Cover Page

The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam, Part 2

DISSENT AMONG THE ULEMA ON THE DEFINITION OF A "MUSLIM"

After quoting, as examples, the numerous definitions advanced by the ulema, they wrote:

"Keeping in view the several definitions given by the ulama, need we make any comment except that no two learned divines are agreed on this fundamental. If we attempt our 3 Report of The Court of Inquiry … into the Punjab Disturbance of 1953., p. 215. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 25 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 9 own definition as each learned divines has done and that definition differs from that given by all others, we unanimously go out of the fold of Islam. And if we adopt the definition given by any one of the ulama, we remain Muslims to the view of that alim but kafirs according to the definition of every one else."4

I have quoted these two excerpts from the Report just by way of illustration. These learned Judges embarked on a very detailed discussion of this issue. The interested reader is referred to the original Report for this purpose.

THE DEFINITION OF A MUSLIM ACCORDING TO THE HOLY PROPHETSA

Now I will tell you the definition that the Holy Prophet Muhammadsa himself formulated, and it was formulated in two or three different ways. It is inconceivable that these ulema were unaware of these definitions. Why did their minds not turn to these simple clear and transparent definitions? Simply because, on the basis of these definitions, the Ahmadiyya Jama‘at cannot, in any way, be declared kafir. It was the extreme instance of transgression and 4 Report of The Court of Inquiry …into the Punjab Disturbance of 1953,

p. 218. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 26 === 10 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam lack of integrity on their part that they abandoned the clear definitions given by the Holy Prophetsa and only on account of their enmity towards the Ahmadiyya Jama’at they tried to give their own self-made definition of a Muslim and miserably failed in this attempt.

THE FIRST DEFINITION BY THE HOLY PROPHETSA

The definition in the Holy Prophet’s sacred words that we have found, which has the greatest level of generality and is the broadest one—and on the basis of which it is impossible for a person, who is called a Muslim, to declare another Muslim to be an apostate, unless the latter himself recants Islam by his own formal declaration—is as follows:

"The Holy Prophetsa said: 'Write down for me the name of every such individual who claims to be a Muslim by the word of his own mouth.'"5

5 Sahih Bukhari, Kitabul Jihadi Wassiyar, Babu Kitabatil Imaminnasa,

Hadith No. 3060. See also Sahih Muslim, Kitabul Iman, Babu Jawazil Istisrari Bil Imani Lil Kha’ifi, Hadith No. 377. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 27 === 11 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam The context of this Hadith was the occasion when the Holy Prophetsa ordered a census in Medina. Since, a census, by its very nature, is a broad ranging entity, the most broad-ranging definition by him was given in the context of that particular occasion. He did not allow dabbling into any contentious issue—he did not even mention the Kalima—and said that, as far as the general census of population and national political realm is concerned, only this much is adequate by way of a definition that whoever calls himself a Muslim, you should record the name of all such individuals for me. The phrase "for me" is a beautiful expression and it signifies: this definition ‘will be acceptable to me’, regardless of whether or not it is acceptable to thousands of other people. For me—for Muhammadsa who has been appointed as the Messengersa of Allah— only this general definition is adequate that a person declares himself to be a Muslim.

THE SECOND DEFINITION BY THE HOLY PROPHET

The second definition, by comparison, has a greater religious flavour. But this, too, is so simple, so transparent, so beautiful and so unambiguous that after listening to even this definition there does not remain any basis for contention. He said: === PDF-Seite 28 === 12 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam

"Whoever observes Prayer in the same way as we do, and declares our qibla to be his qibla [i.e., faces the same direction in Prayer as we do]; one who eats from our dhabiha [i.e., the meat of our slaughtered animals] such a one is a Muslim. To protect such a person is a matter of obligation for God and His Messenger. So, [O ye Muslims!] make sure that you do not violate the obligation from God."6

What a magnificent, how clear, and how beautiful is this definition! Now, look at how the ulema in Pakistan are today showing the audacity to formulate a definition that is diametrically opposite to the above definition. In this day and age, hundreds of Ahmadis have been persecuted, jailed, and the ulema have issued openly provocative fatwas to murder them. They have proclaimed that the Ahmadis observe Prayers like us and in so doing they face the same qibla as we do, and they eat from the dhabiha like we do. Yet, until and unless the Ahmadis desist from these three actions, we will not discharge our obligation of 6 Sahih Bukhari, Kitabus Salat, Babu Fadli Istiqbalil Qiblati, Hadith

No. 391. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 29 === 13 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam protecting them. And the day they abandon these three acts, they would instantly become part of those whom we are obliged to protect and give their civil rights to. Was this the obligation that was mentioned by the Holy Prophetsa? By taking a position directly opposed to, and by contradicting every clause and proviso of the obligation laid down by God and the Messengersa of God, these ulema have formulated a new obligation for themselves. They have invented a new definition of a Muslim, and their demands that the Ahmadi mosques should be demolished and that Ahmadis must be forced to face a direction other than that of Ka‘ba, seems to indicate that they have, in effect, appointed a new qibla, and have suggested to Ahmadis to follow a new mode of worship. As far as the Ahmadiyya Jama‘at is concerned, only the definition given by the Holy Prophet Muhammadsa is sufficient for them, and only the obligation by God and His Messenger, imposed on them, is adequate. We do not care a whit about the umbrella of obligation imposed by any mullah.

THE THIRD DEFINITION BY THE HOLY PROPHETSA

The Holy Prophetsa has given a definition in regard to those people who are on the look out for an excuse to kill non-Muslims. This is actually not a definition per se of a Muslim but it consists of hissa reaction === PDF-Seite 30 === 14 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam expressed in a context that determines, in effect, the definition of a Muslim.

"Hadrat Usamara relates: We went on a sariyya (a military expedition, unaccompanied by the Holy Prophetsa) and mounted an early morning attack on the al-Huruqat region of the Juhaina tribe. I encountered a man and, when I got the better of him, he recited the Kalima, 'There is none worthy of worship, except === PDF-Seite 31 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 15 7 Allah.' —but I still killed him. This pricked my conscience, and when I returned to Medina I related the incident to the Holy Prophetsa. He replied, "O Usama! Did you kill him despite his reciting La ilaha illAllah?" I submitted, "O Messenger of Allah! but he recited La ilaha illAllah due to his fear of the weapons and for fear of getting killed." The Holy Prophetsa exclaimed, "Why did you not cut open his [chest to look at his] heart so that you could ascertain whether he had recited it due to fear or whether it was a heartfelt recital?" Thereafter he said, "On the day of Judgement, what would be your response to La ilaha illAllah?" I submitted, "O Messenger of Allah! Please say istighfar* for me." But he continued to repeat his remark time and again—so much so that I wished that I had not become a Muslim prior to that day, [so as to escape this occasion of being the recipient of such displeasure of the Holy Prophetsa].8

·

10 of 10 left today