Surah 3: Ali 'Imran
The Holy Qur’an with English Translation and Short Commentary, Part 7
And a party of the People of the Book say, ‘Declare your belief outwardly in that which has been revealed unto the believers, in the early part of day, and disbelieve in the latter part thereof; perchance they may return;[428]
[428] The Jews were held in high esteem by the pagan Arabs for their religious learning. They took undue advantage of this and thought of a device to turn Muslims away from their Faith by outwardly embracing Islam in the early part of the day and giving it up in the latter part, seeking in this way to make the unlettered Arabs believe that something must have been seriously wrong with Islam, otherwise these learned men would not have so hurriedly given it up. But these foolish people made a completely wrong estimate of the invincible faith of the Companions of the Holy Prophet.
‘And [a]obey none but him who follows your religion.’—Say, ‘Surely, true guidance—the guidance of Allah, is, that one be given the like of that which has been given to you’—‘or [b]they would argue[428A] with you before your Lord.’ Say, ‘All grace[428B] is in the [c]hand of Allah. He gives it to whomsoever He pleases. And Allah is Bountiful, All-Knowing;[428C]
[a] 2:121.
[b] 2:77.
[428A] If we are wrong in holding this view, then they should remove this misunderstanding by some Divine argument.
[428B] 'Grace' here may signify Prophethood.
[c] 57:30.
[428C] (1) The clause, And obey none but him who follows your religion, constitutes a continuation of the concluding clause of the preceding verse. Thereafter comes the parenthetical clause beginning with the words, Say, surely true guidance—the guidance of Allah—is that one may be given the like of that which has been given to you. Then comes again the speech of the Jews in the words, or they would argue with you before your Lord, the verse finally ending with the Divine commandment: Say, 'All bounty, etc.' This style is peculiar to the Holy Qur’an and is intended to produce a good psychological effect.
(2) According to another interpretation, only the words which in this case would be translated as "Say, the true guidance is the guidance of Allah," would be considered as being parenthetical and the following words, i.e. that one be given the like of that which has been given to you, ...before your Lord, would be taken to form part of the speech of the Jews. (3) Yet according to a third interpretation the speech of the Jews is taken to end with the words, obey none but him who follows your religion, the succeeding clauses being considered to be all Divine speech. See also 'The Larger Edition of this Commentary.'
‘He [a]selects for His mercy whomsoever He pleases. And Allah is the Lord of mighty grace.’
[a] 2:106.
Among the People of the Book there is he who, if thou trust him with a treasure, will return it to thee; and among them there is he who, if thou trust him with a dinar, will not return it to thee, unless thou keep standing over him. That is because they say, ‘We are not liable to be called to account in the matter of the Unlearned people’;[429] and they utter a lie against Allah knowingly.
[429] In the time of the Holy Prophet the idea had gained ground among the Jews that it was no sin to rob a Gentile (non-Jew) Arab of his possession and property because the latter followed a false religion. Possibly, the idea had its origin in the Jewish law of usury, which makes an invidious distinction between a Jew and a non-Jew regarding the giving and taking of interest (Exod. 22: 25; Lev. 25: 36, 37; Deut. 23: 20).
Nay, but [b]whoso fulfils his pledge and fears Allah— verily, Allah loves those who fear Him.
[b] 5:2; 6:153; 13:21; 16:92; 17:35.
As for those who take [c]a paltry price in exchange for their covenant with Allah and their oaths, they shall have no portion in the life to come, and [d]Allah will neither speak to them nor look upon them[430] on the Day of Resurrection, nor will He purify them; and for them shall be a grievous punishment.
[c] See 2:42.
[d] 2:175; 23:109.
[430] God will not speak to them words of kindness nor will look upon them with mercy and compassion, nor will adjudge them as pure.
And, surely, among them is a party [a]who twist their tongues while reciting the Book[431] that you may think it to be part of the Book, while it is not part of the Book. And they say, ‘It is from Allah;’ while it is not from Allah; and they utter a lie against Allah while they know.
[a] 2:76; 4:47; 5:42.
[431] It is an allusion to an evil practice of some Jews in the time of the Holy Prophet. They would recite a passage in Hebrew in such a manner as would deceive the hearers into believing that it was the Torah that was being recited. The word "Book" used thrice in this verse means "a passage in Hebrew" in the first place and "the Torah" in the last two. The passage is spoken of as "the Book" because the Jews tried to make it appear as such.
