Text
The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 32
person or group of persons find that the constitution is being abused by the Governn1ent, then it shall be opt->rt to such person or persons to prefer an appeal. The ap
peal. as has been agreed to in the case of other Dominions would lie in the Privy Council. 11 have already stated that in the event of the Hindus being in power, no great weight is likely to be attached to such appeals, but in the event of the provinces being autonomous the Muslim voice is not likely to prove too weak to make such appeals a real deterrent in respect of infringement of the consl� tution.
In addition to the abuse of the constitution there i�, as already mentioned, the question of the amendment cf the constitution. If it would lie with the majority com munity to change or amend it at will, all our postulations and efforts are useless, for the Hindus whenever they choose can deprive the Muslims of all their rights and privileges. It is essential, therefore, to provide that no amendment or alteration of the law would be possible without the consent of the one important minority. It is much to be deplored that there is no such provision ;n the draft before us. On the contrary, it provides that the law can be amended with only two-thirds of the total votes. As under the Nehru Scheme at least 75 % of the members in the Central Legislature would be Hindus, they could manage easily enough to change, amend, and alter the law with the Hindu votes alone. That the con stitution of a Government can be amended even against the will of a powerful minority cannot be conducive to the peace of the country. It is, therefore, most important that the Muslim proportion should be raised to at lea�t 34% or 33% so that no change be possible without th·�ir consent.
To say that it is against principle to accord increased representation to any community is to betray complete ignorance of the constitutions of the world. In Czechoslo- vakia the minorities have been accorded representation in excess of their population ratio. This may be seen from a passage in the reply, given by the Czechoslovakian Government to the League of Nations in connection with a representation made to the latter by the German minority regarding their ill--treatment by the Czechoslovakian Government. The reply said that in spite of that, they ( the Germans ) held more seats in the national assembly than they were entitled to according to their numerical strength, and that if they could win a sufficient majority, they might be able to change even the constitution. (The Protection of Minorities, p. /20.)
In a word, one solution of the present difficulty, so far as I can understand, lies in allotting to the Muslim community 34% or at least 33% of the seats both in the Senate and in the Parliament, so that without their con sultation it should not be possible to change the laws of the constitution.
The above remedy is proposed only for affairs of general interest. There will, however, be certain matters that affect the Muslims alone, and in my opinion these should not be interfered with without the consent of the community itself. These matters I have already referred to elsewhere. Regarding these, the decision of the Luck now Pact seems to be the best possible solution. That is, it should be provided that no change shall be made in the laws of the constitution, pertaining to these matters, with out two�thirds of the elected Muslim members of the Central Parliament voting for such change, and that such law shall be introduced only in those provinces where two�thirds of the Muslim members of the provincial body agree to the same. Such are the provisions which may help to safeguard the Muslim interests, and there is no reason why they should not be acceptable to the Hindus.
Duty Before Us.
I have so far expressed my opinion on those salient features of the Nehru-Report that are related to the Muslim demands. I now propose to chalk out a line of conduct that it is desirable that we should follow.
There might be many among us who, because of its many defects, would wish the Nehru-Report to be de stroyed altogether. I am opposed to such a view. From what I have written on the subject, the readers can easily see that I yield to none in my disapproval of the Report, so far as it concerns the protection of the Muslim inter ests. It cannot, however, be denied that it is the first attempt of its kind on the part of the Indians to present in detail the Indian view-point. As such, the Report deserves to have its defects removed if possible, and to be adopted as the united demand of the country. For, a people, accustomed to begin a task anew every day, never succeeds. The process of opening afresh the na tional problems is attended with the labour of examining every question anew, and wasting energy and time in fields, where already much has been spent. The new enthusiasm and zeal spends itself by the tirne one arrives at that very stage where things stood before. The result is that the country after having sacrificed its brain, time and money and even unity, returns, like the famous cattle at the mill, to where it was before the start. A people, undertaking to invent anew the railway and the telegraph with a view not to be under obligations to any other people, can never hope to march abreast with other na tions of the world. Accordingly, in my opinion, it should be our endeavour not to destroy the Report but to im...
prove upon it. We should not deny the compilers of this Report the credit of what is good in the Report, and should make patriotism and appreciation of services the motive of our work rather than jealousy and discord. Such a plan, I have every hope, will much facilitate our programme. We must not forget that the compilers of this Report with all their vast experience, and deep love for the country, were members of a particular religion and social circle, and it was natural that they should have leanings towards the same religion and society. We should, therefore, in dealing with them make full allow ances for this human weakness, and consider that if the decision had rested with us some of us might have been guilty of similar blunder. In my opinion, it is therefore meet in the interest of the country that we should deal with the Report in a spirit of criticism and not in a spirit of opposition.
It is true that the Nehru Committee has stressed the point that its proposals, if accepted, should be accepted
in toto. But the injunction is in no way binding upon
the country. The Committee worked with the intention of producing something tangible. The task before us is to endorse the useful suggestions and to reject the rest. We have every right to make reasonable changes, and say to our compatriots, that as you have considered the best interests of your community, so we have deliberated over ours, let us now negotiate a setltement.
In my opinion apart from the demands mentioned above, there are others that deserve similar consideration from an Islamic point of view. One of these is the ques tion of franchise. It is a very complex problem. / wish
that the right of franchise should be extended to the
Jem ale sex also. We cannot deprive a whole section of humanity entirely of its rights. At the same time it can not be denied that the introduction of adult and women suffrage would mean considerable loss to the Muslim community, on account of the general backwardness in education particularly among the females. Again there is the question of Purdah. If it were made compulsory for every voter, man or woman, to exercise his or her right of vote and punishment attached to default as is the case in Czechoslovakia, then perhaps the Musli� women might be induced to go to the polling station ; otherwise it is almost impossible. ,It is, therefore, important to give our best thought to the question and devise some via media.
Another question relates to foreign relations. The Nehru-Report contains a brief note on this subject. It has cleverly avoided a discussion of the sub3ect in detail. The hint, however, is sufficient to serve as an eye-opener to the Mussalmans. It purports to suggest that the future Government of India shall deal with the neighbouring Asiatic Powers in the same way as is being done hitherto by Great Britain, through the agency of Government of India. To me it would be an evil day for the Muslim States, when the control of India's foreign policy would fall into the hands of those who have the intention of hoisting the Rag of ·,Om' in the Hedjaz, and they would control India's relation with Arabia, Afghanistan and Persia. The relations of Great Britain with these Asiatic States are based on an altogether different foundation. The consideration of economic supremacy alone governs their policy. But a free India, which is so early dream ing of political supremacy, will view these relations from a different standpoint. I am, therefore, of opinion that it would be wiser to let Britain control the foreign policy, excepting the minor subjects such as trade, transit and •· ports, etc. Left to itself an Indian Government I am