Text

The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 4

Their first demand is that the Government of the country should be of the federal type, i.e., the provinces should enjoy complete autonomy. Whenever and to whatever extent Britain waives her authority, the same should be given over to the various provinces. But since it is necessary to have a central organisation for the general administration of the country, subjects of com mon interest should be delegated to the Central Indian Government by the provinces. This will mean that the Central Government shall not delegate certain powers to th_e Provinces but on the contrary, in order to run an

powers to the Central Government. If this principle be accepted and adopted in India as it has been _successfully tried and followed in the United States of America, Switzerland South Africa and Australia, it will give us

a Central Indian Government administering foreign affairs, national defence, posts, telegraphs and customs depart ments only, the rest being dealt with by the Provincial Councils according to local needs, the Central Govern ment having neither the power nor the right to interfere in such matters.

The reason why the Mussalmans advocate a federal type of Government, is that they want every community to have full scope for progress, and that the Mussalmans where they are in a majority, should not be the victims of intervention by the Central Indian Government in which the Hindu element is bound to preponderate.

Supposing that a federal type of Government did not exist in India, the progress of Bengal, or the Punjab, or Sindh for instance, where the Mussalmans are in a majority, will always be liable to be interfered with by the Central Indian Government who may at any time find fault with the int�rnal administration of those provinces and in consequence withdraw certain privileges, supersede certain laws, and thus render the majority impotent and powerless. This is not a baseless fear for even the Nehru-Report itself has aggravated it. For the com mittee in discussing the question of the separation of Sindh, observes :-

'' We suspect that the real opposition to separation is not due to any high national considerntions but to grosser economic considerations ; to the fear of the Hindus that their economic position might suffer if Muslims had the charge of affairs in a separated area. We are sure that this fear is baseless. Among all the people of India the Hindus of Sindh are perhaps the most enterprising and adventurous. The traveller meets them in the four quarters of the world, carrying on prosperous businesses and enriching their people at home by their earnings abroad. No one can take away this spirit of adventure and enterprise from the Hindus of Sind and so long as they have it their future is assured. It must be remem bered also that the powers of a Provincial Government are limited and there is the central Government which has power in all important departments." (Nehru-Report, page 32.)

From a comparison of the observations quoted above with the remarks made by the Nehru Committee in deal ing with similar fear on the part of the I\lloslems, one can easily imagine what sort of sympathy will be accord ed to the Mussalmans. For while it has betrayed so much solicitude and regard in respect of the Hindu mis apprehension, it had dealt with the Muslim fear in the same report in the following strain:-

,' A new comer to India looking at thes,� figures and

the strength of the Muslim community, would probably imagine that it was strong enough to look after itself and required no special protection or spoon feeding.''

In other words while the susceptibilities of the l\llussal... mans hardly deserved any consideration at the hands of of compilers of this report, an injury to the feelings of the Hindus was a collossal sin. Apart from this, the authors of the report, as is clear from the above-quoted text, assure the Hindus that their fears regarding Muslim majority, are absolutely unfounded when they ( the Nehruites) will be there to overlord it in the Central Government, and ready to intervene whenever the econo mic supremacy of the Hindus is placed in danger. Though the words are guarded, yet reading between the lines, the presumption grows clear that the Central Gov ernment has reserved for itself powers simply in order to safeguard Hindu interests. We ourselves do not favour the idea of trampling upon other people's rights, but we suspect that the Central Government will not be content with merely intervening when Hindu interests are actually jeopardised in Muslim Provinces, but that by its undue interference it will hamper the progress of those pro vinces, and prevent them from adopting measures condu .. cive to a healthy development, just as in the past certain European Powers stood in the way of the Turks' pro gress. But this is not the only reason. Commonsense suggests that the vastness of India, its diversity of r�li gious persuasions, tongues and culture, make it essential that each province should progress independently. t-Iome rule can never be of benefit to India unless it be of a federal type. Such a type of Government is b�' no means a novel experiment. It has been successfuliy adopted by the United States of America, the wealthiest and most formidable power in the world. So μiuch, h9w ever, must be guaranteed by enactment that no province shall have the right to break off from the Central Body. When an understanding to the effect has been given

by each province, there will no longer exist for India that

fear of being partitioned into divisions as faced the United States once upon a time.

In its second demand this Muslim party urges the acceptance of the principle that in apportioning repre sentation to the various communities, the weak minorities should in their respective provinces be allotted seats more than they would be entitled to on the basis of popu lation so as to embrace the various opinions and inter ests ; while in provinces where minorities are strong enough to hold their own, their representation should be restricted to their proportion in the population and thus preclude the possibility of a majority being rendered into a minority. Accordingly in the Punjab and Bengal the representation of each community will be proportionate to its numerical strength, because if the Muslim majority which is only 55 and 54 per cent. respectively, were made to forego some of its seats for the Hindus or the Sikh cs, it is liable to be reduced into a minority, with the result that the Hindu element will preponderate in the admin istration. On the contrary in the U. P., Behar, Bombay, Madras, and C. P. where the population is predominantly Hindu and minorities form a very small proportion, they should, according to the principle ennunciated above get more seats than they are entitled to by virtue of their numbers, so that their different sections may have oppor tunities for representation. The Hindus by this arrange ment do not lose anything at all, their preponderating majority remaining unaltered. In the same way in the

N.W.F. Provinces, Baluchistan and Sindh, where Mussal

mans have an overwhelming majority, the Hindus should be given more seats than they are entitled to according to their numerical strength so that all their interests might be fully represented.

Alongside of this, another demand relates to the re presentation of Muslims on the Central Legislature. ,It is urged that the Muslims who constitute one-fourth of the population should, so long as their numerical strength does not increase to one--third of the population, be given one--third of seats in the Central Legislature, but when their population grows to or exceeds one-third of the whole, then seats should be allotted to them on popula tion basis.

The third demand is that until mutual confidence between the Hindus and the Muslims has been restored, separate electorate system should be retained in all the provinces, or at least in Bengal and the Punjab, where Muslims are only in a small ,:najority, so that representa tives of the Muslims should be such in the truest sense of the word, and not mere puppets working against Moslem interests under the influence of the Hindus.

The fourth demand relates to the extension of Repre sentative Government to the N. W. F. Provinces and Baluchistan, and the constitution of Sindh into a separate province with a legislature responsible to the people.

The fifth demand stresses the necessity of complete non-intervention on the part o-f the majority community in respect of the language or the script of the minority, and when a minority desires to keep its tongue alive, to make it obligatory on the part of Government to provide facili ties for the teaching of the same in local educational institutions.

The sixth demand emphasises the necessity of Gov ernment's scrupulous non-interference in matters pertain ing to religion and the propagation thereof. It should neither impose restrictions on conversions nor should it have any right to pass such legislation as is likely to ad versely affect the culture or economic position of any community, as for instance, a law regulating cow slaughter must be passed only when three-fifths of the members of the community affected by it are in support

·

10 of 10 left today