Cover Page

The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam, Part 9

"This is a declaration of complete absolution on the part of Allah and His Messenger from all obligation to the idolaters with whom you had made promises."53

Where is there any mention at all in this verse, of the idolaters converting to Islam? God says that those, in reference to whom a contract is mentioned here, are the idolaters. And, We are telling you to get ready to go to battle against those among the idolaters who have violated their covenant with you. Then the Holy Qur’an goes on to say:

53 The Holy Qur’an 9:1. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 71 === The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam 55

"How can there be a treaty of these idolaters with Allah and His Messenger, except those with whom you entered into a treaty at the Sacred Mosque? So, as long as they stand true to you, stand true to them. Surely, Allah loves those who are righteous. How can it be when, if they prevail against you, they would not observe any tie of relationship or covenant in respect of you? They would please you with their mouths, while their hearts refuse, and most of them are perfidious. They barter the Signs of Allah for a paltry price and turn men away from His way. Evil indeed is that which they do. They observe not any tie of relationship or covenant in respect of anyone who trusts them. === PDF-Seite 72 === 56 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam And it is they who are transgressors."54

In this entire excerpt, too, there is not even a hint of Muslims being the subject of discussion. How could Allah and His Messenger attach any significance to the covenant of those who are idolaters? The only exception being those with whom you have entered into a covenant within the Sacred Mosque*. This is the particular set of idolaters with respect to whom—while they are abiding by their covenant with you—it is incumbent on you to keep them protected from any chastisement or suffering at your hands. Allah loves those who follow the path of Taqwa. How can it be [that any importance be attached to their covenant, while the reality is] that should they prevail against you, they would not care for any ties of kinship, nor would they care for any existing covenant. They only verbally please you, whereas their hearts are full of enmity for you, and they are averse to you. They have bargained for the paltry gain of this world, having forgone the Signs of Allah, in exchange. They obstruct people from the way of God. Their actions are, certainly, evil. They do not have any regard for the ties of kinship in relation to any of the believers, nor are they mindful of the sanctity of mutually binding covenants with the believers. This is the context of the verse under discussion.

54 The Holy Qur’an 9:7-10. [Publisher] * Masjidul Haram. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 73 === 57 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam Are these Muslims who are being discussed in this context? It is astonishing how Maududi Sahib could allow himself to advance this claim that if one looks at the context of this verse then it will be established with certainty that the covenant to which this verse refers to is the "covenant of initiation into the fold of Islam"! Then Allah says:

This verse embodies a momentary digression from the theme of the ‘covenant’ per se, and it states that if anyone among those people (with whom you have this covenant) accepts Islam, then, in that case, you should overlook their previous offences. That is, in that case, you will no longer have any dispute with them and your entire attitude towards them will change. After this digression, the previous theme of the ‘covenant’ is resumed,

55 But if they repent and observe Pryaer and pay the Zakat, then they are

your brethren in faith. And We explain the Signs for a people who have knowledge. (The Holy Qur’an 9:11). [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 74 === 58 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam

That is, if they break their oaths after their covenant, and—over and above that—they proceed to revile your religion … Notice how it is not deemed as sufficient for going to battle against them if they only break their covenant. How sublime is this Word of God—what an all-embracing mercy. Although the idolaters are guilty of breaking their covenant, yet the punitive Divine decree, in regard to them, does not descend. Allah says that in the event that they stoop to such a base level that they not only break their covenant but also hurt you and openly revolt against you then you must, surely, go to battle against the leaders of disbelief. Because it is not legitimate to take any action against them until they break their own covenant (and rise against you), so that they may desist from such activities. According to Maulana Maududi Sahib, and a few other ulema, there is no use even to "desist" either; i.e. an apostate must be killed even after he repents, because these ulema are of the view that an apostate’s repentance does not find Divine acceptance.57 But, the phrase58 "so that they may desist" clearly indicates that

56 And if they break their oaths after their covenant, and attack your religion,

then fight these leaders of disbelief—surely, they have no regard for their oaths—that they may desist. (The Holy Qur’an 9:12). [Publisher] 57 See, Ash-Shihab li Rajmil Khatifil Murtab, page 31. [Publisher] 58 La‘allahum yantahun (i.e., "so that they may desist"). [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 75 === 59 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam it is the height of cruelty for anyone to deduce a sanction for a punitive "slaying of an apostate" from this verse. Since the context is clearly that of the idolaters—not of those who have accepted Islam— therefore, I wish that these ulema desist from their attempt to impute those ideas to the Holy Qur’an that are not even remotely connected to it.

THE GENUINE CONTEXT

Taking Maulawi Maududi Sahib up on his suggestion that one must refer to the context of the verse in question, we now proceed to discuss the verses that immediately follow. This will enlighten the reader as to which type of people are being referred to here and as to whether the matter under discussion is "the punishment for apostasy is murder", or some other issue is being dealt with? Who should you fight against? It is stated:

"Will you not fight a people who have broken their oaths, and who plotted to turn out the Messenger, and they were the first to === PDF-Seite 76 === 60 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam commence hostilities against you? Do you fear them? Nay, Allah is most worthy that you should fear Him, if you are believers."59

Allah has made it clear: 'We are not commanding you to fight these people either because you have ascendancy over them, or because you are powerful and their necks are securely held in your hands. In fact, they are so strong, and powerful that they are poised to throw the Messenger [of God] and his followers out of the city, What is the nature of their crimes? It is not stated that i.e., "They turned their backs to Islam, and adopted disbelief". Not at all. Rather, it is stated, i.e., "They have broken their oaths, and have pre-empted the acts of mischief and transgressions. They are the ones who have first drawn their swords against you. They were the first to start aggression against you.

The Command is: "tuqatiluna"*, and not "taqtuluna"**

The imperative form of the verb, tuqatiluna, is itself indicative of the fact that, here, the command to fight is directed against someone who has pre- emptively drawn his sword against you. For according 59 The Holy Qur’an 9:13. [Publisher] * "To fight, in retaliation, against someone who has initiated the fight, e.g.,

·

10 of 10 left today