Text
The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 5
of the same.
In addition to the above I have been repeatedly urging a seventh demand namely that the above-men tioned rights should be embodied in the constitution, and it should be provided that the constitutional law should not undergo any alteration unless and until two-thirds of the elected members should vote in support of the pro posed change. Nor should this be considered sufficient. The same majority of elected members must support such a proposal in three consecutive councils before it is passed into law. And when the proposed changes directly affect any particular community at least two thirds of the members representing the same must in three consecutive councils approve of the proposed changes before the same should be placed on the statute.
Further more, the enacted measures should be enforced only in the province or provinces, two--thirds of the repre sentatives whereof had voted for such enactment. Unless such safeguards were provided the Hindus will be at any time in a position, by virtue of their overwhelming majority, to amend, modify or alter the laws and repeal all the protective measures which, while framing a consti tution for India, they would adopt in order to win over their Muslim partners.
Demands of the Calcutta Muslim League.
The Calcutta Muslim League, which the Nehru Com mittee claims to represent while favouring the idea of its delegates working conjointly with the Congress in draft ing a constitution for India enjoined upon them to keep
( 1) that Sindh should be constituted into a separate and autonomous province ;
(2) that the Reforms should be introduced in the N. W. F. Provinces and Baluchistan and they should be given the same rights as the other provinces ;
(3) that under the present circumstances, the reten tion of separate electorate system in the different provinces is imperative for the protection of Muslim rights, and Muslims cannot forego the same until Sindh is constituted into a separate and autonomous province and the Reforms are introduced in Baluchistan and the N. W. F. Provinces. And only after the fulfilment of these conditions, the Muslims would be prepared to replace the separate elec torate by the joint-electorate system provided that the representation of the different comn1unities is fixed on the basis of population excepting in the follo,ving cases :-
and Sindh. \\7ill concede to the Hindus repre
sentation over and aboYe their legitimate
number in exactly the same "·ay as the
Hindus ,,,ill concede to the iVluslims in pro
vinces ,.vhere they are in a majority.
have representation less than they have at
present.
In addition to this the League accepted the �1adras resolution of the Congress regarding freedom of opinion, laws affecting religion, cow and music. and incorporated the same in its above-mentioned resolution.
It is true that some of the points ,vhich find promin ence in the demands of the other party of the i\Iuslims have been omitted by the Calcutta League. This ho'\vever does not prove that the Calcutta League is opposed to these demands. For example, the demand for a federal type of Government is not to be found in the Calcutta League resolution. A glance over the speeches delivered on the occasion is, however, sufficient to convince one of the fact that the members of the Calcutta League, were proceeding on the assumption that provinces will be completely autonmous. This will be clear from the following words of Maulana Abul Kala;tn Azad:-
'' There would now be nine Hindu Provinces against five Muslim Provinces, and whatever treatment Hindus accorded in the nine Provinces, Muslim would accord the same treatment to Hindus in five provinces. Was not this a great gain? Was not a new weapon gained for the assertion of Muslim rights?" ( Civil & Military Gazette,
The above passage shows that Maulana Abul Kalam Azad had clearly in his mind that the provinces would enjoy complete autonomy, or else, how could the Muslims be said to have a new weapon in their hands if complete control rested with the Central Government having full power to interfere in matters provincial. A Central Government with a Hindu element preponderating, could at any time interfere with the affairs of the Moslem pro vinces ; an indication of which might be found in the tacit assurance given by the compilers of the report to the Sindh Hindus.
Similarly, the question of language is another point not touched by the Calcutta League. Jts silence should not be taken to mean that it attached no weight to the question. It was silent because the Con gress had once finally settled the question and accepted Hindustani or Urdu as the national tongue, both Persian and Nagri scripts being permissible. The Calcutta League had assumed that what the Congress had once decided and agreed to, the Nehru Committee would not overrule.
In short, although the Calcutta League in its resolu tion had omitted certain points, yet this fact should not at all lead one to conclude that it was opposed to the Lahore League in respect thereof. The difference existed only over the demand of the Lahore League ( J} for the separa tion of certain provinces as a matter of right, and (2) for the retention of separate electorates so long as the Muslims could not trust the Hindus and were not convinced that
the latter would not use their wealth and infiuence /or the
destruction o/ the former. Save this, there is hardly
any fundamental difference of opinion between the two sections of the League. lVlr. Jinnah, the central figure in the Calcutta League and who was also its moving spirit, had gauged l\luslim opinion on the occasion of the All f\luslim Conference held in Simla, and was conscious of the fact that the bulk of his community was opposed to his viewpoint, and was in favour of the Lahore section. In his speech he made the following remarks :-