Cover Page
The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam, Part 18
Qitalihim, Babu Hukmil Murtaddi wal Murtaddati Wastitabatihim, Hadith No. 6922. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 131 === 115 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam Ahadith. There are other criteria, too, to decide about the authenticity of Ahadith. One of these criteria is to judge the credibility of its narrator. The other is to find out whether it is reported by a single narrator (whose credentials are doubtful) at any step of its Isnad* or there are other narrators who support him in the same Sanad or there are other more reliable Isnad of the Hadith than the one in question. When we look at this Hadith on the basis of the above two criteria we find that the renowned scholars, who had dedicated their lives to researching the credibility of Ahadith, had passed the judgement on this Hadith that it is ghrib (i.e. reported by only one narrator, who in the present case happens to be extremely unreliable i.e. ‘Ikrama) and that it belongs to what are technically known as Ahadithi Ahad (that is the Ahadith in the Sanad of which at one are more steps there are three or less than three narrators—in the present case there is only one narrator at the second step of the Sanad—that is the step following the Disciplera of the Holy Prophetsa). The opinion of Maulana ‘Abdul Hayi Lakhnawira is that because Imam Bukhari had reported it from ‘Ikrama, other Muhaddithin111 accepted the Hadith on the authority of Imam Bukhari—because of his high
* A Sanad or Isnad, is the chain of narrators which, starting with a Disciplera sa of the Holy Prophet , comes down to the collector of Hadith e.g. Bukhari. There are obviously various steps in this chain. Some times sanad starts with a Taba‘i, or Taba‘ Taba‘i. [Publisher] 111 The collectors of Ahadith. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 132 === 116 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam stature—without critically examining its credentials112. It is indeed possible that a tradition that has only one narrator can be a correct and reliable Hadith. However, such a tradition cannot be comparable to one that has several narrators. Therefore such ‘ahad’ traditions cannot be relied on in matters pertaining to rights and commitments, obligations and punishments, in particular issues regarding the ‘hudud’, namely, the corporal punishments enjoined by the Holy Qur’an.
THE NARRATOR IS A KHARJI*
It is essential that we further investigate the reputation of the narrator ‘Ikrama. When we evaluate this tradition on this basis, we find out that the narrator was a Kharji, viz. an enemy of Hadrat ‘Alira. Most noted and prominent books dealing with the narrators of traditions state about him that he was such a lowly and wicked man that the Muslims did not even say his funeral prayer. Consequently, the scholars of Hadith who had expertise in ascertaining the soundness of a tradition, came to the conclusion that this tradition is worthless because its narrator was a zindiq and a Khariji and was a supporter of the enemies of Hadrat ‘Alira, in particular during the period when disagreements ensued between Hadrat ‘Alira and
112 Al-Raf‘u wal Takmil, old edition, Lucknow. [Publisher] * Belonging to those who revolted against Hadrat ‘Alira during his Khilafat.
[Publisher] === PDF-Seite 133 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 117 ra Hadrat Ibni ‘Abbas . In the Abbasid period, ‘Ikrama attained the esteem and renown of a pious and God-fearing scholar. It is quite clear that the reason for his renown was his opposition to Hadrat ‘Alira and his support for the Abbasids, on the basis of politics. The Abbasids opposed each person and everything that had anything to do with the progeny of ‘Alira. It is generally noted that in fact the traditions regarding death as punishment of apostasy were born out of the events that took place in Basra, Kufa and Yemen. For the real authorities on Ahadith who resided in Mecca and Medina seem totally oblivious of this tradition. Indeed one cannot overlook the fact that the narrators of this tradition of ‘Ikrama are Iraqis. The reader should not forget the saying of Imam Ta’us bin Qaisan in this respect: "If an Iraqi relates a hundred Ahadith to you, utterly dismiss ninety-nine of these and be suspicious of the remainder." (Sunnan Abu Da’ud) As far as ‘Ikrama being a Kharji, unauthentic and a liar is concerned, you are presented with the following testimonies from eminent compilers of books about the narrators:
