Text

The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 29

The Hindu contention, that in a Representative Government it is the majority that rules and therefore a minority has no right to demand representation in excess of their num bers, does not hold good, for the simple reason that Re presentative and elective Governments are originally based on the fundamental principle of individual free dom, and if this principle is unsound and invalid, then Representative Government is altogether a meaningless thing. But if this principle is sound, then 80 millions of Mu§salmans are certainly entitled to say that, when Representative and elective Governments are established in order to safeguard individual freedom, how can they reconcile themselves to a form of government that leaves the interests of ¼ of the population absolutely undefend ed? They do not desire for themselves a majority posi tion, but are they not justified to demand even so much power as would be a secu:::-ity for the continued enjoyment of those rights, which an elective and Representative Government is intended to ensure, and for the sake of which, individuals impose limitations upon their own free dom. If a majority, because of its permanent position of vantage, has right to rule, then what is the difference between the Representative and the Despotic for,ns of Government ?

Nor should it be forgotten that the majority, to wh:ch is usually conceded the right to rule, i§ a politicai majority. -fhis always changes according to changing circumstances, and is never a permanent body, nor such as is susceptible to religious bias in its decisions. When there is a fear that a particular majority would be sus ceptible to external influence in its decisions, and such majority is also permanent in nature, then the need arises for affording protection to the community which is likely to be the victim to such biased decisions.

It may be urged that acco1ding to the above line of argument it would be necessary under every Government to grant to every religious minority representation in excess of their population ratio, and this would make a Representative Government altogether impossible. In answer, we may say that increased representation is in tended only for such minorities regarding which there is the apprehension that communal or religiou{i prejudices would work against them in their relation with the majority. In the absence of such special circumstances, a mere minority requires no special legislative aid. Even when there are more than one minorities whose co�bined strength is capable of deterring a majority from resort ing to oppressive methods, no special protective measure is needed. The difficulty in India is that there is only one important minority ; the Sikhs and the Buddhists though profes� to follow a religion different from that of the Hindus, are, nevertheless, a part of the Hindu body politic. Their presence does not work for the protection of the minorities. They actually strengthen the majority' 5 position. Had there been two real minorities in India whose combined strength would have formed an effective minority, India would not have been faced with the pro.. blem of protection for Muslim interests. At present the only other minority in India except the Muslims is that of �he Christians. These form only J % of the total popu lation. So negligible a quantity has on the one hand little to fear from the Hindus, and on the other is hardly strong enough to come to the help of the Muslims.

I take this opportunity to refute the argument put forward by many people in connection with the Hindu Muslim differences, namely, that in the presence of so acute differences, India should not be granted Self Government. In my opinion, when there are means avail able to protect the interests of the minorities, there is no reason why the same should not be adopted and India granted Self-Government. In several European coun�ries acute differences have been admitted to exist between different sections of the population, but even then with adequate safeguards for the interest of the minorities, new governments have been established. There is no reason, that the example of the European countries should not be followed in India.

The Nehru Committee further contends that to grant the Muslim demand for increased representation would be doing an injustice to other communities. I do not under stand what the committee means by this argument, and I am afraid, nor does the committee itself understand what the argui:nent is meant to convey. For, as a matter of fact, there is no minority community, which is going to suffer as a result of giving increased representation to the Muslims.

In the first place there is practically speaking no minority worth the name other than the Muslim minority· The Buddhists in ilndia are more a section of the Hindu community to-day, than a people independent and apart .

Besides, they are not faced with the same danger as the Muslims. In national questions they, as a rule, join the Hindus. The Sikhs are more or less in the same pos1 tion. As for the Christian, they form only 1 % of the gross population, and most of them being converted from Hinduism, they have no past of their own with which they might justly feel associated ; and accordingly, as they have nothing to lose, they have nothing to fear. Besides, the Muslims do not propose to add to their own position at the expense of the Christian population. They contend that the majority community has such a margin of excess that it can afford to accommodate the Mussalmans without undermining its own majority posi tion. Clearly, therefore, when the question of depriving any of the minority communities of its legitimate rights does not arise, the minorities have little to lose from the Muslim demand.

