Text
The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 7
present occupied by Muslim representatives ; but it is not willing to give the Mussalmans even this proportion of seats in ,the future constitution. lln other words, while the inadequacy of 25 % of seats to represent the different Muslim interests, impelled the Muslim League to demand an increase in the present proportion of Muslim seats, or at least to maintain status quo, the Nehru Committee would, on the other hand, reduce the existing Muslim representation to one-fourth, i.e., 25 % ;-although such demand would in no way adversely affect the position of the Hindu majority.
Over the third demand the Muslim opinion has differ ed. The Lahore League is not prepared to give up separate electorates so long as mutual confidence has not
been restored between the two communities, and the
Mussalmans themselves are not willing to dispense with
the system. In the opinion of the Calcutta League
however, there was no objection to the Muslims' dispens ing with separate electorates provided that Sindh was constituted into a separate province, and Reforms were extended to the N. W. F.. Provinces, and Baluchistan. Of these two demands neither has been accepted by the Nehru--Report.
The Nehru Committee admits as well that according to the League council decision, this was the irreducible minimum demand of the Moslem community. The resolution of the Calcutta League also points to the same intention. The resolution runs :-'' The Muslims will not abandon this right unless and until Sindh is con stituted into a separate and autonomous province, and Reforms are introduced in the N. W. F. Provinces, and Baluchistan.·, But the Nehru Committee accepts only one of the three demands, viz., extension of Reforms to the N. W. F. Provinces. The question of the separation of Sindh is hedged in with various conditions and limita .. tions, and the question of Baluchistan again is dealt with in very ambiguous terms. The Report says:-'' As regards non-Moslem minorities the only provinces which deserve consideration are the N. W. F. Provinces and Baluchistan.'' The words indicate that the compilers of the Report had in mind that the question of the right� of the Hindus in Baluchistan will crop up. Yet, still further on page 124, while discussing communal representation under Article 7 it says :-" The N. W. F. Provinces, and all newly fonned provinc<·s, by separation from oth r provinces, shall have the same form of governrnent a the other provinces in India.''
From the abov" quotation it will appear that whil dealing with the question of constitution alJ referenc to Baluchistan has been omitted. May be, this was du� to oversight. Nevertheless, the matter ib left doubtful. At any rate, we are justified to hold that the hru Committee has failed to fulfil those conditions upon which depended the Calcutta League's decision to abandon th system of separate electorate, and quite indep nd ntly of which, the Lahore League had decided to stick to th system for sometime to come. But the matt r do not end there. The wordings of the Calcutta L a u r olu tion clearly signify that the l�eague does not only d rn nd that the Hindus should agre•� to fulfil th condit1on before dispensing with separate I ctorat , but it n1 k two further provisos also, namely (I) that th condition should be practically acted upon, and (2) that �us\im should also satisfy thems lv s a r ards the r sult of the working thereof. It says • • Wh n th s condition have been fully compli cl with th i'ilus alrnans will b prepared to abandon the separat el ctorat syst m for the joint electorate.'·
The Nehru Committe without accepting these con ditions, simply upon its own reco1nn1endation. dispen ed with the separate electorat syst rr1. On th contrary according to the reservation made by the Muslim League, it should have stated in unequivocal tenns that joint elec torate system would conle into operation only when the three preliminary conditions had been complied with. Similarly in the Muslim League Resolution, the words used are:-" then the Mussalmans will be prepared to abandon.'' According to the wording of the resolution the decision in this matter was left with the Muslims. Though it is by no means suggested here that the Mus lims might or might not abandon the system, yet the words do certainly signify that the Muslims would first satisfy themselves as regards th� fulfilment of their con ditions before deciding finally to do f.,way with the separ ate electorate system. But the Nehru-Report has alto gether ignored these terms.
