An Announcement for Public Awareness

The Reality of Khilafah, Part 2

His insistence on calling us infidels and the proof of our Islamic faith. A reward of 27 rupees for the Sheikh if he is able to write and publish a book that competes with Sirrul-Khilafah God is my witness that I have not stepped out of Islam by so much as a cubit. As far as I know and believe, I stand firm on all the verities of the Holy Qur’an and Hadith. I feel sorry that Sheikh Muhammad Husain and our other opponents have not only declared me to be an infidel and a dajjal [deceiver] and one destined to abide forever in Hell, they have also abandoned the Holy Qur’an and the Hadith. I have said time and again that I cannot follow their selfish desires and their mistaken beliefs; however, if they have anything from the Holy Qur’an or Hadith that I am supposedly against, I am ready to accept it at any time. I proved to them that the word ی

[tawaffi]—which is a common idiom used by the Holy Qur’an, the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, his Companions, and by Arabs even today—means ‘to cause someone to die’. It does not mean anything else. I have also shown them that the word tawaffi, as proven to have been used by the Holy Prophet s (as), points to the fact that Jesus has passed away. Open up Bukhari and reflect with a pure heart on the account wherein the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, says that, on the Day of Judgement, he will say the exact same words as are ascribed to Jesus, the righteous man, in the verse فَلَمَّا تَوَفَّيۡتَنِي [fa lamma tawaffaitani—‘but since You did cause me to die’].1

Would it be fair to say that the true connotation of the words applied to Jesus but not to the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him,2 and that the Holy Prophet s (as) did not partake in the true meaning of the word tawaffi that was in accord with God’s will, viz. ‘being physically raised to heaven’; and that the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, changed its meaning so that when it applied to him it had

ilar to] in the statement of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, indicates that there should be some difference in the application of the word توفی [tawaffi—death] depending on whether it applies to the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, or to Jesus as. Unfortunately, these ignorant people do not realize that while there may be some dissimilarity in the events that are likened to one another, there can be no difference in the actual meaning of the words. For example, someone may say, ‘I ate bread just like Zaid ate bread.’ Although there may be differences in the way the bread was eaten or in its quality, there can be no difference regarding the word ‘bread’ which is the particular object in this sentence. Bread cannot be taken to mean bread in one instance and stone in another. There can be no disparity when it comes to the meaning of words. There is a similar saying of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, recorded by Ibn Taymiyyah in Zad al-Ma‘ad, on page 415, and it is as follows: The Holy Prophet said,

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

[‘O people of Quraish, what do you expect from me?’] They said, ‘Only goodness, O honourable brother and honourable nephew.’] He said, ‘I say to you as Yusuf said to his brothers, ‘No blame shall lie on you this day.’ Go, for you are free.’ You can see that the word tathrib has the same connotation in the statement of the Holy Prophet s (as) as in that of Hadrat Yusuf [Joseph].—Author a different connotation, but when it applied to Jesus it had the meaning originally intended by God? If this were true, it would entail the manifest error that it is beyond the status of a Prophet to change the established meaning of a word in a way that can only be described as distortion.

It would also nullify the similitude that the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, intended to portray by citing the verse 1فَلَمَّا تَوَفَّيۡتَنِي, for, the similarity would only stand if the true meanings of the word tawaffi applied equally to him and to Jesus. In the absence of such application, where would the similarity be? Could the Holy Prophet s (as) not have found another word instead of sharing one to which he was not even entitled? Can one who is buried in the earth and one who has been raised to heaven be equally described by a word that could mean either to die or to be raised to heaven alive? Can two opposites be the same? If the meaning of tawaffi mentioned in the verse فَلَمَّا تَوَفَّيۡتَنِي was not to ‘cause to die’, then had Imam Bukhari lost his mind when he picked another verse from another place and cited it in support of this meaning in Sahih Bukhari? Not only that, but he also brought in the saying of Ibn Abbas ra:

‘I will tawaffi you means “I will cause you to die.”’ If Bukhari did not mean to elaborate upon the allegorical meaning of the Holy Prophet’s s (as) words through the clear definition given by Ibn Abbas, then what was the purpose of bringing together the two verses and mentioning Ibn Abbas as well, and what was the need to have this discussion around the word tawaffi anyway? The fact is that here Imam Bukhari has expressed his own belief about the word tawaffi.