The third argument advanced by the Nehru Com mittee is that in the event of reserving seats for the Muslims, difficulty will be experienced in the matter of allotment of seats, and as a consequence, their right of representation shall have to be reserved both in the Punjab, and Bengal. This is hardly an argument, for the simple reason that it is exactly what the Muslims demand. I have already made it clear that it is only fair and just to grant reservation of seats to the Muslims both in the Punjab and Bengal. It is simply unreasonable to base an objection on what is already a point at issue. But even if it ,vere supposed that seats for the Muslims could not be reserved in the Punjab and Bengal, the objection hardly carries any weight. For, at the time of election to the Parliament the country would be viewed as n whole, and ii· i� a fact that the Muslims in relation lo t·hc gros:-; population of the country form a weak n1iuority. T'hl'rcfore, even on the assumption that seats would not be rc-servc-d in the provinces, there is hardly nny sound argu1ncnt against such reservation in the Central Legislature. Such reservation could very easily bt eff ctcd.

Before concluding, I take this opportunity to draw the ntt�ntion of the Hindus to the fact that if they are really anxious to see India free, they must show some genero sity of n1ind. They should at once disabuse their �inds of the false idea that they can trample upon the rights of the Moslems with impunity, and with success in the fight for India's freedom merely by virtue of their numerical superiority of 3 to 1 . They must remember that though individua1ly speaking every Indian would be benefitted by Self-Government, yet considered in terms of communities, the benefit will go mostly to the Hindus, who form the overwhelming majority in the population. It is meet, therefore, that they should exercise generosity of mind and abandon their present policy of narrow mindedness, which should make even a minority blush. They should bear it in mind that it is the duty of the majority community to be generous. They should remember the words of Professor Murray, that both the parties should act not only in a spirit of forbearance but also of generosity ; and that in the opinion of the world it is the duty of the majority community to be the first in such generosity. ( Vide Introduction to the Protection o/ minority by L. P. Mair, p. 5).

These words of Professor Murray apply to the case of the Hindus. But if the Hindus are not prepared to come to terms with the Muslim minority by conceding to then1 "'rhat serves to secure their pos1t1on without endangering the position of the Hindu majority, then they should neither entertain the hope of winning the confi dence of the Muslims, nor that the latter would consider the new Government of India as a National Government.

Separate Electorates.

The fifth demand urged by the Muslim community relates to the retention of separate electorate system, under which the Muslim would elect their own representa tives, and the Hindus their own. Muslim opinion itself was, however, divided over this question. Some suggest ed the retention of the system so long as the Muslims themselves were not prepared to abandon it ; while others agreed to its abandonment in favour of the joint elector ate system on the fulfilment of their demands as discussed in the fore-going chapters, provided of course, that the rights of the Muslim community had been adequately safeguarded both iu the provinces as well as in the Central Government.

The separate electorate system has been supported by a considerable number of Muslims, but so far as 11 have been able to gauge public opinion on the matter, all are agreed that it is a temporary measure. It is, there fore, superfluous to discuss the respective merits of the two systems. The only point to be considered is, whether separate electorate does really meet the present temporary need of the Muslim co-μimunity. In fact, its retention is necessary on account of the mutual distrust between the Hindus and the Muslims. I think no body denies the existence of such distrust. The only question now is what should be the system of electorate during this period of mutual distrust. Even the Calcutta League was of opinion that unless certain conditions were fulfilled, separate electorate system should not be dispensed with.

And as those conditions have not been fulfilled, it may safely and logically be concluded, that the League ( Cal cutta section) is in favour of the retention of this system.

So far as I can understand, separate electorates would be helpful in banishing the present state of warfare be tween the two communities. It is irrelavent to ask ,-vhat it has helped to produce so far. For, it could as well be asked, what has the joint electorate system done so far to improve the mutual relations in the District Boards and Municipalities, where it is in force.

·

10 of 10 left today