Cover Page
The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam, Part 14
87 Maududi, 'Irtidad ki Saza Islami Qanun meiń' page 15. The Ahadith are
given on page 88. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 104 === 88 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam sa Prophet , he too was forgiven by his great mercy. What happened was that ‘Abdullah bin Abi Sarh not only apostatized but went too far in mischief and was involved in combats with the Muslims. After the fall of Mecca, the Holy Prophetsa included him among those people about whom he had stated that they would not be pardoned. He sought refuge from Hadrat ‘Uthmanra who got forgiveness for him. It is thus written:
"Ibni ‘Abbas relates that ‘Abdullah bin Sa‘d bin Abi Sarh used to be a scribe of the Holy Prophetsa but was led astray by Satan and he joined the non-believers. On the day of the fall of Mecca, the Holy Prophetsa ordered that he be killed. Hadrat ‘Uthmanra requested for his pardon, which was approved and he was thus forgiven."88
88 Sunan Abi Da’ud, Awwalu Kitabil Hududi, Babul Hukmi fi Manirtadda.
Hadith No. 4358. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 105 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 89 Similarly Sunan al-Nasa’i states:
"On the day of the fall of Mecca, the Holy Prophetsa granted general pardon to all except four men and two women and said: kill them even if they are found seeking refuge clutching the drapes of the Ka’ba. [Their names were:] ‘Ikrama bin Abu Jahl, ‘Abdullah bin Khatal, Miqyas bin Subabata and ‘Abdullah bin Abi Sarh…"89 This is the real account. However, the situation that emerges by the reasoning of these scholars is as if untill the fall of Mecca, Hadrat ‘Uthmanra was unaware that the Holy Qur’an had stated death as the punishment of apostasy, that it would be criminal to give refuge to such a person and would be strictly against the teachings of the Holy Qur’an. That is to say that those who make this deduction disregard that they are in fact making a gross allegation against Hadrat ‘Uthmanra in that he first gave refuge to ‘Abdullah bin
89 Sunan Al-Nasa’i, Kitabul Muharabati [Tahrimuddami], Al-Hukmu Fil
Murtaddi, Hadith No. 4072. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 106 === 90 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam Abi Sarh and then had the pluck to present him to the Holy Prophetsa requesting that he be initiated into Islam. That the Holy Prophetsa did not even remark: "‘Uthman, what misdeed are you committing? Do you not know my sense of honour concerning the limits set by Allah? Do you not remember when I was asked to make a concession for a thief, I had sworn by God that even if my own daughter Fatima had committed the offence of theft I would have had her hands cut off, because there can be no concession in matters of the limits set by Allah. How dare you make a recommendation to me about him!"90 Despite all this the Holy Prophetsa did not even once say any of this. Rather when Hadrat ‘Uthmanra made the appeal, he turned his face away. At the second request he kept silent, at the third request, again he kept silent. At the fourth request, by extending his hand, the "Mercy for Mankind", accepted the initiation of that person91.
ANOTHER INCIDENT:
In connection with this event, there is another small incident that the scholars present to corroborate their inference. After accepting this man’s initiation, the
90 See Sahih Bukhari Kitabul Hudud, Babu Iqamatil Hududi ‘Alashsharifi
Walwadi‘i, H. No. 6787. [Publisher] 91 Sunan Al-Nasa’i, ibid. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 107 === 91 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam sa Holy Prophet by way of complaint said to his Companionsra: 'Were you not aware that this man was included in the list of those who I was not going to forgive? Why—what was it that stopped you from killing him?' This happened two or three times. The Companionsra submitted 'O Prophet of Godsa you should have given us a signal with your eyes. The Holy Prophetsa said, 'It is against the dignity of a Prophetsa to commit deception with the eyes. Whatever he says, he says it clearly and openly.' That is to say, if he wanted to have him killed, he would have told them to do so. He would have never done it in a deceptive way.92 It is a shame that some ulema try to deduce from this straightforward matter their own conclusions by crooked reasoning. Not to commit deception of the eye only means that erroneous ways of this kind were beneath his moral greatness. If he had wanted to have him killed he would have clearly told them to rise and kill him. He only wanted to find out as to what it was that, despite having full knowledge of his directive, made them refrain from killing him? The question arises that had the Holy Qur’an clearly directed the punishment of apostasy as death, would the Holy Prophetsa have made concessions to the
92 Assununul Kubra by Abu Bakr Ahmad bin Husain Al-Baihqi, Part 8, Kitabul Murtaddi, Babu Man Qala Fil Murtaddi Yustatabu Makanahu Fa’in Taba Wa’illa Qutila, Page 205, published by Nashrusunna, Multan, Pakistan. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 108 === 92 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam prescribed punishment? Most certainly not. It cannot be entertained even for a moment about the Holy Prophetsa that he would have deviated even slightly from the corporal punishment set by the Holy Qur’an. The heavens and the earth could evaporate, but this could have never been possible.
