Cover Page
The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam, Part 15
THE SIDDIQI ERA AND APOSTASY
I shall now talk about the Khilafat (Caliphate) of Hadrat Abu Bakrra. In most books that are written on the topic of death as the punishment of apostasy that you will come across, you will notice that the scholars, having discussed the Holy Qur’an and Hadith in a cursory manner swiftly move on to the period of
97 Fear of God. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 112 === 96 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam Hadrat Abu Bakrra. They seek refuge in that period to support their beliefs and maintain that it is Siddiqi Sunna. In short they overlook the Sunna of Muhammadsa and begin to discuss Siddiqi Sunna.
THE REALITY OF THE SO-CALLED 'SIDDIQI SUNNA':
In actual fact 'Siddiqi Sunna' is not the practice that they associate with Hadrat Abu Bakrra. On the contrary, history clearly negates that Hadrat Abu Bakrra had anyone got killed only for the crime of apostasy or that he ever had someone declared apostate and had him thus killed despite his being known as a Muslim, despite his reciting the Kalima, despite his observing of Salat facing the Ka‘ba of the Muslims and despite his believing in the payment of Zakat. The fact of the matter is that he only opposed those apostates who, along with apostatizing, raised open revolt against the Islamic government and had driven out its governors and administrators from their regions and were extremely cruel to the Muslims and had them brutally murdered. Abu Bakrra battled against these wretches because these barbarians had commenced the cruelty and fighting and had started to murder innocent Muslims. === PDF-Seite 113 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 97 HISTORICAL VERIFICATION OF THE REVOLT BY THE APOSTATES:
The history books and biographies relate the crisis of apostasy and revolt as follows:
1. "This crisis of revolt and apostasy spread like fire and within a few days had reached from one end of Arabia to the other. The rebellious apostates expelled the Muslim administrators and inflicted grievous torture on the faithful Muslim of their region and brutally murdered them."98
It was not that Hadrat Abu Bakrra had ordered to have them killed as a result of being informed of their apostasy. Rather these cruel wretehes were killing the innocent Muslims for what was for them the crime of apostasy on the part of Muslims in that they (the Muslims) had left their (the apostates) faith and had accepted Islam. They were threatening to kill Muslims if they did not revert to their original faith. It were the apostates who, subjecting Muslims to all kinds of torture, were punishing them for their alleged 'apostasy'. To bring these torturous punishments to a halt, Hadrat Abu Bakrra mobilised his army and marched on against them for the crime of raising general revolt against the bone fide Muslim
98 Dastani Islam, Part 2, Khilafati Rashida, p23 by Shaikh Muhammad Iqbal
M.A., Published by the Panjab Press, Lahore 1970. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 114 === 98 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam government. The author writes:
"Those who could save their lives fled to Medina and sought refuge there. The rebels did not settle on this and started preparing to attack the centre of Khilafat. During this time, per chance ‘Amr bin al-‘Asra returned from Bahrain. He observed that the apostate armies had camped from Yemen to Medina. The enemy’s army was innumerable like the sand of Arabia and confronting them were the handful Muslims with no battle equipment."99
2. Another historian writes:
"Soon after the haven of our celebrated master was lifted, signs of rebellion against the religion of Allah started to emerge from the length and breadth of Arabia. Only the inhabitants of Mecca, Medina and Ta‘if remained steadfast. This crisis of apostasy and rebellion spread like wildfire and reached from one end of Arabia to the other within days. The apostates expelled Islamic administrators and started mercilessly killing true Muslims. Those who could flee took refuge in Medina. Seeing the success of the Holy Prophetsa a few tried their luck at homemade prophethood. Many
99 Ibid p23. === PDF-Seite 115 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 99 false prophets arose in different tribes. Among them was a famous person called Tulaiha bin Khuwailad. His real name was Talha but the Muslim derogatorily called him Tulaiha. He belonged to the tribe of Banu Asad that was an old rival of Quraish. Tulaiha had assumed prophethood during the lifetime of the Holy Prophetsa."100
The assertion of the author that Tulaiha had claimed to be a prophet in the life of the Holy Prophetsa needs our special attention. The ulema say, 'Look how Abu Bakrra attacked the false prophets.' However, they cannot say 'Look how the Holy Prophetsa raised arms against the false prophets'. This demolishes the whole edifice which they have built on false promises and wrong beliefs. Besides some other claimants of prophethood, Tulaiha had claimed prophethood during the lifetime of the Holy Prophetsa. But he (the Holy Prophetsa) did not give any orders for the killing of Tulaiha. He did not attack any claimant of prophethood. Regrettably, these crooked scholars commit atrocity upon atrocity. They have no fear of God as regards the foul assaults they make on Islam and do not even desist from attacking the person of the Holy Prophetsa.
100 Islami Dasturi Hayat by Ghulam Ahmad Hariri, pp. 402-403, Published
by Polymer Publication, Rahat Market, Urdu Bazar, Lahore. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 116 === 100 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam The author adds:
"However, at that time his deception did not work. After the death of the Holy Prophetsa the entire tribe came under his trap. He abolished the prostration in the Salat on the pretext that it hurts. He also cancelled Zakat. As a result, those who rejected Zakat became his disciples. Tulaiha organised a huge army and sent it to Medina. Hadrat Abu Bakrra came to battle the army and the attackers fled!"101
Thus until such time that Tulaiha sent the army to Medina, Hadrat Abu Bakr did not even contemplate that the punishment of a false prophet should be to fight against him.
3. The summary of the account of this period in the History of Ibni Khaldun* is that apart from the tribes of Quraish and Thaqif, the news of the apostasy of various Arab populations reached Medina. The crisis of the rebellion created by Musailma reached a critical point. Similarly, Ta’i and Asad tribes gathered around Tulaiha. The tribe of Ghatfan also apostatized. The people of Hawazan tribe refused to pay Zakat. From Yemen and Yamama the rebels expelled the rulers and administrators appointed by