Text
The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 33
afraid, would interfere rather too much in matters relating to neighbouring Muslim States.
The third question relates to the sanctity of the /umaa ( the Muslim Sabath ). It is very important in so far as national existence of the community is concerned. Where the Jews, 3,500 years after the establishment of their Law, consider it essential to secure protection for their Sabath, and the Christians make stipulations in their treaties in respect of Sundays, there is no reason why the Muslims should not insist on facilities for the /umaa prayers being made an important part of the constitutional law.
The fourth question relates to the Muslim law. In a mixed government the Muslims cannot enforce and in troduce their law of Shariat, but there can be no objec tion to their insisting on the enforcement of Muslim law in their own social and domestic affairs.
The fifth question relates to Hi�h Court Judges. In view of the autonomy in the provinces, it appears to me to be necessary to leave it to the Provincial Govern ments to appoint judges of their respective High Courts, and to the decision of the provincial councils to dispense with their services. The Nehru Scheme has left this power to the Governor-General ; but as constitutionally the Governor-General shall have to act in consultation with his ministers, most or all of whom ;n the case of the Central
Government are likely to be Hindus, the arrangement would virtually bring all the Indian High Courts under the influence of the Hindus. There is, however, no objec tion to the Supreme Court being directly under the Gov ernor-General.
Apart from these questions which have special rela-· tion to the Muslims, there are others of a more general nature that deserve attention from the community. The Compilers of the Nehru-Report, do not appear to have made a deep study of the constitutions, which have been adopted by the New States established after the war. I think a better constitution can be drafted if the matter be given more serious consideration.
The problem of the Indian States has not yet been solved. The solution preferred by the Nehru Committee is neither sound nor acceptable to the States. The British sovereignty over the States has its basis in their superior power. Under the future constitution of India what would be the justification for one part of India to control another? It is, therefore, necessary to devise some such scheme as, on the one hand, would maintain the unity of India as a whole, and on the other, would prevent one part of the country from being subjected to another. To my mind, the institution of a permanent Imperial Conference in place of the proposed Senate. and the recognition of the internal autonomy of the States with adequate safeguards for the interests of their subjects, would afford a solution of the present problem. The Con.. ference might comprise of the representatives of the pro vinces, of the delegates of the councils and of the States•, and it might deal with inter-provincial affairs and other subjects of all-India importance. The body should be concerned with matters relating to administration and not to l�gislation. It is also possible that this body should be invested with additional powers, and attached to the Go:7ernor-General as a sort of Privy Councjl. It may also be invested with powers of arbitration in disputes relating to the constitution.
In short, we should give further thought to the subject matter of the Nehru-Report ; and in order to do that, we must at once call an All-Muslim Parties Conference to which all sections of the community should be invited to send their representatives. I have been delighted to learn that some Muslim members of the Legislative As sembly have already begun the work in that direction, and it is proposed to hold such a conference in December, 1929. I think I need not, therefore, stress this point any further. I cannot, however, help drawing attention of the conveners of this conference to the fact that it would be useful to make the conference as widely representa tive as possible ; and the more generously the invitations are issued, the surer will be the success of the confer ence. It is also important that the invitations should be freely extended to the members of the opposite camp. Time for each speaker should be fixed, and the same rule should apply both to proposers and opposers. All parties should be given full opportunity to have their say. If the conference did not represent both the Nehruite and the ante-Nehruite groups of Muslim politicians, the general voice of the Muslim community would not rise strong enough. Opposition never weakens tho true cause : it rather strengthens it. Personal opinion should be subordin ated to the interests of Islam and the Muslims. If some one has a better proposal to make than our own, there is no reason why the same should be rejected. Instead of driving such a one away, we should invite him closer to us, and should listen attentively to what he has got lo say, for an opinion does not gain in strength by the sup port of fellow-thinkers, but by the criticism of opposets. The procedure should be that in that conference a dis cussion of the Nehru-Report should take place only on questions of principles, for that alone is possible in such a conference.
After the principles have been decided, a sub-committee should be appointed to study closely the details of the recommendations, and to suggest improve ments and amendments, and to d1aft an elaborate scheme not confining itself to safeguards for Muslim interest alone, but traversing the whole field of constitutional ques tions ; and this draft should be presented to the next sit ting of the All-Muslim Parties Conference. If it finds un animous support from the Muslims or even from a majority of them, then it μiay be published. A complete draft of the constitution alone can be expected to create a stir in public circles ; a mere criticism cannot be ex pected to do the same. The stu created by the Nehru Report is also due to the fact of its being a complete proposal. Unless, therefore, we can put forward a com plete proposal by making necessary changes in the Nehru Report, in the eyes of the world we shall be regarded as adverse critics, and not as practical politicians.
Another matter which is equally important is to con.. vene meetings in all towns and cities to pass protest re solutions against the Nehru-Report, and send reports of the same to the Government. For, leaving aside the ques tion of co-operation or non-co-operation, we cannot deny that the Nehru-Report has succeeded in creating a stir in government circles. And if the Muslims failed at this juncture to raise a strong and effective voice of dissent, both the Government and the public at large will per force be led to ascribe it to their appreciation and accept- a�ce of the Nehru-Report. And if as a consequence of this wrong impression, some such changes be introduced in the constitution as are detrimental to the interests of the Muslim community, then it would indeed be really a hard job to rectify the mistake, and the old plea of
status quo would stand in the way of safeguarding the
Muslim rights.
Apart from this, it is also necessary to hold pubiic meetings in order to educate Muslim public opinion re garding what pertains to their interest and advancement. The supporters of the Nehru-Report are traversing the country, and making every possible efforts to enlist public support for their views but the opposite group has taken no steps to explain the demerits of the Report to the general body of Muslims. And it is well-known that the public at large cannot be expected to understand these complex questions unaided. The secret of Mr. Gandhi's influence lay in his change of audience-in his appeal to the man in the street, while his predecessors thought the secret of India's success lay in their approach to the
intelligensia. It cannot be gainsaid that the advocates of
a democratic form of government cannot succeed without enlisting the support of the masses. It is not possible for any body to demand a democratic form of government, and at the same time to turn his back to the masses.
It is, therefore, indispensable to educate the Muslim
masses on the present state of affairs, and for that pur..• pose to hold meetings in all cities, towns and villages, and to consolidate the Muslim opinion. A conference of the enlightened can certainly help in arriving at a right and sound decision, but it will lack the power to make that decision effective unless there be the masses behind it.
Myself and the whole of the Ahmadiyya Community are prepared to co-operate in this matter with all other sections of the Muslims, and I promise to employ the whole of the wide and efficient organisation of the Ahmadiyya Community in the advocacy of this cause of Islam in every reasonable and proper way.