SECOND HADITH:
Maulana Maududi Sahib has also mentioned another Hadith in his book, from which he deduces that death is the punishment for apostasy. He says: A woman by the name of Ummi Ruman (or Ummi Marwan) apostatized. The Holy Prophetsa ordered that she be presented with Islam one more time. If she repented, it would be good; otherwise she was to be killed93. Another Hadith by Baihaqi in this regard is that as she refused to accept Islam she was killed. However, in 'Nailul Autar', Imam Muhammad bin ‘Ali Shaukani writes regarding this Hadith: that the Isnad of both Ahadith* are 94 feeble . Similarly, ‘Allama Shamsul Haq ‘Azim Abadi also
93 Irtidad ki Saza Islami Qanun Meiń – pp. 11-19. See the reference95 below.
The Hadith is recorded in Sunan Dar Qutni. [Publisher] * The plural is used for this Hadith because it comes through two sources.
[Publisher] 94 Nailul Autar – Sharhu Muntaqal Akhbar Min Ahadithi Sayyidil Akhyar by
Muhammad bin ‘Ali Ash-Shaukani, Part 7, Page 217. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 109 === 93 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam writes in his commentary of this Hadith that its credentials are weak. He writes: The Isnad 95 of both Ahadith are week . When nothing is found in the Holy Qur’an, when nothing is found in correct and reliable Ahadith, still Maududi Sahib, relying on the above Hadith—the authenticity of which is doubted by great scholars of Hadith—are bent or declaring that apostates should be killed. The same is true about other ulema who share their verdict on this issue with Maududi Sahib.
THIRD TRADITION:
Maududi Sahib has presented another Hadith: Hadrat Abu Musa Ash‘rira relates that having appointed him as the Governor of Yemen, later the Holy Prophetsa sent Mu‘adh bin Jablra as his assistant. Upon arrival Mu‘adhra announced: ‘People! I am an envoy of the Prophet of Godsa to you.’ Abu Musara arranged for a cushion for him to recline on. Meanwhile a man was presented who had once been a Jew and had converted to Islam but had then reverted to Judaism. Mu‘adhra said, 'Most certainly I shall not sit until this man is killed. This is the judgment of Allah and His Messenger.' Mu‘adhra repeated this three times. Only
95 Atta‘liqul Mughni ‘Ala Sunani Dar Qutni, Kitabul Hudud Waddiyat,
Part III, page 119 footnote on Hadith No.122, Published by Daru Nashril Kutubil Islamiyati, Lahore. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 110 === 94 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam after the man was killed that Mu‘adhra sat down96. Here, on the one hand Mu‘adhra says that this is the judgment of Allah and His Messenger. (However, he does not mention as to when this judgment was passed and what was its wording.) On the other hand neither is there a mention of any such Divine decree in the Holy Qur’an nor is there a record of any such verdict of the Holy Prophetsa in Ahadith that as a consequence of just apostasy one should be killed. This is why it is more credible to deduce from what Mu‘adhra said that it was his own reasoning, his personal opinion. From the Holy Qur’an and Ahadith only this can be confirmed. Then again, no detail is given regarding the incident, as to why the Jew was brought there? What did he do? Each aspect of the narration is ambiguous and is open to supposition and conjecture. There is the possibility that he was caught for some crime other than that of apostasy and was brought there for that reason. Or that he might have engaged in combat against Islam. As all these facts are vague, so reliance on an ambiguous Hadith—which is merely based on the inference of a Companionra—in such an important issue and to pass judgment contrary to the manifest verses of the Holy Qur’an is extremely unjust. It is a universal principle that when the Holy Qur’an is definitive about an issue, even if an authentic
96 Irtidad ki Saza Islami Qanun Meiń, page 14, See Sunan Al-Nasa’i Kitabul
Muharabati [Tahrimuddami], Al-Hukmu fil Murtaddi, Hadith No. 4071. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 111 === 95 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam Hadith is found against it, which seems to openly contradict the evident and definitive injunction in the Holy Qur’an, it is the requisite of taqwa97 to dismiss the apparently authentic Hadith. Moreover, we do not find any mention whether the Holy Prophetsa was informed of this incidence, and if he was, how did he respond to it? Quite apart from this, there are many other Ahadith, which very clearly negate this subject, e.g., the ones I have already mentioned above. So, verses in the Holy Qur’an, the Sunna, history of Islam and the consistency with which the Holy Prophetsa did not ever give orders for the killing of an apostate while he was alive. He went on living, despite his apostacy, till he met his natural death; or was deprived of his life for reasons other than those of apostasy. All this proves that such an important belief can not be founded on so weak an argument.