Text

The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 26

Another answer to the argument is that, under some circumstances, the rights of the electorate are bound to be circumscribed. And the Nehru Committee also has done so, when, for example, it has proposed an age limit of 21 years for a voter. This is a restriction im posed upon individual liberty, for there are men who attain discretion before they are 21 . Why should then such a restriction be upon the electors?

Similarly, the condition of nationality has been passed over by the Committee. !It prevails in all other civilised countries, and so it will surely be imposed upon Indians as well. Now, is it not possible that the electorate might wish to elect a non-Indian, who may be a well-wisher of the country, and who may also be willing to be natu1- alised as an Indian but prevented for the time being by the technicalities of law?

In short, the Nehru Committee, even in its recom mendations, has already restricted the rights of the elec torates ; and when the details of the constitution will be worked out, the rights are sure to be restricted still further. Restrictions, therefore, are not '' a negation of the principle of representative government.'' It is only unfair restriction that is opposed to Juch principle. And when the majority community of a province demands such restrictions as a matter of right, and such restric tions do not infringe the rights of any other community, they can by no means be considered unjust ; and hence, they cannot be deemed to negate the pr�nciple of repre sentative government. All that we can say is that, in-- stead of the whole country co-operating in electing its representatives, its different parts will elect their own representatives. Representation does exist though in � different form. And in fact, all civilised countries differ from one another in their forms of representation.

(iv) The last, and I should say, the most powe:rful argument in the opinion of the opponents is, that with reservation of seats the Muslims would get seats only in proportion to their population, but without such reserva tion, there would be chances for them to secure more, and there is no reason why they should refuse the chance of an increased representation. Any man with a head on his shoulders would see through this argument, and agree that it is playing with the sentiments of the people, and I am really surpri�ed to see that the Nehru Com• mittee did try to exploit the sentiments of the Muslims, without realising that it might produce result, quite con trary to what it expected.

The Nehru Committee is in fact so much enamoured of this argument, that it has stressed it on several occa sions. It says :-'' We have seen that this superiority has not helped the Hindus of Bengal at the District Board elections and we are sure that the result of Council elections will be even more strikingly in favour of the Moslems." ( Nehru-Report, p. 48.)

Again:-'' Looking at it purely from the Hindu point of view, however, we can well imagine that a reservation of seats for the Muslim majorities in the Punjab and Bengal, may actually benefit the Hindus, and may be the Sikhs also, more than no reserva tion. The facts and figures we have stated demonstrate that the Muslim position in the Punjab and Bengal is so strong that in all likelihood they will gain in a joint electorate with no reservation more seats than their popti...

lation warrants. Thus the Hindu and the. Sikh minori t:es may find their representation even reduced below their population ratio." ( Ibid, p. 49.)

Further on, about Bengal it writes:-•• The Hindu minority, although it is a very big minority, is highly l�kely to suffer in numbers in an open general election without reservation. (Ibid, p. 47.)

Clearly the Nehru-Report emphasises the point that without Reservation of Seats, the Muslims would be in a specially strong position in the Punjab, and Bengal. When a report prepared by the Hindus proceeds to lay so much stress on the advantages to be derived by the Muslims in the absence of reservation, it naturally arouses.. misgivings, more specially, when the same report admits elsewhere ( on p. 51 } that without such reservation the Muslims, in the Punjab and Bengal, "would, in all prob ability, be able to elect no more than 30 or 40 '· repre sentatives to the Central Parliament, instead of 72 their proper number according to population. The cat is now out of the bag, and no mask can hide the grim reality.

I would briefly refer here to another important point that, in the opinion of the Nehru Committee as ev:denced from the above quotations, elections would continue to be fought on communal lines even under a joint elector ate system. For, if, the people's mentality was going to be changed after the introduction of this system, how would it then be possible for the Muslims to command a majority of seats in the Punjab and Bengal?

In my opinion, the distribution of population shall have no special enect upon the elections. According to the Nehru-Report, the Punjab is divided into three divi sions, viz., ( 1) those areas in which the Muslims pre ponderate ; (2) those in which both the Hindus and the Muslims are equally strong ; and (3) those in which the

I Jindu8 pn:ponderatc. It has furth<:r proceeded to $how .,+ t.hi1t, aa the area, where the J-fjndu elernent preponder-- ateB, i,; srnallcr than the area, where the Muslirns pre pon<lcrc1te, the Mu8lims aha1l be in a position of advant-- age over the Sjkhs and the Hindus. It holds the &ame vjcw with r<!gard to the position in Bengal. In my opin:on it is a mistaken view. �fhe Nehru Committee seems to have; assumed that a district will form a constituency, while as a matter of fact a constituency is much smaller in area. According to the Nehru Committee every 1,00,000 inhabitants will select one representative. Ac cordingly, a population of 2,06,50,000 in the Punjab would elect 7 ½ candidates from each district, the total number of districts being 28. In many of these divisions the 1-lindu or the Sikh population would certainly not be so insignificant as it would, otherwise, be in the whole district. The matter will be clearer when seen in the light of the fact that a minority differing with its sister communities, as a rule, settles in towns and cities, instead of in rural areas. The Hindus general1y do so. In all those tracts, where Muslims are in majority, the Hindu population lives in towns and not in villages and prefers to live together. And euch of them, also, as happen to go to the villages for business, invariably have their property in towns, and do not sever connections with the cities. For illustration, one has not to go far. In the Punjab the Muslim popuiat:on amounts to 55% of the total, while the Hindu and the Sikh population is on1y 43 % . But in the city elections, where eight Hindu and Sikh members are electer:l, only six Muslims are returned,

i.e., Hindu and Sikh representation from the municipa}i ..

ties amounts to 57%, and that of the Muslim only 43 �lo. No doubt the introduction of adult sufferage would dimin-- ish the non-Muslim proportion, and increase the Muslim ,. proportion, but it cannot be gainsaid that from the pre-- sent relative proportion, it is clear that 1--lindus and the Sikhs are more thickly {Jopulated in towns. On the in troduction of adult suffrage this tendency would grow stronger, and even in predominantly Muslim areas, the Hindus who will live in towns, shall exercise their right of vote more largely than the Muslims, and thus secure their share even in places where they happen to hold a minority position. The Nehru scheme is thus to all in tents and purposes at best but make-belief; for most surely the powerful factor, namely, that of Hindu-Sikh intellectual and economic superiority would assert itself anyhow. The Nehru Committee has fortunately taken cognizance of this fact.

·

10 of 10 left today