The Promised Messiah

Testimony of the Holy Qur’an, Part 9

But the question is, why are such clear and simple meanings not accepted. Are they beyond the power of God Almighty? And why instead are those meanings accepted that fall under the category of far-fetched interpretations? Is God Almighty not powerful enough to have brought the Jews of the time of Moses as back to life in the time of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, by way of reincarnation, just as our opponents believe that He will bring back Hadrat ‘Isa, in his physical body from the heaven at some point in time after hundreds of years? When it is accepted on the basis of unfounded sayings that the soul of Hadrat ‘Isa will return to the world, then why and on what basis should it not be accepted that the souls of all those Jews mentioned in the manifest and explicit text in the Holy Qur’an had returned to the world in the time of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, by way of reincarnation? Look, God Almighty clearly says:

Meaning that, remember the time when you, and not someone else, said that we will not believe in you just because you ask us until we see God face-to-face. Then a thunderstorm struck you while you were watching.

There is another subtle point in this verse; namely, that God Almighty did not declare the Jews [in the time of the Holy Prophet s (as)] as the successors of the past generation. Rather, He addressed them as if they themselves were the Jews of old. Thus, in this case, the Holy Qur’an has given the Jews in the time of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, the exact same names of the earlier Bani Isra’il. Therefore, since these people have been declared to be those very same people, it necessitates that they also have the same names. The reason is that names are for historical facts like organs are for the body from which they cannot be separated; and essential ‘organs’ [i.e. names] cannot be separated from their corresponding facts.

Now consider well that, while addressing the Jews in the time of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, God Almighty said in clear and categorical terms that you indeed were the ones who committed such and such wicked deeds in the time of Moses as. Then how unjust and wrongful is it to subject such a clear and explicit verse to various interpretations; but on the basis of ahadith alone, to bring Jesus as back to earth even though his death is clearly established from the Holy Qur’an.

Dear friends! If it is indeed the way and practice of God Almighty that He brings people of the past back into the world, then the definitive text of the Holy Qur’an that repeatedly addresses the dead, and thus testifies to their lives, can never be legitimately ignored. But if, in this context, you fear that even though such meanings are not beyond the power of God Almighty, they nonetheless defy reason and, therefore, you incline towards such interpretations and meanings as are not contrary to reason, then the prophecy regarding the coming of Jesus must indeed be interpreted in the same way. Because if reason opposes the Jews of the past coming back to life in the blessed ministry of our Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, or if the returning of their souls by way of transmigration seems unreasonable, then why is it suggested that Hadrat Masih will return to the world, despite the following verse giving a loud and clear testimony concerning his death:

Is the return of the souls of the Jews to the world irrational and beyond the powers of God Almighty, and yet the return of Hadrat ‘Isa to the earth in his physical body quite rational? Moreover, if on account of the impossibility of literal meanings, the clear and obvious statements of the Holy Qur’an are interpreted to mean something other than their apparent meanings, then why can we not interpret ahadith to mean something other than their apparent and literal meanings? Is the status of ahadith higher than that of the Holy Qur’an that we must always stick to their literal meanings, however irrational, yet subject the Holy Qur’an to various interpretations?

To revert to the main subject, some people deny the general application of the verse:

They say that the word ْ مِنْکُم [minkum—from among you] in the verse refers only to the Companions and that true Khilafat ended in their age, so that henceforth there would be no trace of Khilafat in Islam until the Day of Judgement; as if, like a short-lived dream, Khilafat lasted for only thirty years and, thereafter, Islam suffered an eternal doom. But may I ask: Can any righteous person believe that the blessings of the shariah of Moses as and his Khilafat continued for 1,400 years without interruption, but the blessings of that Prophet s (as) —who has been declared to be ‘the Most Exalted Messenger’ and ‘the Best of all the Prophets’ and whose shariah will last till doomsday—were limited really only to his own time and God Almighty did not desire that examples of his blessings should be manifested through his spiritual Khulafa’ for a long time to come? I shudder at hearing such statements. It is a pity that such people, too, are indeed called Muslims who utter such blasphemous words, by way of complete insolence and cunning, that apparently the future holds no more Islamic blessings; rather, they have long since come to an end.

Besides, it is strange logic to infer from the word minkum that since the Companions were the prime addressees, therefore, this Khilafat was limited to them. If the Holy Qur’an were interpreted in this way, it would amount to a bigger transgression than that of the Jews. Now let it be clear that the word minkum has occurred approximately eighty-two times in the Holy Qur’an and on all those occasions, except for two or three where a specific context has been given, the word minkum stands invariably for all the Muslims who will be born until doomsday.

Now, by way of example, I write a few of those verses in which the word minkum is found:

1

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

(1) Meaning that, whoso among you is sick or is on a journey should fast the same number of other days. Now think whether this injunction was exclusively for the Companions ra, or whether all other Muslims who will be born till doomsday are its addressees? Likewise, ponder over the following verses:

Meaning that, this is an admonition for he among you who believes in Allah and the Last Day.

3

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

(3) Meaning that, and those of you who die and leave wives behind.

I will allow not the work of any worker from among you, whether male or female, to be lost.

1

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

(6) Devour not your property among yourselves by unlawful means, except that you earn by trade with mutual consent.

Meaning that, if you are ill or on a journey, or come from the privy, or you have touched women, and you find not water, then in all these circumstances, betake yourselves to pure dust.

3

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

(8) Meaning that, obey Allah, the Messenger, and your sovereigns.

4

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

(9) Meaning that, whichever person from among you commits any evil deed due to his ignorance, and then repents and becomes occupied with doing good deeds, then Allah is Most Forgiving, Merciful.

Meaning that, whichever person among you commits such a deed shall face disgrace in the present life; and on the Day of Judgement, there is for him a severe punishment.

2

[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]

(11) Meaning that, there is not one from among you who shall not come to hell.

·

10 of 10 left today