Surah 3: Ali 'Imran

The Holy Qur’an with English Translation and Short Commentary, Part 13

And [a]Muhammad is but a Messenger. Verily, all Messengers have passed away before him. If then he dies or is slain, will you turn back on your heels? [b]And he who turns back on his heels shall not harm Allah at all.[494] And Allah will certainly reward the grateful.

[a] 5:76.

[b] 2:144, 218; 5:55; 47:39.

[494] A false report was spread at Uhud that the Holy Prophet had been killed. The verse refers to that incident and purports to say that although the report was untrue, yet even if it had been true and the Prophet had in fact been killed, that should not have made the Faithful waver in their faith. Muhammad was only a Prophet; and as other Prophets before him had died, so would he. But the God of Islam is Ever Living. It is on record that when the Holy Prophet died, ‘Umar stood up in the Mosque at Medina with a drawn sword in his hand and said, "Whoever will say that the Prophet of God is dead, I will cut off his head. He is not dead, but has gone to his Lord (he has ascended to heaven), even as Moses had gone to his Lord, and he would come back and punish the Hypocrites." Abu Bakr coming on the scene firmly told ‘Umar to sit down and addressing the Muslims who had gathered in the Mosque, recited this very verse which convinced them that the Prophet was really dead and so they were overwhelmed with grief. The verse incidentally establishes the fact that all the Prophets before the Holy Prophet, had died; for if any of them had been alive, the verse could not have been quoted as proof of the Holy Prophet’s death. In fact, Islam does not depend for its life on any individual, however great. God is its Revealer and its Protector and Guardian. But the verse should not be understood to mean that the Holy Prophet could ever be killed in war or at the hand of an assassin. He was promised Divine protection from all harm to his life (5:68). The enemy had rejoiced when the false report went round that the Prophet was dead. But it proved a blessing in disguise for Muslims. It prepared them for the great strain which his actual death was to bring upon them later. But for this experience, it would have proved unbearable for them.

And no soul can die except by Allah’s leave—a decree with a fixed term. [a]And whoever desires the reward of the present world, We will give him thereof; and whoever desires the reward of the Hereafter, We will give him thereof; and We will surely reward the grateful.

[a] 3:149; 4:135; 42:21.

And many a Prophet there has been beside whom fought numerous companies[495] of their followers. [b]They slackened not for aught that befell them in the way of Allah, nor did they weaken, nor did they humiliate themselves before the enemy. And Allah loves the steadfast.

[495] Ribbiyyun is the plural of Ribbiyy which is derived from Rabba for which see 1:2. Ribbiyy means, one related to Ribbah, i.e. a company or a large company or a numerous company. Thus the word means, those forming a large company or a large body of persons. The word also signifies learned, pious and patient men (Lane).

[b] 4:105.

And they uttered not a word except that they said, [c]‘Our Lord, forgive us our sins and our excesses in our conduct, and make firm our steps and help us against the disbelieving people.’

[c] 2:251, 287.

[a]So Allah gave them the reward of this world, as also an excellent[496] reward of the Hereafter; and Allah loves those who do good.

[a] 3:146.

[496] The rewards of the next life are of various degrees, and such believers, as have been described above, will get the best of them. The word Husna rendered as "excellent" does not necessarily indicate superlative degree but is also used to express an intensified sense absolutely.

[b]O ye who believe! if you obey[497] those who have disbelieved, they will cause you to turn back on your heels, and you will become losers.

[b] 2:110; 3:101.

[497] Muslims are not enjoined to eschew dealings with all non-Muslims; they are warned against following only such disbelievers as are the active enemies of Islam.

Nay, [c]Allah is your Protector, and He is the Best of helpers.

[c] 8:41; 9:51; 22:79.

[d]We shall cast terror into the hearts of those that have disbelieved because they associate partners with Allah,[498] for which He has sent down no authority. Their abode is the Fire; and evil is the habitation of the wrongdoers.

[d] 8:13; 59:3.

[498] Idolatry springs from superstition and fear; and one possessed of superstition and fear can never be truly brave.

And Allah had surely made good to you His promise[499] when you were slaying and destroying them by His leave, until, when your courage failed you[500] and you disputed among yourselves concerning the order[501] and you disobeyed[502] after He had shown you that which you loved, He withdrew His help. Among you were those who desired the present world,[503] and among you were those who desired the Hereafter. Then He turned you away from them, that He might try you—and He has surely pardoned you, and Allah is Gracious to the believers—

[499] The "promise" refers to the general promise of victory and success repeatedly given to Muslims, particularly in 3:124-126.

[500] The verse refers to the party of archers posted in the rear of the Muslim army at Uhud, and points out that they could not resist the temptation of taking part in actual fighting and in sharing the booty, and their failure to control that desire was an act of cowardice on their part. It is indeed the heart which is the seat of true bravery and courage.

[501] The "order" may refer either to the order of the Holy Prophet given to the party of archers on the hill not to leave their station without his permission, or to its import and significance, i.e. whether the Holy Prophet had really meant them to stay there even after the battle had been won; some saying that he did mean it and others alleging that he did not.

[502] Muslims stationed at the hill paid no heed to their leader, ‘Abdullah b. Jubair, who, in compliance with the order of the Holy Prophet, told them not to quit the place, even if victory was within sight. They could not control themselves, and the result was that their act caused great suffering to Muslims.