I remember it definitely that when it was again and again urged on the All-Party Muslim Conference that if the Hindus at first agreed to our terms, but later on plead ed that owing to certain obstacles, the terms, so agreed to, could not be put into practice, then how the Muslims would be able to force their hands ; Mr. Jinnah emphatically said that the wordings of the 1 esolutions had not been fully comprehended. Those wordings definitely meant that the joint electorate system would be intro duced only after those conditions had been practically ful
filled. Separate representation would not be given up
merely on the Hindus accepting the conditions. But hardly a year has elapsed that Mr. Jinnah has been dis illusioned. The Nehru-Report, without so much as accept ing them in toto, not to say of practically conforming to them, has rather rejected the separate electorate system. It does not even refer to these proposals.
One section of the Muslim community notwithstand ing grave dangers ahead, with the sole desire to see peace established in India, was prepared to forego communal electorates and even to incur the displeasure of their own community, yet the fate which has been meted out to their proposals by the Nehru Committee has been already related. When such is the state of things at the very beginning, and at a time when in the enthusiasm for the attainment of Swaraj the Hindus are earnestly desirous of winning over the Muslims, what will be the state of affairs, when India will grow free and Hindus will have all powers in their own hands, may better be imagined than described.
The fourth Muslim proposal related to the introduc tion of Reforms in the N. W. F. Provinces and Baluchistan, and the constitution of Sindh into a separate province with representative governmtnt. The Nehru Commii:tee has acceded to the extension of Reforms in the N. W. F. Provinces. Its intention is not clear with regard to Balu chistan. With regard to Sindh it stipulates that so long as the province cannot shoulder its financial responsibility or its inhabitants do not undertake to bear the charges, the province should not be made autonomous. Aparently these conditions are reasonable ; for when a province is financially incompetent how can it be constituted into an autonomous territory? They will leave the Muslims free to urge that when Sindh because of financial incompet ency cannot be made autonomous, separate representa tion also cannot be dispensed with, for which the separa.. tion of Sindh was a precedent condition. I, however, propose to bring to light what is between the lines of this apparent simple recommendations of the Nehru-Re .. port. The word ' responsibility ' is so comprehensive that by a mere specification of it, Sindh could be per petually kept out of autonomy. By 'responsibility', it may mean a simple system of administration, which I am sure Sindh is financially competent enough to adopt. Or, it may mean some such �xpensive system as may be impossible for a small province like Sindh to manage, and then the possibility of its growing into a separate province will be precluded for ever. I have grounds to suspect that by responsibility is here meant something more than the need or the competence of the province. The Nehru-Report mentions that it received a combined memorial from the Hindu, Parsee and Muslim communi ties of Sind urging the necessity of constituting the pro vince into a separate entity.
With regard to the finan cial question it had suggested that ' the coat should be cut according to the cloth," i.e., they should be given an administration compatible with their financial strength, and the matter should not be postponed for long pending economic betterment. But the committee observes that it could not take the declaration as the final solution of the financial problem ( vide p. 69 of the Nehru Report ). The inference is clear that what is intended is to recom mend an administrative machinery for Sindh which it is un equal to bear. And since the people of Sindh could not agree to shoulder such an administration because that would mean for them in its present status an economic loss instead of an economic advancement, the question of separation would naturally have to be dropped altogether. This view is further strengthened by the attitude of Pandit Nehru when, in regard to the motion for the separation of Sindh proposed to have been moved in the Bombay Legislative Council, he advised the Congress party to oppose such a motion in case the Muslim members in sisted upon moving the same.
The fifth demand related to language. This demand has been altogether ignored by the Nehru Committee. It cannot, of course, contend that it is a minor matter. That certainly it is not. The future advance or fall of the Muslims lies linked with it. If the future Government of India were to discard Urdu, within a few years the few places which the Muslims still fill at present will be taken away from them, and their peculiar culture will be lost. Even assuming that it was an uni,riportant matter, the importance attached to it by the party interested cannot be lost sight of. If the Muslims attach to the question of Urdu so serious an importance and consider it to be a question of life and death for the community it does not behove others to treat it lightly. Elsewhere II propose to show that the question of language is not a minor question and that it is not peculiar to India, also that in other countries a very great importance has been attached to this question and special laws have been en acted relating to it which have been incorporated in the constitution of the land.