Text
The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 27
(v) The only questio.a that now remains to be con sidered is that of elections to the District Boards in the Punjab and Bengal. It has been stated that in these elections, the Muslims in spite of their economic back wardness, succeeded in capturing more seats than they were entitled to, and the inference has been drawn that with a good organisation which it is hoped they would possess shortly, the co1nmunity would, by dint of its numerical strength, be able to secure the lion's share.
As this di�cussion ha8 already occupied longer space than expected, I would cut short by taking up the ques tions of the Punjab and the Bengal District Board elec tions under the same head. First, as regards Bengal, the Nehru-Report has taken up the question in detail, and it has sought to establish that the Muslims in some districts captured more seats than their numbers entitled them to. But the point at issue is the gross proportion of seats captured by the Muslims in the Dis trict Boards of the province as a whole. Of the total
458 mernbers, the Muslims in proportion to their popula
tion are entitled to 247 seats and the Hindus to 211. The results. however, show that the Muslims could capture only 209 seats while the Hindus secured the remaining 249. In other words the Muslim population, which was entitled to a percentage of 54, gained only 45 seats, and the Hindu population with a percentage of 46 only cap tured 55 per cent. of the seats. If that is the prospect held out to the Mussalmans by the Nehru Committee, it is hardly an occasion for rejoicing.
I admit that the Muslim position in the Punjab ap parently seems to be rather strong. The Punjab District Board statistics published by Mr. Afzal Haq Chowdhury,
of the Muslims to hold their own in spite of educational and economic backwardness. The figures show that in proportion to their population, the Muslims \.Vere entitled to 443 seats, and in proportion to the:r voting strength to 363, but they were able to capture 408 seats, that is in proportion to their voting strength they wrested 4S seats more than their due. The Sikhs, on population basis, were entitled to 186¾ seats, and on franchise basis to ) 84¾; but they actually won 185 seats, that is slightly in excess over their right. The Hindus in proportion to their numerical strength ,1/ere entitled to 275¼ seats and on franchise basis 268, but they could capture 221 seats only. It has been accordingly inferred that the Musli1n population is strong enough to secure representation over and above its right.
putting a straight question. Would any sensible man ever draw general conclusions from the results of a parti cular occasion? For such conclusions, what is necessary is to have figures of at least ten elections, and to find out from their average, what proportion of seat$ has been captured by different communities. If the disparity in figures is to be found only in the near past both in the Punjab and Bengal, then we shall be forced to ascribe it not to the adriotness of the Muslims, but to the wave of rabid communalism that reached its climax during the past four or five years. The riots in Multan, Calcutta, Barisal, and Lahore and the sufferings of the Moplas were shock$ powerful enough to make any Mussalm:1n·s blood boil within him. But this temporary excitement of feelings can hardly be considered a permanent feature. Do the protagonists of non-reservation of seats mean to assure us that they would continue exciting communal passions, and fomenting communal warfare? If not, and their love for the motherland should prompt them to say no, then I ask whether the result of a temporary excite ment in the two communities can justly be regarded as the standard of future elections. There is no doubt that a community, which suffers an irreparable loss, becomes indifferent for the time being to other influences, and sets to work free from every kind of restraints, their numbers only adding to its strength. Since the Muslims have been victims of grave inequities in the past, their feelings were excited more than those of any other com munity. To judge therefore of their future activities by their present efforts is simply unwise. The validity of the figures of the recent elections would be proved only when the average of at least ten consecutive elect:ons approximates the present figures. To a statistician, the inference d:rawn from the comparison of figures is valid only ( 1) when r,ircumstances of an extraordinary nature are absent, (2) the statistics extend over a fairly long period, and (3) when the .figures do not go to indicate the underlying presence of any adverse movement or a probability thereof, that is, when it is proved that in the figures for the successive years, there is no gradually developing factor militating against our conclusions. But in the figures noted both by the worthy member and the Nehru Committee not one of the three conditions has
been fulfilled. It has neither been proved that special circumstances did not exist at the time of the elections. ( on the contray I have proved that special circumstances did exist.), nor have the statistics of several elections been quoted, nor again has it been proved that from the figures of the past elections it does not appear that any such factors have been developing as threaten the progress of the Mussalmans. It is consequently foolish to dra"v any conclusion from these figures. The value of such figures depends on their average. Without such average they are meaningless ; while to depend on the figures of one single election is positively mischievous. Even the weakest army may by chance defeat a most formid able host, but such chances are rare indeed.