It does not befit[432] a truthful man that Allah should give him the Book and Wisdom and Prophethood, and then [b]he should say to men, ‘Be my worshippers instead of Allah;’ but he would say, ‘Be solely devoted[432A] to the Lord because you teach the Book and because you study it,’[432B]
[432] The expression ma Kana la-hu is used in three senses: (a) It does not become him to do so. (b) It is not possible for him to do so; or, it does not stand to reason that he should have done so; (c) he cannot possibly do so, i.e. it is physically impossible for him to do so.
[b] 5:117, 118.
[432A] Rabbaniyyin is the plural of Rabbaniy which means, (1) one who devotes himself to religious service or applies himself to acts of devotion; (2) one who possesses knowledge of God; (3) one who is learned in religious lore, or a good or righteous man; (4) a teacher who begins to nourish people with the small matters of knowledge or science before taking the great ones; (5) a lord or master or a leader; (6) a reformer (Lane, Sibawaih & Mubarrad).
[432B] The words, because you teach the Book and because you study it, show that it is the duty of all those who themselves have acquired spiritual knowledge that they should impart it to others and should not let men grope in the darkness of ignorance.
Nor does it befit him that he should bid you take the angels and the Prophets for lords. What! would he enjoin you to disbelieve after you have submitted to God?
And remember the time [a]when Allah took a covenant[433] from the people through the Prophets, saying, ‘Whatever I give you of the Book and Wisdom and then there comes to you a Messenger, fulfilling[433A] that which is with you, you shall believe in him and help him.’ And He said, ‘Do you agree, and do you accept the responsibility which I lay upon you in this matter?’ They said, ‘We agree.’ He said, ‘Then bear witness and I am with you among the witnesses.’[433B]
[a] 5:13.
[433] The expression Mithaqun-Nabiyyin may either signify the covenant of the Prophets with God or the covenant which God took from the people through their Prophets. The expression has been used here in the latter sense because another reading of the expression as supported by Ubayy bin Ka‘b and ‘Abdullah bin Mas‘ud is Mithaqalladhina ’utul-Kitab meaning, the covenant of those who were given the Book (Muhit). This rendering is also supported by the words that follow, i.e. and then there comes to you a Messenger fulfilling that which is with you, because it was to the people and not to their Prophets that the Messengers of God came.
[433A] The word Musaddiq has been used here to denote the criterion by which a true claimant is distinguished from a false one. The word has been rightly translated here as "fulfilling," for it is only by "fulfilling" in his person the prophecies contained in the previous revealed Scriptures that a claimant can prove his truth.
[433B] This verse is also considered to apply to other Prophets in general and to the Holy Prophet in particular. Both applications are correct. The verse lays down a general rule. The advent of every Prophet takes place in fulfilment of certain prophecies made by a previous Prophet in which he enjoins his followers to accept the next Prophet when he makes his appearance. If the Prophet comes in fulfilment of the prophecies contained in the Scriptures of one people only, as was the case with Jesus and other Israelite Prophets, then only that people are bound to accept and help him: but if the Scriptures of all religions predict the coming of a Prophet, as in the case of the Holy Prophet, then all nations are bound to accept him. The Holy Prophet appeared in fulfilment of the prophecies not only of the Israelite Prophets (Isa. 21: 13-15. Deut. 18: 18; 33: 2. John 14: 25, 26; 16: 7-13) but also of the Aryan seers and Buddhist and Zoroastrian sages (Safrang Dasatir, p. 188, Siraji Press, Delhi Jamaspi, published by Nizamul-Masha’ikh, Delhi, 1330 A.H.).
Now [a]whoso turns away after this, then, surely, those are the transgressors.
[a] 5:48; 24:56.
Do they seek a religion other than Allah’s, while to Him submits whosoever is in the heavens and the earth, willingly or unwillingly,[434] and to Him shall they all be returned?
[434] As in the physical world man must submit to the laws of nature—and he knows by experience that such submission is useful for him—it is only reasonable that, in spiritual matters also wherein he has been granted a certain amount of freedom, he should obey the laws and commands of Allah and thus win His pleasure to his own benefit.