Text

The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 30

. The real thing, however, is that if the separate electorate system is at all objectionable, it 1s objectionable not from the view-point of inter-com munal relation, but for its 1n3urious effect upon the community itself. So far as inter-communal relation is concerned, separate electorate works for reduction of acerbity. Its chief defect is that it weakens the spirit of competition in a community. But under the present circumstances, when the Hindu-Muslim relation is so strained, it is simply indispensable. The consequence of its retention would be that the two com munities would settle down to work in a spirit of security. Our experience only strengthens the same opinion. We see that inspite of separate electorates, no legislative body has a purely Muslim Party. If the system had helped to foster disunity, it would have naturally led to the formation of separate Muslim and Hindu Parties in the Councils. The very absence of such parties shows, that the evil attributed to the system is in fact not due to it. At any rate, we find that under this system Muslims of all shades of opinion, Swarajists as well as the ad vocates of joint electorate system, have been able to win seats ; and similarly, those Hindus also who are c�-operat ing with the Muslims. Therefore, in so far as elections to the councils are concerned, the system does not seem to have produced any undesirable result.

In my opinion, it should be mutually settled that after the satisfaction of the demands of the Muslim League and the attainment of Swaraj, the system of separate elector ates should remain in vogue for a period of ten years in those provinces, where either the Hindus or the Muslims should demand such a measure. During this period of ten years, it would be at the option of the community, at whose instance it was introduced, to give it up of its own accord. Otherwise, it would continue to work for the full term of ten years. After the expiry of ten years the system of joint electorates with reservation of seats should be introduced in those provinces where the Hindus or the Muslims are in a ,,veak minority, and should con t1nue to be in force till such time as the minority of its own choice should not forego its right. As for the Punjab and Bengal, the system of joint electorates with reservation of seats should be introduced for a fixed period of time upon the expiry of which, only the system of joint electorate should be retained. But the preliminary conditions of such an arrangement should be the actual attainment of dominion status, and the redress of Muslim grievances, so that the Muslim might reap full advantges of their opportunities and be able to stand upon their own legs.

I consider it necessary to add that the above is put forward not as a formal proposal, but only as a sugges tion which might form a basis for discussion, and might lead to a solution agreeable to both the Muslim groups. Personally 11 am of opinion, that if the Muslims should get opportunities under an autonomous Government for a sufficiently long time to secure their own interests and to stand upon their own legs, then there is no reason why they should not gradually improve their condition, and be able ultimately to face their opponents in the open field. Especially when this arrangement is proposed only for the Punjab and Bengal, ,vhere the l\1uslirns are in a majority position, I do not think the l\1uslims would be running any risk. At any rate, it is a mere suggestion, which might be considered by the Hindus and the l\luslims. And it is possible that it may lead to some sort of mutual understanding.

I want also to have it understood that the system ot separate electorate is not entirely opposed to the prin ciple of representation, and the :mere fact that the system is r.ot in vogue in Europe, is no argument for its unsound ness. In a country where diverse communities with dis tinct religions and cultures live together, and their 1nutual relations continue to be strained from a very long time, it is simply indispensable to introduce some form of safe guards, without which the annihilation of the minority would be a foregone conclusion. The responsibility for such annihilation would lie with the majority, for in times of dispute it would be in the power of the majority alone to restore confidence in the minority. Thus, in this case it was only meet that, the Hindus should have suggested to the Muslims that they should elect their own repre sentatives separately, and the Hindus would elect theirs. But the strange thing is that they are not prepared even to accept the remedy when it is proposed by the Muslims.

It is indeed a deception to say that the system of separate electorates fosters disunity. I have already re futed the argument in principle. I now turn to facts. Did the Hindu-Muslim disunity arise after the introduction of separate electorates? If the answer is in the affirmative, I ask what was the proportion of Muslims in various Government departments previous to the introduction of the system? If it is a fact that before the introduction of the system, the Muslims enjoyed their full share of Government offices, then no doubt it will have to be ad mitted that the Hindus had no prejudice against the Mus lims before the system was introduced. But if the Mus lims' position was worse than it is now, then it shall have to be admitted that the prejudice is not the result of separate electorate, but on the contrary it was in con sequence of such prejudice that the Muslims were obliged to make this demand for separate electorates. And if it is proved that there has been an intensification of pre judice in these days, then the fact has to be ascribed not to separate electorates, but to the restlessness among the Hindus at the sight of the Muslims snatching away some of those privileges, ,vhich were so long the sole monopoly of the Hindus.

I cannot conclude without adding that the object of representation is a faithful interpretation of the views of a people, and there is no doubt that such interpretation can be best done by a co-religionist. The fact must not be lost sight of that at the time of elections, people secure votes by appealing to matters which are irrelevant but calculated to excite public feelings. But during the col;lncil session there arise many such ques tions, as are completely unknown to the electorate itself. True and faithful representation can be done only by a co-religionist who can faithfully reflect the views of his constituency, even when a new matter comes in for consi deration. And this state of things is to continue, till the people learn to separate politics from religion ; and mutual tension disappears, and cordial relations grow among the different communities with the consciousness of a united Indian nationality. Differences do not die out in a day, nor by mere pious wishes. As Professor Murray puts it, they disappear only gradually in several generations by the practice of mutual tolerance.

Pro'tection of Culture and Religion.

In respect of this demand I need not say much at this place, as I have already dealt at length with this question of safeguard for culture and religion in my vari ous wnbngs. I would only repeat here that religious conversions and religious propaganda should be free from every kind of restrictions. For the better elucidation of the subject, I think a brief list of the various safeguards imposed in Europe for the protection of the minorities would be helpful. I, therefore, give below a summary of those points, considered to be necessary for the pro tection of their culture and their religion, and I would recommend that these might be kept in view at the time of drafting a constitution for the country and arriving at a Hindu-Muslim understanding.

In the Congress of Berlin in 1878 on the occasion of recognising the independence of Rumania, the following provisions were made in the interests of the Muslim and Jewish minorities : -

(I) No one would be deprived of his civil or military rights on grounds of religion, nor debarred from Govern ment offices, or honours, nor from the assemblies, nor from joining the different professions and arts.

(2) No one would be prevented from organising or forming religious association, or from meeting religious leaders within or without the country.

Among the treaties made under the auspices of the . � League of Nations for the protection of the minorities, the undertaking has been tendered in the case of Poland that the Government shall be responsible for introducing primary education among the minorities in their own ver naculars in those districts and towns, where their numbers are considerable. lt has also been provided that in such districts, out of any amount voted for educational, charit able, or religious purposes, an adequate share in propor tion to their population shall be given to the minority. In Article 9, it has been laid down that these privileges can in no case be abrogated.

Regarding the Jews, it has been provided in Article IO of the same treaty that the money set apart for their education shall be spent through the medium of com mittees elected by the Jews. In Article 11 , it has been provided that the Jews shall not be asked to do anything derogatory to the sanctity of their Sabath. The only ex ceptions are matters, concerning the Army and the Police. No elections shall take place on Saturdays.

The undertaking was given by Yugoslavia that the Musli1ns shall have full liberty to follow their religious law in cases of inheritance. ( This should be noted.) Government shall protect mosques, shrines, and other Muslim buildings. Wak} properties shall not be interfered with. ( Important" to note.) No obstacle shall be put to the establishment of new wak}s and allied institutions in the future.

In Czechoslovakia, the teaching of the Vernacular has not been restricted to the primary schools alone.

Albania has undertaken to introduce such a system of electorates as would ensure complete protection of the national, religious and linguistic interests of the minorities.

·

10 of 10 left today