Text

The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 31

ln respect of Aland Isles, Finland agreed that th� people of the 11sles shall not be made to contribute funds for the schonls, where education is imparted in the Fi!l ish language.

In connection with the Jewish minority, Poland further agreed that education in the religious institutions of the Jews shall be deemed to fulfil the requirements of the law of compulsory Primary Education. ( Mussalmans should note). It was also provided that Jewish servants and soldiers shall be given time to offer their prayers, and further that they shall be given rations as sanctioned by their religion. Their religious teachers shall remain exempt from active service. ( These points also should be remembered when negotiating a settlement ).

The point also should be made clear that no depre catory and defamatory accounts of the kings of any people should form any part of the courses of school studies, as it tends to ruin the national character. This is done in some European countries. The Hindus seem to have a special aptitude for this most objectionable form of activity.

The points narrated above clearly show that in con sidering the question of national protection, the immediate importance of a particular matter is not so material; what has to be considered is its effect, great or small, upon the national character of the people concerned. It is, therefore, essential to make complete provision of the protection of the religion, culture and language of the community in question.

I have already stated that there should be some guar- � 1 antee that the laws would be rightly administered, for it is evident that without their proper enforcement the laws serve no useful purpose. To attain this end two means are generally adopted :-( 1) That the minority should be given its due share in all the services ; and (2) that there should be some final appellate authority to which appeals might be preferred in case of difference.

The Muslim community has been continuously urging the first demand, but the plea of efficiency has been in variably adopted to keep them out of their rights. The pretext is however altogether without foundation. The Muslims are not at all inefficient. They are only falsely stigmatised as such. Instances are not wanting of <t Muslim subordinate being found deserving of every kind of preferment unde1· a European officer, but the moment he comes to be placed under a Hindu officer he is found to be incompetent. Such instances conclusively prove that there is no doubt about the capacity of the Muslim officers, but that there is a plot to suppress their merits, and attempts to poison the minds of the European officers a�ainst the Muslims by frequent report of inefficiency. The fact is evident, that the Hindus, being in the office from a longer t!me and in larger numbers and occupying the higher posts, find opportunities to prejudice the European officers against Muslim subordinates easily enough. As a consequence some Europeans also have been led to believe that Muslims are really inefficient, while as a matter of fact an examination of the past records of their services might easily show that most of the persons now condemned as inefficient, possessed a brilliant record previous to their coming under a Hindu officer. It is, however, much to be regretted that eve11 European officers are apt to rely on hearsays, and do not take the trouble to investigate the truth before passing a condemnation upon a whole nation.

The demand for representation in the services 1n pro portion to the numerical strength of a community should in no way be considered as opposed to current political theories. The demand has been urged on behalf of the European minorities, and its importance has been duly recognised. There is, therefore, no reason to turn it down in India as a foolish and absurd claim. In Poland, for instance, it has been recognised with regard to the Jewish minority that they ·' were to be admitted in due proportion to the public services, and allowed to hold non-commissioned rank in the army.'' (The Protection of

The League Coun�il appointed a commission to repo:t on the Governmental organisation of Letivia. From their report it is evident that the commission attached great importance to this question of services. It said that the Jews were not being fairly treated. They were being given employment under Government JllUCh below their proportion in the population. ( Ibid, p. 113.)

,. • It will thus appear that the question of services can not be considered as a matter of minor importance. In fact it is essential that every community should receive a share of Government services proportionate to its numeri cal strength, so that the community may have opportuni ties to see for itself whether its rights, safeguarded by law, have not been disregarded in their actual applica tion. In short, it is necessary for the progress of every community that it should get a due and reasonable sha<e in th� services of the country, and it is important that it should be provided accordingly, in the future constitu-

tion of the Governmeht.

The other means to ensure the due enforcement of the laws of the constitution is that relating to appeals. The situation in India makes their means a little difficult of application. The ultimate goal assigned for India is that of Dominion Status. In my opinion this is a right goal, though some people regard it merely as a transi tional stage, and one that has been necessitated by the exigencies of the time. I am, however, of opinion that even intrinsically Dominion Status is the best form of Government, and particularly so for the Mussalmans. At present neither the British people nor the Indians do adequately realise the fact, that the Juture of Great

Britain is linked with Asia and particularly with Islam.

But God pleasing, the future will vindicate the truth of the fact. Great Britain under the stress of a habit cf thought grown for centuries, may or may not admit it, but the fact remains that its hold on Europe has loosened, and its old prestige has disappeared. To-day the Un1ted States of America has stepped into its place. Like England of a few centuries ago, the United States to-d�y are pledged to a policy of non-intervention in European affairs ; but like England under the force of circumstances the States shall be obliged in future to change this policy and actively take part in European politics. With 3 change in its policy the other powers would begin to �ealise its strength, and Great Britain shall be oblioed.=, ' in order to maintain its position, to seek for new allies , or better say, to set up new powers to join hands with it. And at that time it will be impossible for her to maintain her position of supremacy among the WorL:l Nations except by making common cause with Asia and particularly with Islam, just in the same way as the Roman Empire when it became converted into the Byzantine

I a1n afrnid I an1 A bit off 1ny point, but not so h-1r as it n1ight s 111 to th sup rficial observer. What I n1t.:an to sa • is that the bc$t fotn1 of connection with Britain is attachn1 nt to th English Crown, or in other ,,·ordt- Don1inion elf-Govt: rrunent, '\vhich has been :.l.R ..

signed to be the inunediate goal of India ; and under this

forn1 of gov rnn1e nt thc.: r cnn be suitable n1c-nns of ap.. peal to an in1partiRl third party. rfhere fore, it should be

provided in the laws of the constitution. that if nny

·

10 of 10 left today