1. Adh-Dhahabi states: a) Al-Salt Abu Shu‘aib told us that he asked Muhammad bin Sirin about ‘Ikrama, Ibni Sirin replied: 'I have no trouble that he be === PDF-Seite 134 === 118 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam among the people of the Paradise; however, the fact remains that he is a great liar'. b) "Ya‘qub bin Al-Hadarmi relates about his grandfather that he had said that once ‘Ikrama stood by the door of the mosque and said that all those who were inside the mosque were non-believers. ‘Ikrama subscribed to the principles of the al-Abadia sect." c) "Ibnul Musayyab asked his slave, named Burd, whom he had freed, not to tell lies against him (by reporting false Ahadith on his authority), just as ‘Ikrama tells lies against Ibni ‘Abbas (by reporting false Ahadith on the authority of Ibni ‘Abbas."113 2. Another great scholar writes: a) ‘Abdullah bin al Harith relates: "I went to the house of ‘Ali bin ‘Abdullah bin ‘Abbas and saw that in front of the house of Hadrat Al-Hassanra ‘Ikrama sat shackled. I said to ‘Ali do you not fear God? ‘Ali replied: This wicked man goes about relating false traditions ascribing them to my father." b) Wuhaib says: "I was with Yahya bin Sa‘id Al-Ansari and Ayyub. They mentioned ‘Ikrama. Yahya bin Sa‘id said that ‘Ikrama
113 Muhammad bin Ahmad binil ‘Uthman Adh-Dhahabi (died 748 AH) in
his book Mizanul I‘tidal fi Naqdir Rijal under ‘Ikrama, Maula Ibni ‘Abbas. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 135 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 119 114 was a liar". 3. Hadrat Ibni Hajar al-‘Asqalani writes: a) Yahya bin Mu‘in said: Imam Malik bin Anas did not relate a Tradition narrated by ‘Ikrama for the sole reason that he maintained the school of thought of the Safria sect. b) ‘Ata’ said that he (‘Ikrama) belonged to Abadiyya sect. c) Al-Juzjani said that he asked Imam Ahmad bin Hambl whether ‘Ikrama was ’Abadi? He replied, 'It is said that he was Safri'. d) According to Mus‘ab Al-Zubairi, ‘Ikrama belonged to the Kharji school of thought. e) Ibrahim bin Mundhar has narrated on the authority of Ma‘n bin ‘Isa and some others that Imam Malik did not consider ‘Ikrama trustworthy and would command that the traditions related by him should not be accepted. f) I have heard certain residents of Medina recounting that ‘Ikrama's and Kasir ‘Iza bodies were brought on the same day to the mosque door. People said the funeral prayer of Kusayyar but did not say the funeral prayer of ‘Ikrama. Ahmad has also related a
114 Kitabud Du‘fa’il Kabir by Abu Ja‘far Muhammad bin ‘Amr Al-‘Uqaili
Al-Makki, Part 3, under ‘Ikrama Maula Ibni ‘Abbas, published by Darul Kutubul ‘Ilmiyya, Beirut. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 136 === 120 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam Tradition with similar meanings. g) Hisham bin ‘Abdullah al-Makhzumi relates that he heard Ibni Abi Zai’b that ‘Ikrama was untrustworthy and that he had seen him115.
It is thus most certainly not acceptable to rely on such a Tradition about which it is conclusively proven that its narrator was a great liar and a staunch enemy of Hadrat ‘Alira.
TEXTUAL TESTIMONY:
When we investigate into the words of the Tradition, we find it inaccurate in many ways. 1. There is no doubt that Hadrat ‘Abbasra has his own standing. However, he cannot compete with the status of Hadrat ‘Alira. The latter was the Caliph of the Prophetsa. God had chosen him for Caliphate. It was not possible that while Hadrat ‘Abbasra had a regard for the directive of the Holy Prophetsa Hadrat ‘Alira did not. Even if we acknowledge the Tradition to be correct, the phraseology of Hadrat ‘Abbas does not verify the information, he says: 'As for me, I am never prepared to do so, for this was the clear directive of the
115 Tahdhibul Tahdhib (under ‘Ikrama Maula Ibni ‘Abbas) by Imam Hafiz st Shahabuddin ‘Abu’ul Fadl Ahmad bin ‘Ali bin Hajar al-‘Asqalani, Vol.7, 1 Edition, pp. 263-273, Published by Majlis Da’iratul Ma‘arif Nizamiyyah, Hyderabad, Dakkan, India. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 137 === 121 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam sa Holy Prophet ' that do not inflict on any one a torment which is the prerogative of God alone how then can ‘Alira do so? Therefore it is an absolute fabrication to be associated with Hadrat ‘Alira in that he had the man burnt alive, because this is recounted via a great enemy of his who wished to calumniate him. Another Tradition verifies this. Here ‘Ikrama relates: When the news of this reaction of Hadrat ‘Abbasra reached Hadrat ‘Alira he said most indignantly 'Woe be on Ibni ‘Abbas'.116 2. Then again, the phrase: connotes generality. It can be construed in many ways. The word 'man' is applicable to man, woman, child and all. However, there are many theologians who have declared death penalty for a female apostate impermissible. 3. Moreover, by the word 'din' [which means faith] any faith, and not just Islam, can be denoted. The Holy Qur’an has also pronounced the faith of the idol worshippers as 'din'117. With these doubts and uncertainties, how is it possible to deem a Hadith like this applying exclusively only to a Muslim who changes his/her faith? In the light of the perceptive and subtle phraseology of law, by virtue of this Tradition each individual who changes his or her faith should be
116 Sunan Abu Da’ud, Awwalu Kitabil Hududi, Babul Hukmi Fi Manirtadda,
