Text
The Nehru Report and Muslim Rights, Part 8
The sixth demand relates to non-interference in matters both religious and economic. The Nehru--Report is not clear on this point also. The importance and magnitude of this question have been obscured in a mass of words. The Report states under the heading '' Funda mental Rights '' :-'' Freedom of conscience and the free profession and practice of religion are, subject to public order or morality, hereby guaranteed to every person." These words hardly embrace the Mus1im demand. The Hindus always create disturbance over cow-slauethter.
According to this rule their disturbance may prov!de justification to prohibit cow-sacrifice.
• Similarly nothing occurs in the Report about • Tab ligh, i.e., preaching of religion. This law gives every citizen a right to proclaim his religion but it does not give him the right to preach it to others with freedom. The law may at any time be interpreted to mean that, as ' Tabligh • leads to a disturbance of the ccuP.try' s peace, it is therefore banned. You may proclaim your religion but cannot invite others to accept it. Similarly the law could be held to mean that as conversion leads to a disturbance of the peace, it is henceforth prohibited. The law of the liberty of conscience cannot prevent such an interpretation, because it is solely concerned with belief. Conversion means abandoning one community and joining the rank of another. Even if it were not so interpreted, at least a law may be enacted to the effect that no person can change his religion without a certi ficate from the Magistrate. It may be argued in favour of such action that in this way the chance of compulsion and the use of force will be prevented. Such a procedure is bound to stop religious conversions as is the case at present in several States. Firstly, because the people cannot undergo such a tedious procedure. If they apply for such permit then they are subjected to such questions as, who was the preacher, what was the manner of his preaching, whether force was anplied. and similar other questions, under the stress of which they are compelled to give up the idea of changing their religion. Instances are not wanting, and I am prepared to prove them. In short, the Article relating to religion has several loop holes which can serve to unduly restrict religious free dom. Thus the Nehru-Report fails to meet the Muslim demand from this view-point also. To my mind it actu ally runs counter to that demand. For in the chapter on " Fundamental Rights" in Article 12 it says:-" No person attending any school, receiving state aid or other public money shall be compelled to attend the religious instruction that may be given in the school.''
If the above article be read in the light of the fact
that it is quite possible that under the future Government of India, a law may be enacted to the effect that no private school will be permitted which refuse to accept
Government aid and to conform to Government rules, the constitutional law does in no way forbid its enactment,
-if such a legislation is passed, then it will mean that
the Muslims will be gradually estranged from their reli.. gion. Every religion and every religious institution is entitled to make religious education compulsory for its own followers, and this does by no means amount to compulsion. 'It would be compulsion if one were to com pel people of other p�rsuations to follow instructions in one's religion. In fact, this law could in several respects be made an instrument for hampering Muslim reli gious education. To say that it will operate equally against the Hindus would amount to a betrayal of utter ignor ance of religions. Islam, unlike Hinduism, is a religion that has definite restrictions, a knowledge of which can be obtained only through proper education. Hinduism, on the other hand, is a political religion. A man alto gether unfamiliar even with the A. B. C. of the Vedas and its teachings, and following son-ie peculiar views of his own, may claim to be as good a Hindu as the most erudite master of the Vedas.
The seventh demand is that questions growing out of mutual communal distrust, and solution whereof is essential in the interest of the minorities should be in corpora ted in the constitutional laws, so that their revi sion might not be easily effected. I am not aware whether any community other than our own has urged this demand. Nevertheless it is a most important de mand. But the Nehru Committee has chosen to ignore it. The demand was implied in the Lucknow Pact but was not embodied in legal language. The wordings were
rather vague.
From the above it is clear that not one of the seven points of the Muslims has the Nehru Committee acceded to in full. Some of them it has wholly rejected, while a few have been accepted only partially. It is strange that in the latter instances the modifications have in every case defeated the very object of the demand, and both its acceptance and non-acceptance have thus grown equally ineffective. The question now arises that when the Nehru Committee has rejected even those terms which the moderate section of the Muslim community consi dered to be their minimum demands, can its findings be regarded to be just and fair? Can the Muslims hope to live in peace in India by accepting the same? I have given my most anxious thought to the question, and come to the conclusion that they cannot. 11 propose to discuss it in the chapters that follow. In order to make it easily intelligible I have divided the subject under differ
ent heads.
