Urdu question-and-answer session, 30 March 1986
- 1. The speaker before you said that this movement was announced in 1849. What role did your organisation and your elders play in the War of Independence of 1857? Sir Syed Ahmad Khan and many other landlords, who even today own hundreds and thousands of acres of land, criticised the War of Independence until the very end. But an ordinary Muslim … (Follow-ups:) By 1849 the British had reached the Punjab. Did your elders condemn it, as Sir Syed Ahmad and many others did? You yourself call it 'Ghadar' (mutiny). Hindus and Sikhs generally say that. I have never heard any Muslim speak this way of the 1857 independence movement. (When asked whether there was ever a jihad in which idolaters and Muslims fought together:) For freedom one has to do so. The Holy Prophet (saw) allied with the Jews of Medina against the Meccans. There was an agreement with the Jews, after all. (Finally:) So he forbade jihad?
- 2. (The question is read out:) What would you say about non-Ahmadi people? Are they Muslims according to Ahmadiyyat or not? (Supplementary question from someone present:) Since the Messiah of Qadian, has merely reciting the Kalima Tayyiba become insufficient? For someone to call himself Muslim, is it not sufficient that he professes the Kalima Tayyiba? You just said that whoever does not acknowledge the Messiah, does not believe in him, how can he be a Muslim? (Further interjection:) The Holy Prophet (saw) did not say this to anyone who did not accept him.
- 3. Why do Ahmadis not perform Fatiha Khwani when they go to a Muslim's home upon a death? (Follow-ups:) Our elders, whom we follow – did they know less about Islam? Were our elders wrong, were they not Muslims? Is this a custom? Fatiha Khwani is indeed a prayer.
- 4. Qazi Sahib Jalil Sahib has asked a question (which was forcibly made number three). He says: Regarding the creation of Adam – we are not familiar with Darwin's theory. We want to know what the Islamic view is on the creation of Adam. Does the verse 'Inni ja'ilun fil-ardi khalifa' ('I am about to place a vicegerent in the earth') refer to the creation of mankind, or is it glad tidings of the advent of a prophet?
- 5. Question number two: You surely know that Hindu women fill sindoor in the parting of their hair for the welfare and closeness of their husbands. A man employed at a sindoor factory hesitantly asked the factory owner: 'Sir, is what is written on the sindoor box true?' The owner sensed the delicacy of the matter and said laughingly: 'God gave the knowledge of sindoor to my father in a dream; I am just carrying on the work he started.' Would you kindly tell us whether Mirza Sahib was truly a prophet, or did he too merely dream of being a prophet? Is your conscience satisfied in this matter that you are carrying on the work Mirza Ghulam Ahmad started? – Ejaz Sahib Janjua.
10 of 10 left today