Cover Page

The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam, Part 16

101 Ibid. * ‘Abdur Rahman Ibni Khaldun 1332-1426 CE. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 117 === 101 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam sa the Holy Prophet . After the death of the Holy Prophetsa, Hadrat Abu Bakrra tried to counsel the rebels by means of negotiations through emissaries and via correspondence as well. He waited for the army to return that had gone out under the command of Usama. However, with the intent to attack, the rebels advanced towards Medina. They encamped at Al-Abraq and Dhul Qarsa just outside Medina and sent a message to Hadrat Abu Bakrra that they were willing to say the Salat but wanted payment of Zakat to be dispensed with. Hadrat Abu Bakrra refused to agree to this demand and appointed Hadrat ‘Ali, Zubair and ‘Abdullah bin Mas‘udra to stand guard at various outward points of Medina. The people of Medina started gathering in the mosque. A delegation of the rebels got back to their comrades and informed them that the number of Muslims present in Medina was very small. Consequently, the rebels attacked the outskirts of Medina. In response Hadrat Abu Bakrra took the Muslims, who had gathered in the mosque, and they went out on camelbacks to confront the enemy. The enemy retreated. However, even in retreat, it employed different techniques to startle the camels of the Muslims. As a result, the camels ran uncontrollably towards Medina. Although the Muslims did not suffer any casualties, yet the enemy deemed them to be weak and sent a message to their rebel comrades to come and join them in === PDF-Seite 118 === 102 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam attacking the Muslims as they were in a weak position. Upon this Hadrat Abu Bakrra gathered the Muslims at dawn and went very near to where the enemy was and attacked them. Even before the sun had risen, the enemy retreated. Upon return, the tribes of Banu Dhubyan and ‘Abs as well as other tribes began killing the unarmed Muslims of their region. In response Hadrat Abu Bakrra vowed that he would definitely take revenge for each and every Muslim."102

4. In Tarikh Tabri, the related circumstances are summarised as follows: As soon as the news of the illness of the Holy Prophetsa was out, it was also reported that Musailma had taken over Yamama and Aswad ‘Ansi had taken over Yemen. Soon Tulaiha also claimed prophethood, thus becoming a standard bearer of rebellion. He gathered an army and went towards a place called Sumaira’ to fight the Muslims. The populace followed him in great numbers and the situation thus became critical. Moreover, Banu Rabi‘a announced rebellion and apostasy in the region of Bahrain, and claimed that they would restore monarchy into the dynasty of Mundhar once again and appointed Mundhar bin

102 ‘Abdur Rahman Ibni Khaldun – Tarikh Ibni Khaldun, Vol. II, pp. 401-

414, Daru Ahya’it Turathil ‘Arabi, Beirut, Labnan. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 119 === 103 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam Naghman their king. Soon afterwards, the governors of the Holy Prophetsa sent reports that the high and low had rebelled in all the regions and the rebels were persecuting the Muslims in all sorts of ways. In the beginning Hadrat Abu Bakrra continued to have a dialogue with the rebels in the manner that the Holy Prophetsa used to hold negotiations with the rebels through the emissaries. However, the tribes of ‘Abs and Dhubyan started advancing their army towards Medina while brutally murdering the unarmed Muslims of their region. The other tribes followed suit. At this Hadrat Abu Bakr vowed that in return of every single Muslim killed, he would kill one rebel. In fact he would kill more. Subsequently, that is exactly what he did. He sent a message to Khalid bin Walidra that promptly after the capture, he was to kill a each rebel who had killed a Muslim in a most exemplary way. Before his demise, the Holy Prophetsa had sent Hadrat ‘Amr bin al-‘Asra to Jaifar (‘Umman). When he returned after the death of the Holy Prophetsa the Muslims gathered around him to hear the situation of the rebels. He recounted that the rebels were encamped along the entire route of Daba to Medina. The instigation of rebellion and apostasy took place in the time of the Holy Prophetsa by Aswad ‘Ansi in the region of Yemen. The tribe of Madhhaj joined them and the havoc of its rebellion started spreading like wildfire. In addition to its infantry, the === PDF-Seite 120 === 104 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam rebellious army that joined him had 700 mounted men. He warned the administrators of the Islamic government thus: 'O, usurpers! return our country to us.

