Urdu question-and-answer session, 11 May 1991
- 1. Huzoor, last year I asked you a question and it gave rise to another question. [Huzoor (rh): It took you a year to produce a second result? A child takes nine months.] You had said that because the Mormons' morals are good, Allah is not destroying them, despite their believing in a false prophet.
- 2. Hazrat Khalifatul Masih II (ra), in describing the differences between the Bible and the Holy Qur’an, writes in Tafsir-e-Kabir, volume 3, page 246: The Bible says of Aaron that by virtue of being a member of the family of Levi, the family of Moses, he was his brother, not a real or maternal brother; it says: God said, Is not Aaron the Levite thy brother? I know that he can speak well (Exodus chapter 4). But the Holy Qur’an describes Aaron (as) as the real brother or maternal brother of Moses. However, another Bible reference also describes him as a real brother: Amram took Jochebed, his father's sister, as wife, and she bore him Aaron and Moses. This shows the Bible also calls him a real brother.
- 3. In Islam too it is believed that angels assume human form, and among Christians as well. In the incident of Abraham (as), Hazrat Khalifatul Masih II (ra) explained that they were angels. How can one know whether an angel in human form is sitting in front of you or a human being? They feel hungry, they marry …
- 4. My question too relates to last year. You said in an answer that if husband and wife pray, the wife may say the Iqamat. If father and daughter, or son and mother pray, what is the ruling for the daughter and the mother – may they say the Iqamat?
- 5. (Continuation of the answer to the question about angels in human form)
- 6. Huzoor, when you were meeting two people, someone asked a question which I could not understand properly. His question was: when decline comes upon a people, God sends His appointed ones; thus when decline came, the Holy Prophet (saw) came. But now our people's condition is such that even some Ahmadi brothers themselves drink alcohol – how can they do Tabligh? Although Rabwah is our centre, the condition there too is very delicate. Why is this? People say …
- 7. Huzoor, there are many common features between the era of the Holy Prophet (saw) and the era of the Promised Messiah (as). [Huzoor: No, it is one era; only the era of the Holy Prophet (saw), until the Day of Judgement. Within that era, from the time of the Promised Messiah (as), the age of Messiahship also begins; the two cannot be separated. Put it this way.] So many things are common. [Huzoor: What do you mean many – everything should be common.] The Holy Prophet (saw) migrated from Mecca to Medina. Can it be thought that he (as) too …
- 8. Huzoor, I lived in Saudi Arabia for about six years. In the Saudi government there is a rule that Tabligh cannot be done there. The Saudis say: we do not know whether the Promised Messiah has come or not. When on the Day of Judgement God asks them, they say: nobody came and told us that the Promised Messiah has come, so we did not accept. Will the Saudis be forgiven on that day because they can say nobody told them?
- 9. The first question concerns the enforcement of Sharia in Pakistan. When an oppressed woman is raped and states in court that this injustice was done to her, but cannot produce four witnesses, the court has declared her guilty and punished her as guilty of adultery. Such a case happened in Pakistan; a magazine published in Germany writes that this law will further worsen the condition of Muslim women … What is the Islamic concept regarding this?
- 10. The second question concerns the splitting of the moon. According to what I have read in the books of the Promised Messiah (as) and in Tafsir-e-Saghir by Hazrat Khalifatul Masih II (ra), in my view the moon did not actually split into two. But when I talked with some Ahmadi friends, they insist that the moon actually split; that what the Promised Messiah (as) has written in Ayina-e-Kamalat-e-Islam and some other books shows this. But Hazrat Khalifatul Masih II (ra) wrote in Tafsir-e-Saghir that those who think the moon actually split are wrong.
- 11. Huzoor, last month a German friend came to our Tabligh stall and asked us about the Black Stone: first, whether it is mentioned in the Holy Qur’an, and second, why it had importance before Islam and still has importance after Islam, and Muslims even kiss it. Using Islamic history we satisfied him and also contacted the missionary, but still there was some discussion in our community later. Can you shed more light on this, because when one kisses a stone …
- 12. Huzoor, here in Germany many friends ask us why eating pork is forbidden. Germans say this too is an animal made by God; why has Islam declared it forbidden, what is the rational argument?
- 13. My dear Huzoor, earlier you answered my brother that a child is born in nine months. In this connection I read in a book – I do not know about it, so I ask – that Hazrat Imam Hussain was born six months and ten days after his elder brother Hazrat Imam Hassan. After the birth of the first child, the postnatal period is at least forty days. What follows from this?
- 14. Huzoor, when funeral prayer is offered, I have often noted it is said that the number of rows should be odd. What is the particular reason for this from the Islamic point of view? But when a very great man dies and hundreds of thousands come, this is not observed. I remember that at the funeral prayer of Khalifatul Masih III (rh) I did not see any such thing.
- 15. My dear Huzoor, if during prostration in prayer one can be absorbed in the praise of Allah, as you said in a sermon – it often happens to me that I start thinking from a scientific point of view; many times I wander off into the universe in prayer. Does this affect the prayer?
- 16. If a German comes to our stall and asks for Pakistani melodies or songs, qawwali etc., may we give them to him? For example the Pakistani qawwal Nusrat Fateh Ali – he demanded his recordings.
- 17. I am Ahmed Ismail from Ghana and I would like to know, from the Islamic point of view, if smoking is a sin or not.
10 of 10 left today