Cover Page
The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam, Part 20
126 Sunan Abu Da’ud, Awwalu Kitabil Hudud, Babul Hukmi fi man Irtadda,
Hadith No. 4358. [Publisher] * Idolators. [Publisher] 127 Kanzul ‘Ummal, Kitabul Imani Wal Islam, Al-Faslul Khamis, Fi Hukmil
Islami, Al-Irtidadu Wa Ahkamuhu, Hadith No.1464. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 152 === 136 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam This narration also confirms that the Righteous Khalifa, Hadrat ‘Umarra was opposed to the concept of killing the apostates.
EARLY ULEMA AND THE CONCEPT OF APOSTASY:
When they cannot find any solid and strong evidence in the eras of the Holy Prophetsa and the Righteous Khulafa’, those who are in favour of death penalty for the apostates start talking about Ijma‘ [consensus of opinion]. They infer this from the opinions of the Ulema of the middle ages of Islam (when darkness prevailed) and declare that there was an Ijma‘ on this issue. Hence, no argument is acceptable against the Ijma‘.
THE CLAIM OF IJMA‘ IS INCORRECT:
FIRST ARGUMENT:
I have already given an argument against this Ijma‘ that in the era of Hadrat Abu Bakrra, apostates were caught but not killed.128 Therefore, the Ijma‘ of that time was against the death penalty of apostates. If there was an Ijma‘ on the
128 Tarikhul Tabri, Part III, Hawadith 11AH, pp 259-263; Tarikh Ibni
Khaldun, Al-Qismur Rabi‘i, Vol. II, p 864-865. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 153 === 137 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam subject, then it was not possible for Hadrat Abu Bakrra not to kill the apostates. Not a single Companionra of the Prophetsa objected and told Hadrat Abu Bakrra that the commandment of the Holy Qur’an was to kill the apostate, it was an established law, and it was obligatory for him to put it into practice; that he did not have permission to inflict any punishment to the apostates other than their death; that he did not have a right to make them slaves. This was the Taqriri* Ijma‘ of the Companions. Not a single voice was raised against the decision (of Hadrat Abu Bakr) and it proves that if there was any consensus of opinion it was on the point that Islam does not permit death as punishment for an apostate.
SECOND ARGUMENT:
In the Sunnan Dar Qutni, a statement is attributed to Hadrat Ibni ‘Abbas as follows:
"It is reported that Ibni ‘Abbas Said: 'The female apostate should be imprisoned and
* A technical term used when someone gives his tacit approval to someone
else's statement or action by not raising an objection against it. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 154 === 138 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam should not be killed'." 129
That is, according to him a female apostate was not to be killed, but was to be imprisoned. The Holy Prophetsa had forbidden killing a woman even in a battlefield. Thus, both the narrations are rejecting the opinion of Maududi that a female apostate should be killed, and also the opinion that there is an Ijma‘ on the issue of apostasy.
THIRD ARGUMENT:
‘Allama Al-Marghinani (d. 593 AH) writes:
"The reasons for not killing a female apostate are two-fold: One, the Holy Prophetsa
129 Sunan ad-Dar Qutni, Kitabul Hududi Wad Diyati Wa Ghairha, Vol. III,
page 118, Hadith No.120, Published by Darunnashril Kutubil Islamiyyah, Lahore, Pakistan. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 155 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 139 prohibited the killing of women; and second, in essence this particular punishment requires that it may be left for the Day of Judgement. A person needs time to be tested. Killing a person hurriedly takes away that chance. Adopting this principle of justice helps prevent a trial—the trial related to war! (The chances are that she will not go back and join the ranks of enemy war machine.) As women by nature are not inclined to wage war like men, therefore, their killing is prohibited."130
FOURTH ARGUMENT:
Similarly, a great jurist, Imam Ibnul Humam (d. 681 AH) writes in his book Fathul Qadir:
130 Al-Hidayah Sharhu Bidayatul Mubtadi, by Abu’ul Hasan ‘Ali bin Abi
Bakr Al-Rashidani Al-Marghinani, Part 2, pp. 406-407, Published by Darul Ahya’ Atturathul ‘Arabi, Beirut, Labnan. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 156 === 140 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam
"The reason to kill an apostate is only with the intent to eliminate the danger of war, and not for the reason of his disbelief. The punishment of disbelief is far greater with God. Therefore, only such an apostate shall be killed who is actively engaged in war; and usually it is a man, and not a woman. For the same reason, the Holy Prophetsa has forbidden to kill women. And for this very reason, an apostate female could be killed if she in fact instigates and causes war by her influence and armed force at her disposal. She is not killed because of her apostasy, but for her creating disorder (through war) on earth."131
FIFTH ARGUMENT:
Moreover, ‘Allama Al-Sarkhasi, an eminent scholar of the fifth century Hijra, writes:
'To disbelieve is no doubt a very grave sin, but it is a matter between God and His servant. Hence, its punishment shall be in the life Hereafter. The corporal punishments that are
131Sharhu Fathil Qadir by Muhammad bin ‘Abdul Wahid, Part V, Page 311,
Published by Darul Ahya’ Atturathul ‘Arabi, Beirut, Labnan. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 157 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 141 given in this world are ordained to protect the rights of other human beings, such as the punishment of "qisas" [the law of retaliation for murder or physical injuries] is to protect life; punishment for "Zina" [adultery & fornication] is to protect family lineage; punishment for "Sirqa" [theft] is to protect the property of others; punishment of "Qadhaf" [defamation] is to protect honour and reputation of others; and punishment for "Khumr" [use of intoxicants] is to protect mental health in society. When a person who insists on "disbelief" is engaged in armed struggle against Muslims, to protect the Muslims from the evil consequences of war, he is killed. At places, God has clearly stated the immediate cause of protection from the evil effects of the war. For example, He says: .132 And at other places, He gives the reason (of Shirk) that leads them to war. Thus, on the one hand it is established that the reason to kill is armed conflict, and on the other hand it is known that woman is not by nature capable of waging armed attacks; therefore, she
132 But if they attack you, then kill them. (The Holy Qur’an 2:192).
[Publisher] === PDF-Seite 158 === 142 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam is killed neither for her disbelief, nor for her apostasy.'133
How is it possible to call this as Ijma‘ when such eminent scholars are clearly against the notion of killing an apostate?