have been contributing in their respective ways to the world of science, so differ ent peoples, in their distinctive cultural spheres have been experimenting in the philosophy of life, and are thus not only serving humanity at large, but also, by working for the realisation of their own view�points, have been developing their particular cultures. Communities which do not contribute towards augmenting this com mo� treasure-house are morally dead, and bound to die physically sooner or later. It is for the protection of their culture that the Hindus are to-day clamouring for Self� Government. '' Good government is no substitute for Self-Government " is an embodiment of the same truth. A good government can indeed make a people increase in wealth and comfort. but it cannot benefit their culture. On the contrary, it would destroy it. Cultural develop ment is possible only when the Government is run by the people themselves. Just as our Hindu brethren are inspired by their study of past history with a desire to have opportunities to develop their distinctive culture in celation '\vith modern conditions and thus make their con tribution to the world civilisation, so they may understand that the hearts of f\1uslims have been pulsating precisely in the same manner. They too are heirs to glorious traditions, and are the descendents of a race of men, ,,�hose enterprise knew no bounds. They too have their aspirations.
They too are not strangers. They are lndians and yield to none in their patriotic sentiments. But it can hardly be gainsaid that where the Hindu ele ment ,-vould preponderate, the Government would develop on lines of Hindu culture and philosophy. It is. there fore, that the �luslims demand for opportunities in the predominantly Muslim provinces to make progress on their o,-vn cultural lines. I do not, here, mean to say that they would enforce the Islamic law in those pro vinces. Such enforcement of the laws of a particular religion ,vould not be proper, either for the Hindus or for the 1\1uslims under a joint system of Government. But apart from Government, there are many spheres of life other than religion wherein a man should like to develop according to the philosophy of life peculi3.r to his people, and to sow the seeds and rear the plants of national development suitable to the particular scheme of worldly progress. A legitimate desire, therefore, prompts the iv1uslims' demand for similar opportunities :n two of the bigger provinces to make progress for some time to come, in accordance with their special traditions without interference and interruption. ls this demand an unreasonable one? Is the desire unnatural? Is it anta gonistic to feelings of patriotism? No, not in the least. Free cultural development is not inimical to common na tional interests. so India with a free dominion Govern ment, while serving as a vast laboratory for the cultural development of Asia, is not likely to cause any injury to England. It is regrettable, therefore, that the Nehru-