Text
The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 25
Report, whatever its merits may be, has absolutely failed to satisfy this desire of the Muslim co,nmunity. Even if it leaves the door open for the Muslims to dominate some day in the Punjab and Bengal, yet it does not afford them an opportunity to contribute to the treasures of human civilisation by enabling them to develop for some ti1ne iu accordance with their past traditions. The cul ture of a people cannot yield its fruit, unless it is given an uninterrupted series of opportunities for self-expres sion. But under the Nehru Scheme, there is the pos sibility of the Muslim element, being totally eliminated from the Government in the Punjab and Bengal.
Sixth Argument.
For full national development a people must be equipped with experience in all lines of work. This serves as an additional argument for reserving Muslim representation in the Punjab and Bengal on the basis of population. Evidently, in predominantly Hindu pro vinces the Muslims cannot be expected to receive train ing in higher statecraft. There are only two provinces where the Muslims may get such experience, viz., the Punjab and Bengal, where the Muslims hold a majority position. And if in these two provinces also, the Gov ernment be purely Hindu, or comprise of a poor Muslim element, then the opportunities for training in higher state-craft would be practically non-existent for the Mus lims, and in consequence they are bound to suffer con .. siderably. The N. W. F. Provinces, Baluchistan and Sindh can hardly serve as training grounds, for the ob vious reason, that Baluchistan with a population of 4,25,000 only has at best the status of a municipal cor poration, and the other two provinces are, both from the view-point of population and of economic capacity, too poor to afford a Government machinery on as large a scale as the major provinces. For the all-round train ing of their talents, it is essential to afford the Mussal mans uninterrupted opportunities for training for such time as they do not make up the deficiency. That could be done only by reserving their places in the Punjab and Bengal. Otherwise, the Muslims will never be able to shoulder the responsibilities of government, and would in consequence, instead of adding to the country's strength, lie like a dead weight upon it.
Having discussed at length the grounds for securing to the MusEms their position in the Punjab and Bengal in exactly the same manner, as would the pos;tion of the Hindus be secure in predominantly Hindu provinces, I now proceed to deal with the objections raised by the Nehru Committee against the demand for safeguarding the Muslim interests. The Nehru Committee holds that, (i) safeguarding the rights of, and Reservation of Seats for majorities lead to an intensification of communal misunderstanding, because the election is held upon the artificial basis of ·1ifference of religion ;
(ii) Reservation for majorities with joint electorates r�tards inter-communal unity, because it makes the majori ties independent of the votes of the minorities, and there fore indifferent to them ;
(iii) Responsible Government means a Government in which the Executive is responsible to the Legislature. and the Legislature to the electorates. If the members of the Executive, ·.vho have the majority at their back, come to power by virtue of special safeguards, and not by virtue of open election by the electors, then the Gov, ernment would be neither Responsible, nor Representa tive.
(iv) In the Punjab and Bengal, the Muslim population is so distributed that the community does not require any Reservation of Seats. It can easily capture seats equal to or even exceeding its nuμierical proportion.
(v) I add to these another argument, advanced by a worthy member of the Punjab Legislative Council, that the results of the elections to the district boards, where the Muslims, notwithstanding a minority of voters, cap tured more seats. encourage one to believe that a free contest would be more advantageous to the Mussalmans than separate election.
(i) As regards the first objection, I fail to understand how, in case of Reservation of Seats for particular com munities, the election can be held on the basis of reli g:ous differences. For, under such a system it will have already been decided that candidates. belonging to a particular community only, shall be entitled to stand for a particular constituency. In a Muslim constituency it is not po$sible for a Muslim candidate to ask for votef on the mere ground of his being a Mussalman. Such a question may, of course. arise in non-reserved constitu encies, where it is quite possible that a particular seat may be contested by Hindu and Muslim candidates, the former asking for votes on the mere ground of his being a Hindu, and the latter on his being a Muslim. But where the law has already decided, that· a particular con stituency shall be reserved for a particular community, this question cannot arise. The question, that could arise in such a constituency, may be of a sectarian nature such as. whether the candidate is a Shia, or a Sunni ; or reaarding the political view-point of each contestant.
And in cases of reserved constituencies, the importance would centre around the question of political views. And if the method of election be that of joint elector ates with Reser�_ation of Seats, it is all the more certain, that no other consideration save that of political creed, would be raised inasmuch as the different Muslim candidates would have to capture Hindu votes. They would, therefore, be compelled to eliminate the question of religion altogether, lest their rivals should get the better of them with the votes of non-Muslim com munities.
The fact should also be remembered that generally in elections there are more than one candidate standing for a constituency. He has to contest the seat some time with more than one rival. To say, therefore, that every candidate would urge his claim as a Muslim, and consequently, there would be an increase of communal feeling, is absurd. For all the contestants cannot, claim for votes on one and the same ground of their being Muslims. They shall have to urge other points, and these would be mainly political. And if it is here argued that possibly none of the Muslim candidates in a parti cular constituency may be in agreement with the Hindu view-point, how can we, then, reasonably expect a Hindu candidate from such constituency to obtain Muslim votes by fair means? I say ' fair �eans,' because in electi�n affairs voting is done secretly, and so it is quite possible to secure Muslim votes by unfair means. Voters may be persuaded to behave traitorously to their community with.. out the least fear of being exposed. A candidate, who is fraudulently returned, does not represent the country ; at best1 he represents his sordid crinbitions.
(ii) As regards the second objection, it can be argued that Reservation of Seats will rather remove mutual dis- trust, and restore normal relations between the com• munities as under this arrangement, the constant fear
of injury to mutual interest will disappear.
Further, it is no advantage to any individual candi date, A or B, that the Government has reserved a parti cular seat for the Muslim Community ; because such re servation is for the community as a whole, and not for any particular candidate, who must care for every single vote, and in order to beat his rival, must canvass every member. Therefore, the contention, that the majority would no longer care for a minority falls to the ground. It is the candidate, and not the community, who seeks the votes, and therefore, he must in any case remain dependent on the votes of individual electors. Moreover, there will be his supporters, who for his sake, shall have to care for the vote of every elector, and thus indirectly the whole of the majority party shall have to depend, for the success of their candidates, on the votes of the minority. Reservation of Seats, therefore, does not pre vent, rather it leads to the removal of communal distrust.
(iii) In its third objection the Committee argue that Reservation of Seats imposes restrictions on the electors ; and the majority rules the country not as a result of free and open election, but by virtue of the restrictions im posed on the electors by law. Hence, such a system is ·' a negation of representative government,'' and so de feats its end.
In my opinion this is a very important political ques tion. If the conclusion arrived at by the Committee ·is right, the whole controversy comes to an end. But,
1 1 think the committee have made a mistake in its judgment. For, the question to be considered is, whether it could be possible for any Muslim to represent a particular view- ---· point which a Hindu could possibly do. If not, then it is evident that the electorate is opposed to that particular view-point. Under the circumstances, how would the presence of a Hindu candidate increase the weight of the representation, unless it be by resort to unfair means; and unfair tactics are in any case unfair.