[503] The words refer to those archers who quitted the place at which they had been stationed. The Arabic clause may also signify that some members of the party desired the present world, i.e. taking part in the fighting and collecting the booty, while others (viz. ‘Abdullah b. Jubair and those of his comrades who did not quit their posts) desired the Hereafter, i.e. they thought of the ultimate consequence of disobeying the command of the Holy Prophet. Some were short-sighted, while others were far-sighted.

When you were running away and looked not back at anyone[504] while the Messenger was calling you, in your rear, then He gave you one sorrow after another sorrow,[505] [a]that you might not grieve for what escaped you nor for what befell you.[505A] And Allah is quite Aware of what you do.

[504] The words refer to the incident which happened when in the Battle of Uhud the Muslims were attacked from both the rear and the front and their ranks were broken and many of them fled in confusion in different directions. At first, when they heard that the enemy was coming from behind, they turned back to attack him, but it so happened that at that time a large body of Muslims was also coming from that direction. In the confusion those Muslims were mistaken for the enemy and were attacked. So great was the confusion and the panic that even the voice of the Holy Prophet was not heeded.

[505] The Holy Prophet had stationed a party of archers at the hill. They abandoned their positions prematurely, thinking that the battle had been won. Consequently, the victory which was almost within the grasp of the Muslims became converted into a near defeat. It naturally caused a sorrow to them. This was the first sorrow. The second or the later sorrow was that which they felt at the unfounded report of the death of the Holy Prophet. God so designed that the sorrow pertaining to the unfounded report of the Prophet’s death (the later sorrow) should come after the sorrow of the reverse which the Muslims had suffered (the first sorrow), in order that the later sorrow should remove the effect of the former sorrow at seeing that the Holy Prophet was safe. The words Ghammam bi-Ghammin also mean, sorrow upon sorrow.

[a] 57:24.

[505A] The words "what escaped you" signify, the victory which was almost within the grasp of the Muslims and "what befell you" signify the reverse they suffered and the loss of Muslims killed.

Then after the sorrow, [b]He sent down peace on you—a slumber[506] that overcame a party of you— while the other party[506A] was anxious concerning their ownselves. They entertained about Allah wrong thoughts like unto the thoughts of ignorance. They said, ‘Have we any part in the affair?’ Say, verily, the affair wholly belongs to Allah.’ They hide in their minds what they disclose not to thee. They say, [a]‘If we had any part in the determination of affairs, we should not have been killed here.’ Say, ‘If you had remained in your homes, surely those on whom fighting[506B] had been enjoined would have gone forth to their death-beds[506C] that Allah might fulfil His decree and that He might test what was in your breasts and that He might purge what was in your hearts. And Allah knows well what is in the breasts;

[b] 8:12.

[506] The reference in the verse is again to the Battle of Uhud. Abu Talhah says, "I lifted my head on the day of Uhud and began to look about, and saw that there was none among us on that day whose head had not bent down on account of slumber" (Kathir ii. 303). As sleep or slumber is a sign of mental peace and tranquillity, the Holy Qur’an refers to the incident as a Divine favour. The incident evidently occurred when the battle was practically over and the Muslims had returned to the neighbouring hill.

[506A] The reference is to the Hypocrites who had remained behind at Medina. They were more concerned about their own security than about the honour of Islam and the security of the Holy Prophet and the Muslims. The words, we should not have been killed here, occurring a few lines further, mean, "If we had any voice in the determination of affairs and if our advice had been accepted, we, i.e. our brethren, would not have been killed in the battle," the insinuation being that the Muslims were foolish enough to march to the battlefield against heavy odds, while they (the Hypocrites) had wisely refrained from going with them. According to idiom in the Holy Qur’an the slaying of one’s self sometimes signifies the slaying of one’s brethren or companions (2:55, 2:86).

[a] 3:169.

[506B] Qatl has been used here in the sense of, Qital, i.e. fighting (Muhit & Kashshaf). See 2:192 and Jarir under 3:155.

[506C] The word "death-beds" has been used in order to point to the abject cowardice of the Hypocrites on the one hand, and the steadfast devotion of the believers on the other. It reminds the Hypocrites that while they had deserted and returned to Medina, thinking that fighting in the circumstances was sure death, such was the firm faith of the believers that even if they (the Hypocrites) had kept back from the very beginning they (the believers) would have cheerfully gone forth to the battlefield—or the place of death, as it was thought to be. All this happened that God might purify the Faithful.

Those of you who turned their backs on the day when the two hosts met,[507] surely it was Satan who sought to make them stumble[507A] because of certain[508] doings of theirs. But certainly Allah has already pardoned them. Verily, Allah is Most Forgiving, Forbearing.

[507] The reference is again to the Battle of Uhud.

[507A] The word "stumble," mentioned in the verse, refers to the disobeying of the orders given to the party stationed at the hill or the running away of some Muslims from the battlefield.

[508] The words seem to contain an implied praise for the archers at the hill who misinterpreting the Holy Prophet’s orders left their post, meaning that only "certain" of their misdeeds had brought them this temporary disgrace, otherwise they were really loyal and obedient to the Holy Prophet.

·

10 of 10 left today