Hadith No. 4351. [Publisher] 117 Surah Al-Kafirun. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 138 === 122 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam killed, regardless of his or her particular faith. In this case each Jew who becomes a Christian should be killed and each Christian who becomes a Muslim should be killed, as indeed should be a hypocrite who chooses some other faith! Then the word: 'man' should be applied even outside the jurisdiction of Islamic State. In other words, any person who changes his religion should be slain whether he lives in Australia, or Africa, or in the jungles of South America. Just think of the consequences. Islam instructs its followers to invite others to join the religion of Islam, so much so that it demands each Muslim should becomes a missionary and a Da‘i IlAllah—a caller towards Allah. But then what will seem to be its attitude towards the followers of other religions? Will they have the same right to propagate their faith? Those who are in favour of death penalty for apostasy, do not take into account the ill effects of their inhumane and innovative view on mutual relations with other nations and religions. Why don’t they understand that if their view is valid then it would mean that the followers of other religions will be allowed to change their faith, but a Muslim will not have the same right to leave his religion! Islam would appear to have the right to change other people’s religion, but other religions will absolutely have no right to invite Muslims to change their religion! What a dreadful face of Islam they are painting to show to the === PDF-Seite 139 === 123 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam world? Therefore, to infer from this Tradition the death penalty for an apostate is absolutely incorrect. Its meaning is ambiguous, and its narrator is a liar, lewd and a renegade Kharji who is slandering Hadrat ‘Alira that he burnt alive the Zindiqs! Though Hadrat Imam Bukhari was not informed, but the later Muhaddithin proved that the narrator of this Hadith was a Kharji, an enemy of Hadrat ‘Alira. His debauchery and malice were so enormous that the Muslims did not care even to say his funeral prayer. I now present a few more Ahadith on the subject:
A.
"‘Abdullah narrates that the Holy Prophetsa said: 'It is not permissible to kill a Muslim who bears witness that there is none worthy of worship but Allah, and I (Muhammadsa) am the messenger of Allah. There are only three exceptions. First, a killer is to be killed in retribution; second, a married man who commits adultery; and third, he who leaves the === PDF-Seite 140 === 124 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam religion and the community118.
B.
118 Sahihul Bukhari, Kitabud Diyyati, Babu Qaulillahi T‘ala Annannafsa
Binafsi Wal ‘Aina Bil ‘Aini, Hadith No. 6878. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 141 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 125
"Abu Qilabata narrates: 'One day ‘Umar bin ‘Abdul ‘Aziz held an open court, and called the people to see him. They started coming to him… He asked my opinion regarding one case. I swore to God and said that the Holy Prophetsa did not allow killing of any one with the exception of the following three criminals: One who kills another human being out of his personal passions. Second, one who is married and yet commits adultery. Third, the one who becomes an apostate and engages in a war against Allah and His Messengersa. On hearing that the people said: Is it not narrated by Hadrat Anasra that the Holy Prophetsa punished the thieves by cutting their hands, putting red-hot needles in their eyes, and then throwing their bodies in the sun to rot? On hearing that, I said to them, "Let me tell you Hadrat Anas' narration as Anasra had told me himself: 'Eight men of ‘Ukl tribe came to see the Messenger of Allahsa and accepted Islam by making bai‘at at his hand. But the climate of Medina did not suite them and they got ill and became very === PDF-Seite 142 === 126 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam weak. They complained about their health to the Messenger of Allahsa, and he told them that they should go out with his shepherd and live in the open in the meadows for his camels, and they may use the milk and urine of the camels as a treatment for their illness. They agreed and went out to live at the meadows. They used the milk and urine of the camels and their health was recovered. Then, they killed the shepherd of the Messenger of Allahsa and ran away with the camels. When the Messenger of Allahsa came to know about it, he sent men to catch them. They were caught and brought in front of him. He ordered that they should be punished for their crimes. Their hands and feet were cut, red-hot needles were pierced in their eyes and they were left in the sun to die! I say can there be any crime as monstrous as they had committed and were punished for! They had committed a murder and theft after their apostasy! 119