1J3 EFORE saying a word in justification of Muslim de-
mands, let me disabuse the Muslim P').ind of a danger ous idea, lest it should lead them to take such a step as it may not be possible for them to retrace and nothing but heart...burning may be the consequence thereof. It is urged to come to some decision novv to be modified later on, if any injurious aspect issues out of it. I understand that most of the 1\1ussalmans feel in the same strain, and as a result of this. there prevails among them a false, and, I would say, a danger ous sense of security. If the Muslims only realised that it· would be beyond their power to alter any decision they might make to ... day about S\varaj, they would not be so hasty, and before taking a step fraught with so many dangers, they would try to answer a thousand ques .. tions and discover various means of retreat. But it is most deplorable that some people have knowingly or un knowingly given the community an assurance that in case the present decision prove injurious in any respect, it will be possible to alter it in future. The Mussalmans are thus under this impression that the proposed changes will be nothing ;more than an experiment, that in case of defects coming to light, a new scheme will have to be devised. But I would tell them with all emphasis at my command that things stand quite th� other way. When a step has been taken to-day, there will be no going back to-morrow. It will be far easier for them to get all their demands acceded to now ; but after Swaraj has once been attained it will be simply impossible.
What is Dominion Status ?
The Moslems should well understand that what the Nehru Committee and every Indian demand to-day is Dominion Status, i.e., a sort of semi-independent Govern.. ment. 1lt is worth their while to know what Dominion Status signifies, because without such a knowledge Muslims will not be able to realise that by their half hearted efforts to get their demands accepted, they are not only ruining their future generations but are also cut ting at the very root of Islam, and preparing the ground for the Spanish tragedy in India. Heaven protect us !
Dominion Self--Gover.:1.ment is a ver�r recent phrase, meaning that form of independent Government as obtains in Canada, Australia, South Africa, Newzealand and from the last five years in South Ireland. After various dis putes, and agreements up till the outbreak of the War the Dominions had acquired the following rights:-
The British Parliament shall enact no legislation re lating to the internal administration of the Dominions, the Dominions reserving to themselves the right to legis late in matters internal. A Dominion may at any time deprive its own citizens of the right of appeal to the British Privy Council, i.e., it can declare the judgment of its own Supreme Court to be final. Every Dominion has the right to maintain its own military, naval forces for the protection of its own territories. It may also alter its constitution by a majority decision of its own parliament, even if such constitution was passed by the British Parliament. The British Government has the right to veto any law enacted by a Dominion Govern ment, but this privilege is not to be exercised except in matters which concern not exclusively that particular Dominion but affects other parts of the British Empire.
It was decided in the Imperial Conference held in 1911 that British Policy in respect of Dominions will in future be, that they will enjoy complete independence in local administration without any limitation, and Great ·Britain will not inter£ere unless a Dominion has done something prejudicial to its loyal relations with. the Im perial Government ( vide Law of Constitution). But in this interval fresh developments have taken place and Dominions have been givea further priYileges. Though formally Great Britain still possesses the right to veto any law passed by a Dominion, this privilege has been practically surrendered. In f 920, the Queensland Gov ernment passed a certain law against which the local land holders as well as the British landholders registered their protests, declaring the law to be a transgression of the law of the constitution involving their forced ejection from lands by the Government. The British Govern ment, however, refused to interven.e, as it could not interfere in the internal affairs of the Dominions.
In one thing alone Dominions entirely depend upon Great Britain and that is territorial expansion.
Regarding foreign relations also, since the Creat War, the Dominions have achieved a good dea1 of free dom and subject to Great Britain's sanction. A Dominion can make treaties with other countries. In the Anglo Irish treaty of 1924, Great Britain recognised the right of the Dominions to remain neutral in any war that Britain might declare against any other people, their obligation to join being confined only to cases when another nat�on 'had initiated the offensive. In the former case the Domi nion Parliaments would have the right to decide whether