There are now three points in support of my claim. The first is the blessed saying of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, that just as the righteous man ‘Isa had said فَلَمَّا تَوَفَّيۡتَنِي, so would he say these words. The second is the fact that Ibn Abbas has defined the word tawaffi as ‘to cause to die’. The third is the testimony of Imam Bukhari which is evident from the manner in which he has discussed this verse.

Now, who do you think has abandoned the Hadith and the Holy Qur’an? Is it me or my opponents? Have they been able to prove their meaning of the word tawaffi with sayings of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, or of his Companions, as I have done? Regardless, if my opponents can prove some other meaning of tawaffi on the basis of a hadith of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, a statement of one of his Companions, and the validation of an eminent Imam such as Bukhari, I would be willing to accept that meaning. It is truly cunning of them to first abandon the Hadith and the Holy Qur’an and then to accuse our sect of having abandoned the Holy Qur’an and the Hadith.

O maulawis who oppose me, may God have mercy on you, pay close attention and know that the only meaning of the word tawaffi in the verse under discussion that is established by the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and his Companions is ‘to cause to die’. Anyone who abandons this meaning interprets the Holy Qur’an according to his own whim because this hadith does not allow any other meaning of the word tawaffi in this verse. For this reason, Shah Wali’ullah, in his Tafsir Fauz al-Kabir, which adheres only to the sayings of Holy Prophet s (as) and the Companions, has defined mutawaffika as mumituka [to cause to die]. Had he found any other meanings, he would surely have given them as well.

Our opponents should be ashamed of themselves for abandoning the unambiguous and authentic texts. Fear God, O heedless ones. Are you not going to die one day?

You should also not be jubilant over the word nuzul. The Holy Prophet s (as) has not specified the kind of nuzul referred to here, because this word has various connotations. For example, it is used to describe the nuzul [arrival] of a traveller at some place. The Holy Qur’an also uses nuzul in the spiritual context, such as the nuzul of iron and clothes and cattle. The biblical account of Elijah and John the Baptist, which is agreed upon by Jews and Christians alike, makes it very clear that dead Prophets return to the world in a spiritual sense and not a physical one. They never descend from the sky, but, with the permission of God, their spiritual qualities descend upon someone who has an affinity with them and who reveres them, and thus the ‘descent’ of such a person is considered to be their descent. Some saints have mentioned this kind of ‘descent’ in their mystical works. Therefore, in the eyes of God, this is a kind of nuzul, otherwise God’s word would stand falsified.

The Biblical story of Elijah is accepted among Jewish and Christian sects, and it would be foolish for us to say they all colluded in trying to interpolate these verses. In fact, the story has proven to be very detrimental for Christians. If Elijah’s descent were to be taken literally, the Jews would be proven right and it would become obvious that Jesus was not a true Prophet, as Elijah was supposed to have descended from heaven prior to his coming. This objection by the Jews was a great hurdle for Jesus in proving his prophethood. Had the story of Elijah been a fabrication, Jesus would surely have told the Jews that there is no truth to the claim that Elijah must return to the earth in his physical body before the appearance of Christ. Instead, he accepted the verses as authentic and declared that Elijah’s descent was supposed to be a spiritual one. It was on account of these interpretations that the Jews called him an apostate and unanimously declared him to be irreligious and a disbeliever because he had distorted the apparent meaning of categorical verses of the Torah. If Jesus had explained that the said passages in the scriptures had been distorted, while this would not have silenced the Jews, many would have believed him after witnessing his miracles. Seeing that he was helped by God and received Divine revelations and worked miracles, people would have accepted his claim. However, Jesus did not do so and he instead acknowledged the authenticity of the verses that promised the return of Elijah. This has caused the Christians no end of trouble as they have nothing to say to the Jews who taunt them that Jesus could be a Prophet only if all Divine scriptures were rejected. So far, Christians have not been able to prove that these verses were interpolated so as to get rid of this nuisance. Indeed, it is not possible for them to go against the words of Jesus, peace be upon him, after a passage of 1900 years. This is a very important point for our Muslim brothers to ponder. They should realize that if the apparent meanings they are emphasizing are true, then Jesus cannot be a Prophet in any way. He can only be the

Prophet of God if the descent of Elijah is believed to be a spiritual phenomenon.

It is a pity that after the passage of 1890 years, these maulawis and faqihs [theologians] have taken up the same quarrel with me. Even a child can understand that the stance I have adopted is the same as that of Jesus, while the belief upheld by the mullahs is the one advocated by the Jews. Look at the misfortune of the maulawis that as soon as they adopted this belief, they started to resemble the Jews. However, all is not lost and there is still time, if they but understand!

·

10 of 10 left today