Cover Page

The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam, Part 8

METAPHORICAL 'SLAYING'

Then, immediately in the next verse, Allah, the Exalted, says:

'Then We raised you up after your death, that you might be grateful.'46

In other words, this is the clarification of the notion of "death" that they had been commanded to impose on their own selves. Thus it enunciates that those people did not get killed, in the physical sense, i.e., they were not slain. Rather, for their own sake they had subjected their own selves to a kind of "death", as was the commandment for them. Because, when a human being subjects his own self to a sort of "death", solely for the sake of God, then God ensures that he is given a new life. Thus, Allah has also touched upon the theme of how He turned towards them* with compassion, i.e., when they imposed a sort of "death" on their selves

46 The Holy Qur’an 2:57. [Publisher] * , taba. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 65 === 49 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam then, consequently, God granted them a new life. And they used to marvel at it, in gratitude, as to how God had infused a new life in them, spiritually, and how it surely occasioned gratitude on their part.

OPINIONS OF THE EARLIER EXEGETES

There are still more arguments based on the verses of the Holy Qur’an but, since the contemporary ulema are comparatively more favourably inclined towards the fatwas passed by the medieval theologians and religious scholars—than they are towards the Holy Qur’an—I would not embark on the discussion of additional verses of the Holy Qur’an and, instead, present here the views given in a few commentaries of the Holy Qur’an.

1. In Tafsir Ruhul Bayan, it is stated: === PDF-Seite 66 === 50 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam

That is when the Holy Qur’an states that:

"You should slay your "selves", it means you should slay your selfish desires and greed, and crush your foul wishes—because, it is the selfish desires and greed that constitute the essence of the "self". Such an act is better for you, in the sight of your God. Because, the more you crush the-self-that-incites-to-evil47, the more rapidly would you advance in high rank and spiritual elevation in the presence of God. And He, too, would enable you to undertake more acts of virtue and, by treating you mercifully, He, too, would continue to draw closer to you."48

So, this is the meaning of the verse:

"Then He turned towards you with compassion. Surely, He is Oft-Returning with

47 Nafsi Ammarah. [Publisher] 48 Shaikh Isma’il Haqqi Al-Barusawi, Tafsir Ruhul Bayan, Surah Al-

Baqarah, 2:55, Part 1, Page 139, Published by Al-Maktabatul Islamiya. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 67 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 51 49 compassion, and is Merciful."

2. Imam Raghib Asfahani states,

[With reference to] "'faqtulu Anfusakum' it is said that it means that some of you should kill some others from among yourselves. And it is also said that by 'Qatlin Nafsi' is meant crushing and stamping out the carnal passions of the self."50

Now, I advert to the second argument.

ULEMA’S SECOND ARGUMENT

The second argument—allegedly based on the Holy Qur’an—to justify death penalty for an apostate, is presented by Maududi Sahib in a book of his. Yet he does not even mention the argument presented by Maulana ‘Uthmani Sahib, which shows that he, too, attaches no significance to this argument. Had it been, in fact, a notably strong argument, he would have at least paid some attention to it. 49 The Holy Qur’an 2:55. [Publisher] 50 Al-Mufradat by Imam Raghib, under the word Qatl (i.e., slaying).

[Publisher] === PDF-Seite 68 === 52 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam Maududi Sahib gives a different argument which he bases on the following verse of Surah Al-Taubah:

'But if they repent and observe Prayer, and pay the Zakat, then they are your brethren in faith. And We explain the signs for a people who have knowledge. And if they break their oaths after their covenant, and revile your religion, then fight these leaders of disbelief— surely, they have no regard for their oaths— that they may desist.' 51

But, at this point, the very verse on which he bases his argument rips it apart, because the verse states the purpose of it all, which is: 'So that they might desist.' But, if they were to be put to death then how would they ever desist? In this scheme, the question of repentance (or desisting) does not at all arise for them. He argues on the basis of the verse 12 of Al-Baqarah

51 The Holy Qur’an 9:11, 12. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 69 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 53

as follows:

"Here, violation of oaths can by no means be taken to mean violation of political covenants. Indeed, the reference to the context unambiguously fixes its meaning as ‘turning back from the covenant of accepting Islam’. Following this, the phrase: ("Then fight with the leaders of disbelief") can be none other than fighting with the leaders of a movement of apostasy."52

ANALYSIS OF MAUDUDI’S INTERPRETATION

If one looks at the context, then his assertion that the covenant, here, means ‘the covenant to accept Islam’ is established. But, in fact, referring to the context refutes his claim. These are the verses from Surah Al-Taubah, and the Holy Qur’an’s theme, in this context, is that the idolaters—who entered into a covenant (or pact) with 52 Maududi, Irtidad ki Saza Islami Qanun meiń [The Punishment of

Apostasy in the Islamic Law], page 9, Published by Markazi Maktaba Jama‘ati Islami, Ichra, Lahore, Pakistan, 1951. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 70 === 54 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam you—are guilty of violating that covenant. Their [attachment to that] covenant is no longer trustworthy, and you would have to go to battle against them. Thus the Surah begins with the verse:

·

10 of 10 left today