Even if statistics showed the continued success of the Mussalmans as against other communities in the District Board elections of the past few years, still it would be erroneous to conclude that the Muslims would prevail against the Hindus in the Council elections also. There is nothing common between the Councils and the District Boards. A seat on the latter is now hardly a matter for pride or prestige. The District Boards are practically unconcerned ,-vith the trade of the country. The Hindus, I mean the trading community, therefore, are not particularly interested in then1: for they take part in something. only ,vhen their interest is at stake. If they take part in District Board elections it is invari ably for the sake of some fr:ends. The Hindus are interested in the l\lunicipalities and also in the Councils, because the l\ lunicipalities are concerned with trade and so are the Councils. There is also the element of prestige. The Hindus see in these bodies the opportunity for the fulfilment of their hopes, viz., that of reviving Hindu cul ture. "y..l e cannot, therefore, safely draw our conclusions from the results of the District Board elections. There is before us the parallel of the British Parliament, and Local Boroughs. We may see that the country may at one time send one party to power in the parliament, and the opposite party to boroughs and municipal com mittees. Those conversant with politics are therefore agreed, that we cannot judge the results of the one from the figures of the other. I fail to understand how the Nehru Committee and our Punjab Councillors have as sumed the two bodies to be similar in character and have thus judged the result of the one from the figures of the other.
But apart from the arguments of reason and the con siderations of politics, if we study the figures themselves. it looks clear that the result of these elections is due more to the indifference of the Hindus than to the clerver ness of the Muslims. The figures show that all the extra seats, the Mussalmans ,¥on, were wrested from the Hindus and not from the Sikhs. If their adroitness had been the real factor in the game they could have wrested seats from the Sikhs also. But from the figures it is clear that only the Hindus lost as many as 46} seats. As against their loss the increase of the Muslims and the Sikhs was 46 and ¼ respectively. Clearly both the Muslims and the Sikhs have encroached upon the rights of the Hindus alone. Had there been the question of the domination of a majority over a minority, then the Sikhs would have been the larger sufferers being the smaller minority com munity,-almost half as much as the Hindus. The figures therefore do in no way prove that the Muslims' gain was due to their strength. On the contrary, they prove that the Hindu community is not interested enough in the District Boards. The facts do not therefore warrant the conclusion that in the elections to the councils also, the Hindus would suffer a defeat at the hands of their Mu slim rivals.
The fact must not be lost sight of that it is the land holders who are most interested in the District Boards. The traders no doubt purchase landed property, but they dislike turning agriculturists, and do not take such in terest in the District Boards as they otherwise might be expected to ci:::>. As for the Hindu agriculturist, he is as much oppressed by the Baniya as the Mussalman. In government offices, the Hindu agriculturists o-f Rohtak, Garbaon, Hissar, Kamal and Ambala, will not be found in appreciable number,-in fact they are fewer than the Muslim employees. That is why they co-operate with the Muslims in getting rid of the domination of the Baniya Elections to District Boards are mostly fought out by the members of this class and not by the Sahuk,ara and the Hindu trading classes.
Moreover, it must be remembered that neither the central political bodies take active part in elections to District Boards, nor do the wealthy men from cities con test seats in those elections. In the elections to the Councils, on the other hand, central political bodies take active part, and rich men from the cities join the con test. The two elections have therefore little resem- , ,
blance to each other.
In a word in the first place the figures quoted are not such as would justify any scientific conclusion. Secondly, even assuming the correctnesa of the inference, which has been drawn from the figures, we cannot, with any show of reason, judge the situation in the Council election from the conditions in the District Board elections for the simple reason of want of any analogous fea tures between the two, which alone would justify such com-
But let us for a moment admit, for the sake of argu ment, all the conclusions, which, those who produce the figures, want to infer from them. The question then arises :-Do these figures indicate that the results would always continue favourable to the Mussalmans, or simply that there are chances fo1 the Muslims to come off best? I am sure no reasonable man would conclude from these figures that Muslims would always wrest more seats than they are entitled to. Because there are ah\--ays the same opportunities for the Hindus to organise themselves as for the Mussalmans. Again, when we take into considera