Cover Page
The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam, Part 21
SIXTH ARGUMENT:
Imam An-Nakh’i says: "He (the apostate) will be granted respite till his death."134
OPINIONS OF THE PRESENT DAY ULEMA: The Ulema of present day have never agreed on this opinion. There was never an Ijma‘ in the past and there is no Ijma‘ at present. For example: Imam Mahmud Shaltut, ex-rector of Al-Azhar University states: "For this violation, all that is stated in the Holy Qur’an is in the following verse:
133 Kitabul Mabsut by Shamsuddin Al-Sarkhasi, Part 9, Page 110, Published
by Matba‘atus Sa‘ada, Egypt. [Publisher] 134 Nailul Autar by Imam Muhammad bin ‘Ali Muhammad Al-Shaukani,
Part VII page 221, Abwabu Ahkamir Riddati wal Islam, Babu Qatlil Murtaddi, Published by Mustafa al-Babi al-Halabi, Cairo. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 159 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 143 135
You can see that in the above verse only this much is stated that the works of such apostates shall be lost, and in the Hereafter they shall be punished and remain in the Fire. As far as the corporal punishment, the jurists present the following Hadith in its favour which is narrated by Ibni ‘Abbasra: The Holy Prophetsa said, "Whosoever changed his religion should be killed." Scholars have discussed this Hadith and they hold different viewpoints… Opinion on this issue is changed when it becomes clear that the "Haddud" – (the prescribed punishments for various crimes in Sharia) cannot be based on Hadithi Ahad; and that it is not right to kill anyone just for disbelief. Killing is allowed only when some one fights with Muslims and attacks them to make them change their religion by force. Many verses of the Holy Qur’an very clearly prohibit the use of force in matters of religion. Allah the Exalted says: 136 ; and .137
135 And whoso from among you turns back from his faith and dies while he
is a disbeliever, it is they whose works shall be vain in this world and the next. These are the inmates of the Fire and therein shall they abide. (The Holy Qur’an 2:218). [Publisher] 136 There should be no compulsion in religion. Surely, right has become
distinct from wrong. (The Holy Qur’an 2:257). [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 160 === 144 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 2. Apart from Imam Shaltut, Ustadh Muhammad Mahmud Zaghlaf, Dr. ‘Alauddin Zaidan, ‘Abdul Mun‘im Yahya Al-Kamil and Yahya Kamil Ahmad hold the opinion that:
"There is no evidence in support of this alleged punishment in the Holy Qur’an or in the authentic Sunna. On the contrary, several verses of the Holy Qur’an declare similar assumptions to be utterly false, and permit man to use his freedom to adopt either disbelief or belief. It is up to him to accept Islam or to leave it. Moreover, the verses in the Holy Qur’an make it clear that Allah Himself will judge each person in the matter concerning acceptance or rejection of the true faith, as only He is fully aware of the secrets of the hearts of His servants." "Those who argue that Hadrat Abu Bakr Al- Siddiqra fought battles against the apostates should know that, after a careful study of various historical aspects of those battles, we shall come to the conclusion that they were not only apostates, they were also a source of mischief within the Islamic society and they had revolted and disturbed the law and order situation within the country. So much so that
137 Wilt thou, then, force men to become believers? (The Holy Qur’an 10:100). Al-Islam—‘Aqida Wash Sharia, by Imam Mahmud Shaltut, pp. 292- 293, Darul ‘Ilm, Cairo. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 161 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 145 they had brought Medina under siege! These circumstances compelled Abu Bakr to take up arms against them and break the siege. It proves that it was not merely a matter of few persons becoming apostates and being fought against for their apostasy. They were battled against to stop their armed attack against the Islamic government and to finish a mischievous revolt. It was to eliminate a threat to Islamic state’s security. Abu Bakrra took action in the light of the following command of God:
Similarly, the historical account of Tha‘labah* is a clear proof that apostasy is not a punishable act. It also refutes the argument that Abu Bakrra fought against the apostates only because they refused to pay the Zakat. Tha‘labah had refused paying Zakat in the time of the Messenger of Allahsa and he had openly treated the Holy Prophet’s functionary with
138 And fight in the cause of Allah against those who fight against you, but
do not transgress. Surely, Allah loves not the transgressors. (The Holy Qur’an 2:191). [Publisher] * See Addurrul Manthur by Siyuti, Part 3, under Surah Al-Taubah, pp. 467-
468, published by Darul Kutubil ‘Ilmiya, Beirut, Labnan. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 162 === 146 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam contempt. But still, the Prophetsa did not order his death nor tried to take Zakat forcefully from him. Later, Tha‘labah himself repented and wanted to pay the Zakat but the Prophetsa refused to accept it. Similarly, Abu Bakrra, Umarra and ‘Uthmanra, in their respective eras of Khilafat, did not accept his Zakat. This incident proves that neither at the time of the Holy Prophetsa nor in the era of Abu Bakr Zakat was considered a compulsory tax to be forcefully collected, and none was attacked because he had refused to pay the Zakat. The Muslims used to pay the Zakat most willingly to purify their souls in obedience to their God. Obviously, Hadrat Abu Bakr followed the footsteps of the Holy Prophetsa and adhered to his noble manner of conduct. Thus, it appears impossible that he would have compelled anyone to return to the faith of Islam by the dint of sword! We fear Allah and do not attribute any action to him that might be against the Sunna of the Holy Prophetsa. The fact remains that he fought with those apostates only to secure the budding Islamic society from the threats of their mischief and armed attacks.
In the light of these facts all such pernicious opinions prove false that the orientalists and opponents of Islam propagate === PDF-Seite 163 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 147 under the heading "Abu Bakr’s battles against apostates."139
In the same manner, the following scholars have also rejected this worthless opinion:
139 Haqiqatul Hukm Bima Anzala Allahu – pp 126-131, First Edition,
published by Daru Nahrinnabil, Cairo. [Publisher] 140 Nuqta’i Sarkari Hayat Ya‘ni Jihad ka Sahih Mafhum Qur’ani Karim ki