Urdu question-and-answer session, 23 August 1985
- 1. Hudhur, my question is: on the occasion of the Battle of Ahzab, when the blessed teeth of the Holy Prophet (saw) were broken and Abu Sufyan said, 'Glory to Hubal!' [Hudhur interrupts: That did not happen on that occasion, you have it wrong; it was at the Battle of Uhud.] Then the Holy Prophet (saw) said, 'Why do you not reply?' [Hudhur: That is a different matter; you have mixed up both events. The incident of not replying belongs to a later stage, when the Holy Prophet (saw) had regained consciousness and then, supported by the Companions, went into a cave; it is the interval mentioned in the Holy Qur’an where God then caused slumber to overtake the Companions. Because it was a state of weakness, the Holy Prophet (saw) forbade replying, even if they raised boastful slogans. This incident has no connection with the breaking of the teeth.] At that time it was called out, 'Is Muhammad (saw) among you?' and he said, do not answer. Then it was called about Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq [Hudhur: Not as 'Amir-ul-Momineen'; Abu Bakr and Umar became that later], then about Hazrat Umar (ra); he said, do not answer. Then Abu Sufyan said, 'Glory to Hubal!' and the Holy Prophet (saw) said, 'Why do you not reply?' The Companions asked, 'O Messenger of Allah, what shall we reply?' Now, when the Kalima is seized and thrown down today – while the Holy Prophet (saw) taught that Allah alone is great and exalted, and the very meaning of 'La ilaha illallah' is that nothing besides God is worthy of worship – yet we were taught to be patient, we have the command of patience: we cannot describe our state at such times. What should we do?
- 2. My mother is Ahmadi and my father is a non-Ahmadi. [Hudhur: Are you Ahmadi by birth or did you join later?] I cannot quite say by birth, because my father is non-Ahmadi. [Hudhur: If you have been Ahmadi since childhood and were never non-Ahmadi, you can call yourself Ahmadi by birth.] Yes, since childhood; all of us siblings are Ahmadis. [Hudhur: Fine, so you were with your mother from the start.] Our father is non-Ahmadi, and an elder (step-)brother too. We leave the brother aside, but the father is a staunch opponent of Ahmadiyyat, constantly abuses it and speaks disrespectfully of us, the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat and Hudhur. What should our response be? [Hudhur: Patience and prayer for him, nothing else. The teaching of praying in return for abuse is undoubtedly very difficult, but we are bound; we cannot abandon the teaching. This is not optional; I cannot permit you otherwise.] It goes further, to beating. When the father beats, what should we do? [Hudhur: You are young …] When we were small it was bearable; now we are grown up. [Hudhur: If you may not even hit back a stranger, how will you hit your father?] No, we won't do that, but our father treats our mother this way.
- 3. [Partly unintelligible] Here in Germany, by God's grace and your prayers, we are doing very well. There are boys from Pakistan; since the PPP ended in Pakistan, they see that Ahmadi asylum cases are being accepted and now try to pass themselves off as Ahmadis. At any station one asks, 'Make us Ahmadis.' When they then go to their own mosque, the same boys mock us and spread propaganda, while our situation is such that we cannot avoid them. [Hudhur: Why do you do that? … If you do not know, then …] We do not know why they want this. [Hudhur: On one hand you say you do not know, on the other that they make mischief in the other mosque. With those you know about, act accordingly; with those you do not know about …] They will openly oppose.
- 4. [Question itself not preserved; as restated by Hudhur:] If there is an Islamic government somewhere, what should its attitude be towards nuclear weapons?
- 5. Hudhur, my question concerns Hazrat Adam (as). Hazrat Adam (as) is described as the father of the present human race, or, as written in the Holy Qur’an: I appointed Adam as Khalifa. If he was the father of this race, over whom was he appointed Khalifa? Were there humans before him? – Secondly: when we read the Holy Qur’an, it says God forbade Adam to approach that tree and eat its fruit; he ate it and was led astray by Satan. This gives the impression that only after eating the fruit did circumstances arise by which human procreation began. What fruit was it, what was it that was forbidden?
- 6. Can you please explain the revelation of the Promised Messiah (as) that he was the mantle of the prophets?
- 7. (The question precedes this section and is not preserved. From the answer it concerns the prophecy that the earlier prophets would appear in the latter days.)
- 8. (The question is unintelligible in the audio; the answer indicates it concerns the creation of man or evolution.)
10 of 10 left today