Cover Page
The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam, Part 17
The impression given is that she was killed only because of apostasy. Although records do not mention the point that she was killed merely for apostasy. However, he is insistent that the killing of Ummi Qirfa was a link of this sequence. Although the reality is:
107 Irtidad ki Saza Islami Qanun Mein, Page 18. See Assununul Kubra, by
Abu Bakr Ahmad Binil Hussain Bin ‘Ali Al-Baihaqi, Part 8, Kitabul Murtaddi, Babu Qatli Manirtadda ‘Anil Islami Idha Thabuta ‘Alaihi Rajulan Kana Awimra’tan, published by Nashrus Sunna, Multan, Pakistan, page 202.[Publisher] === PDF-Seite 125 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 109
"The killing of this woman was ordered because she had thirty sons and she would constantly instigate and incite all thirty sons against war with the Muslims. In order to break the might of these brothers."
Thus the mother was killed for the crime of instigation, only to give the clear message to her sons that if their mother incites them against Muslims and if they think that they are strong and powerful, they should, if they can, save their mother. Yet, after their mother was killed, their lives were saved to show to the world that if by taking one life a mischief can be subverted, then only that life should be taken.108 From the angle of ‘Ilmi Darayat*, too, this Hadith is not acceptable: An old woman, mother of thirty sons who, too, were apostates, is killed and the sons were not called to account or killed along with their mother.
108 Al-Mabsut by Shamsuddin al-Sarkhasi, 2nd Edition, Vol. 10, p110, Published by Matba‘atus Sa‘ada, Egypt. [Publisher] * Judging the authenticity of a Hadith on the basis of its contents. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 126 === 110 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam
A TRADITION FROM THE FARUQI ERA:
Let us move on to the circumstances of the era of Hadrat ‘Umarra. The Hadith that Maulana Maududi presents from this era is:
"‘Amr bin al-‘As, Governor of Egypt, wrote to Hadrat Umarra that a man had accepted Islam but became an infidel, returned to Islam, but once again disbelieved. He had repeated that process many a time. Should his Islam be accepted or not? Hadrat ‘Umarra replied that as long as Allah, the Exalted, accepted his Islam, he should keep on doing so. Islam should be presented to him, if he accepted, his life should be spared, otherwise he should be put to death."109*
They deduce from the last bit 'otherwise he should be put to death' that surely the punishment of apostasy was death and that is why Hadrat ‘Umarra said so. If the punishment of apostasy was indeed death, then it was impossible for an austere Khalifa like Hadrat ‘Umarra to give the above-mentioned answer. He would have issued a strict reprimand to the governor as to on what authority he had to grant that 109 Irtidad ki Saza Islami Qanun Mein, Page 18. [Publisher] * The reference is to a Hadith mentioned in Kanzul ‘Ummal, Kitabul Imani
Wal Islami, Min Qismil Af‘al, Al-Faslul Khamis Fi Hukmil Islami, Al- Irtidadu Wa Ahkamuhu Part I, Hadith No. 1463. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 127 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 111 man another chance after his apostasy! He had apostatized not once or twice but several times! Why it was allowed to happen and why he was not killed? Instead, Hadrat ‘Umar directed to allow him to accept Islam as many times as Allah allowed him. That is to say, he could accept Islam as many times he was apprehended, and that it was incumbent upon the ruler to let him off. What we have here is an inference of Hadrat ‘Umarra. But even this inference of Hadrat ‘Umarra does not give the scholars any right over the lives of other Muslims. Hadrat Umarra pronounced that if the man would say that he was a Muslim, then, despite the history of his repeatedly apostatizing, each time on his confession of Islam, he was to let go. He was to decide his own fate. His word, despite the previous pattern, was acknowledged as reliable. No one can say that Hadrat ‘Umarra had said that as the man’s falsehood was proven, because his betrayal was established, therefore, his word should not be paid heed to even if he accepted Islam one more time. So, how does the validity of death as punishment of apostasy is inferred from this Hadith? How can one infer that even if one repents, one should not be forgiven and whenever one apostates one should be killed? === PDF-Seite 128 === 112 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam THE METHODOLOGY TO MEASURE SOUNDNESS OF NARRATIONS:
Moreover, the principle stands firm that the Ahadith or Athar that are in conflict with the well- known practice of the Holy Prophetsa or are against the evidently clear verses of the Holy Qur’an, are not acceptable. The narration under discussion is among Athar because it is a personal deduction of Hadrat Umarra. If a deduction of Hadrat Umarra or even of all the Companionsra (God forbid) is found inconsistent with the practice of the Holy Prophetsa or the Word of the Holy Qur’an, in that instance we should consider the narrator erroneous and not (God forbid) that Hadrat ‘Umarra made an inaccurate inference. For it is impossible that these eminent people who were fostered by the Holy Prophetsa would have disregarded the practice of the Holy Prophetsa. It does not mean that we disagree with Hadrat Umarra. It only means that because this narration is quite clearly in conflict with the Holy Qur’an and Sunna, the narrator of this Athar is wrong. Either someone has misunderstood or someone has told a lie.
THE APOSTATE WAS A FIGHTER:
In addition, there is an indication that this particular person was captured during a battle. Here, one may argue that a person who is captured in a battle === PDF-Seite 129 === 113 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam and the ruler of the time (or the victorious general) decides that he is to be killed because he had fought against him and had killed his comrades, but the captive, to save his life, accepts Islam, then what should be done to that person? It is the legal right of the ruler or victorious general to choose to forgive or order death penalty. Then the moment he renounces Islam he, as it were, presents himself to the authorities to be killed. In such a case it would be obvious that the decision to kill him at the first place was right. In any case a sword would always be hanging over his head. No one can be permitted to escape justified verdict against himself through deception. But this is quite a separate subject and has nothing to do with apostasy.
A TRADITION OF THE ‘ALIRA ERA:
We now enter the era of Hadrat ‘Alira. Here again, a most perilous looking Hadith, (rather a narrative, which has an associated Hadith) is presented. The credibility of this Hadith is apparently very strong. I shall discuss it is some detail. But first I shall quote the Hadith as it is found in Sahih Bukhari. The Hadith is: === PDF-Seite 130 === 114 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam
‘Ikrmah narrates that some zindiqs (The one who conceals unbelief and makes an outward show of belief) were brought to Hadrat ‘Alira. Hadrat ‘Alira ordered to have them burnt alive. Upon hearing this Hadrat Ibni ‘Abbasra said that if it were him he would have never done that because the Holy Prophetsa has clearly prohibited us from inflicting a torment on others that is the sole prerogative of Allah, the Exalted, that is to say, the torment of fire. I would have had him killed, because the Holy Prophetsa had said: 'Kill him who changes his faith.'110
INVESTIGATION OF THE TRADITION:
Prima facie, the above Hadith contains a strong argument in support of killing an apostate. It is found in the authentic books of Ahadith e.g. Bukhari, Tirmadhi, Abu Daud, Nasa’i and Ibni Maja. Because all these books mention it, it could be argued that the Hadith must be reliable and sound. However, the authenticity of a Hadith cannot only be inferred from the fact that it is documented in authentic books of 110 Sahih Bukhari, Kitabu Istitabatil Murtaddina wal Mu‘anidina wa