Text

The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 6

• ' We have got a majority in this house but shall we bf:' able to carry a majority in the country? ( Voices ., '{ es n). Nothing will please 1ne more but at the same time it will be fair to say that I am not so sure that I am satisfied that the m�jority of Mussalmans throughout the country are in favour of it." ( Civil & Military Gazette, 2nd Jan., 1928, p. 3, Col. 4 ).

7{ have stated the demands of the Muslim community

� and have also shown wherein lies the differ ences between the two Moslem groups over the consti tutional issue. I have also shown that of the two Muslim parties the Calcutta section of the League is more dis posed towards the Hindu viewpoint. But even this group has stated in clear words that unless the Muslim demands have been satisfied in full, the Muslims cannot co-operate in framing any Swaraj scheme. This plainly means that these demands are not to be considered as the basis for Hindu-l\1uslim unity, but their acceptance is a condition precedent to negotia tions for unity. The Lahore section of the League is entirely in agreement with the other group in these demands, and in fact it cannot be expected to be content with anything less, when it actually insists on something more.

Now I proceed to elucidate the findings of the Nehru Report with regard to the Muslim demands :-

The first question relates to the constitution of the Government, which, most Mussalmans think should be of the federal type. As already explained, this is the most important question without which, no safeguard what ever could prove of any avail.

ilt is evident from the quotation of Maulana Abul Kalam Azad' s speech, that the Calcutta section of the

League under the leadership of Mr. Jinnah is also for a federal type of Indian Government. But the Nehru Report instead of a federal type of Government, pro poses a unitarian type of Government of a centralised pattern, which will be considered as the real ruler of the country-the rights of the Provincial Government being derivative. There is no doubt that the -astute compilers of the Report could not frankly deal with this question for fear of provoking Muslim opposition, which it would be difficult to suppress. !\!either could they ignore this grave issue without being accused either of ignorance of politics, or of having not prepared the report with due care. Therefore, they very cleverly inserted the follow ing words in the beginning of the seventh chapter of the Report where they have formulated their recommenda tions :- 64 We have made no attempt to draft the consti tution as a whole.''

No sensible person, however, can plead that the compilers of a constitution could with in1punity ignore the question what was to be the future form of Govern ment of the country. The Nehru Committee has done so. But as such, an important question cannot be detached from the constitutional issue. So what has been con ... cealed by omitting a de.finite ennunciation. the details have made it only too clear. Different passages of the Report show that the committee has proposed an all powerful central Government of a unitarian model. .Article 34 under the heading, '' The Provincial Legisla ture '' in the chapter on u Recommendations " reads: ,' The legislative authority of every provincial council extends to all matters coming within the class of subjects hereinafter enumerated and specified in Schedule II, attached hereto.''

Similarly in the �ame chapter and under the heading .. Parliament shall have power to make laws for the peace, order and good Government of the Common,vealth in relation to all matters not coming in the classes of subjects by this Act assigned to the legislatures of provinces."

From the above passages it is clear that in the future Government of India the provinces will derive their power from the Central Government, and not the latter from the former. Similarly in Article 30 under heading • • The Provincial Legislatures '• it is stated :-'' There shall be payable to the King out of the revenues of the province for the salary of the Governor an annual sum of . . . . . . ., which, until Parliament of the Common wealth otherwise provides shall be as in Schedule . . . . hereof provided.'' It is apparent from this rule that the Provincial Legislature will be subordinate to the Central Parliament. A still more clear reference is to be found under the head '' Civil Service '' where under Article 81 is to be found :-' Parliament may also, to such extent and in respect of such matters as it may prescribe, dele gate the power of making rules under the said laws to the Governor-General in Council or to local govemments.' ,

It is amply clear from the above references that the constitution proposed by the Nehru Committee is one entirely opposed to the united Muslim demand. The Muslims demand a federal type of Government with fully autonomous Provincial Governments, only residuary powers vesting in the Central Government which should administer subjects, transferred to it by the provinces of their own accord, liable under no circumstances to inter vention on the part of the Central Body. It can hardly be gainsaid that without such a form of Government, security for Muslim in India is an impossible dream. The sole consideration underlying the Muslims' demand of autonomy for Sindh, N. W. F. Provinces, and Baluchistan, is that, because of the existence of a Hindu minority in these Muslim provinces, the Hindu majority in other pro vinces will not be tempted to oppress the Muslim minorities in those provinces. But if all powers were to vest in the Central Government, this safeguard would be rendered absolutely useless. For, with the power to intervene at any time, the Central Government will inter £ ere in the affairs of the Muslim provinces whenever it chooses. If it is contended why it will do so,-well, that is the crux of the whole problem. Because there is lack of mutual trust between the two com munities. If there is no such distrust then all these restrictions are superfluous ; and it could be frankly stated that we should have full faith in our Hindu brethren. They could rule as they like. We could have expected nothing but good of them. With such a frame of mind the whole controversy would have ended at once, but where is that mutual trust?

The second demand of the Muslim community relates to affording protection for minorities by giving a minority where it is weak, representation in excess of its legitimate share, and where it can hold its own, to give it not more than its legitimate right. The Nehru-Report has however decided that in no case should the minority enjoy any extra rights, neither where the minority is weak, nor where it is strong. The Report says :-.. Representation in excess of their proportion in the population fixed for Moslems in a number of provinces-under the sanctioned pact as well as the Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms, will disappear under our scheme.'' In other words this united demand of both the Lahore and Calcutta sections of the

League has also been rejected, which means that, because the Muslim in the Punjab and Bengal, on the ground of being a majority, have refused to be ruled by the Hindu minority, the concession of small extra representation enjoyed by the Moslems in other provinces, should be withheld from them, although such extra representation did not give the Moslems any dominating position in the councils, but merely made possible the representation in the councils of their various groups and associations.

In the same connection the Muslims demanded that they should be granted 33 % of seats on the central legislature, so that their representation from differ ent provinces might be facilitated. The Calcutta and Lahore sections are uniformly at one in this demand. But this demand also has been rejected by the Nehru Committee. The Report says :-·• The Moslems are a little less than one-fourth of the total population of British India and they cannot be allowed reservation over and above that proportion in the central legislature.�'

At present, though the number of Muslim seats -::n the legislative Assembly is not quite 33 % , yet it exceeds 25% in any case. The Nehru Committee recognises that

30% of the seats in the Legislative Assembly are at

·

10 of 10 left today