You may keep whatever wealth you have accumulated but get out of our land.' The Muslim administrator was then replaced with ‘Amr bin Hazam and Khalid bin Sa‘id bin Al-‘As as the rulers. Later, Aswad took his army to attack San‘a’ and having murdered Shaihar bin Badhan, who was the administrator appointed by the Holy Prophetsa, seized San‘a and murdered the other Muslims. Hadrat Ma‘adh bin Jablra escaped and saved his life. Once he reached Ma’rib, he informed Hadrat Abu Musa al-Ash‘ari of the situation. They both came towards Hadrimaut and thus the entire country of Yemen came in the clutches of Aswad. His government was established there and his power increased. The Muslims eventually sent him hell- bound in a battle at Yamama. Tulaiha made a claim to prophethood and having gathered the rebels got entrenched at a place called Sumaira’. The number of people who followed him was so great that the ground could not accommodate them. They divided themselves in two groups and sent their delegations to Medina. Hadrat Abu Bakrra refused to accept their demands. The delegation returned to its comrades and told them that the Muslims were very few in number and suggested to carry out an attack. Following these negotiations Hadrat Abu Bakrra === PDF-Seite 121 === 105 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam appointed small contingents to guard the fringes of Medina. He informed the Muslims that an epidemic of rebellion had spread all over the country and the delegation of the rebels had figured out the scantiness of the Muslims and that it was a matter of conjecture whether the enemy would attack during the night or would wait till daybreak and that the Muslims should be fully prepared. Only three days had elapsed that the rebel army attacked Medina at night. Hadrat Abu Bakrra gathered the Muslims and came forth to battle and made the enemy retreat. The majority of the tribe of Banu Hanifa joined Musailma. He seized Yamama and expelled its governor, Hadrat Thumama bin Athalra who had been appointed by the Holy Prophetsa.

Musailma gathered a lot of strength and force. A woman by the name of Sajah, who had made a claim to prophethood, came forth to battle with him. He was apprehensive of her and having reconciled with her, persuaded her into battle with Muslims in these words: 'Had the Quraish (Muslims) been fair, they would have kept half the country and handed over the other half to us. However, they have been oppressive to us. Will you be willing to marry me, so that we can both get together with our tribes and swallow the entire Arab tribes.' He thus married Sajah and came out to fight the Muslims. His army === PDF-Seite 122 === 106 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam numbered 40,000. Hadrat Khalid bin Walidra confronted him and defeated him.103 5. Similarly it is also recorded in the history of Al Khamis:

"Majority of Banu Hanifa joined Musailma, the great liar. He seized Yamama and expelled the governor of the Holy Prophetsa. He (the Governor) informed the Holy Prophetsa about it; after the passing away of the Holy Prophetsa he informed Hadrat Abu Bakrra. In response to this Hadrat Abu Bakrra sent Hadrat Khalid bin Walidra with a huge army to battle Musailma.104

In short, the Companions did not fight Musailma the liar, and his tribe of Banu Hanifa only because of their apostasy. Rather, they fought him for the crime of rebellion, because Musailma was a rebel and he had declared war against the Muslims.

6. In addition ‘Allama ‘Aini in his Sharhi Sahih al- Bukhari writes:

103 Tarikhul Tabari by Muhammad bin Jarir Al-Tabari, Vol. III (the account

of 11AH), Published by Darul M‘arif, Egypt 1962. [Publisher] 104 Tarikhul Khamis part pertaining to the account 11AH, by Hussain bin

Muhammad Dubnul Hasan al-Dayyar Bakri, Published by Mu’ssasa Sha‘ban, Beirut. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 123 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 107

"Hadrat Abu Bakrra only fought against those who refused to pay Zakat because they stopped Zakat through the sword and made war against the Muslims."105

STRANGE POINT WORTH NOTING

It is also documented in the historical records of Al-Tabari and Ibni Khaldun that:

"After the war, when Hadrat Abu Bakrra was victorious over the rebels, some of them were made prisoners and some slaves."106

If the punishment of apostasy was indeed death and was in fact the reason for which Hadrat Abu Bakrra fought, and if despite repentance, Islam does not propose any other punishment for apostasy, then why did Hadrat Abu Bakrra forget this matter at that time? What right did he have to oppose an evidently clear command of the Islamic Sharia? If God had ordained

105 ‘Allama Mahmud bin Ahmad ‘Aini, ‘Umdatul Qari, Sharhu Sahih Bukhari, Vol. 14, Page 81, Kitabu Istatabatil Murtaddin wal Mu‘anidin wa Qitalihim wa Ma Nusibu Ilar Riddati. [Publisher] 106 Op cit. === PDF-Seite 124 === 108 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam that apostates certainly were to be killed and not given a respite of more than three days, then, despite capturing them for this very crime, despite vanquishing them, why were they not killed but were made slaves?

THE KILLING OF A FEMALE APOSTATE:

Maulana Maududi has also mentioned a female apostate called Ummi Qirfa:

"In the era of Hadrat Abu Bakrra a woman by the name of Ummi Qirfa had apostatized after accepting Islam. Hadrat Abu Bakrra demanded repentance from her but she did not comply. Hadrat Abu Bakrra had her killed. (Darul Qutni, Baihaqi.)"107

·

10 of 10 left today