Urdu question-and-answer session, 10 September 1993
- 1. Huzur, our knowledge is based on experiences and observations. It is related about Hazrat Moses (as) that the sea split into two and closed again when Pharaoh came. But the law of nature does not show such a thing. Just as the ascension of Hazrat Jesus (as) to heaven is against the law of nature, it is likewise not understandable how this happened. Similarly the birth of Hazrat Jesus (as) without a father.
- 2. Huzur, in the city where I live there are many Turks, and they have three or four mosques there. In these mosques they talk more about politics than about the worship of God. Whenever we hold Tabligh conversations with them, they turn the topic to politics. I want to know what the relationship between religion and politics is, and what the Holy Qur’an and Sunnah teach about it.
- 3. My question is: who came to the earth first?
- 4. Huzur, the Holy Prophet (saw) [said] that after him there would be 73 sects. Will likewise [the community] of the Messiah (as) split into sects?
- 5. My name is Abdul Momin, I am a representative of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat in [Brussels?]. In the Holy Qur’an reward and punishment, life after death and the Day of Judgement are mentioned very frequently, but in the books of the People of the Book they are not mentioned. If they are mentioned at all, it is as vaguely as when we apply some events of the Last Day to this world. What is the reason? Second: if a person does not believe in life after death at all, what arguments can be given to him?
- 6. Huzur, some Pakistanis and German friends say: as we believe, or know, Hazrat Jesus (as) is buried in Srinagar – how do you know this and how do you prove it? Please shed light on this.
- 7. My name is Majid, my father’s name is Karim Ahmad. My question: Hazrat Masih-e-Maud (as) was born in Qadian and passed away [elsewhere] … [rest of question: when will we return to Qadian?]
- 8. I have been here since 1987. My question is about the Jehovah’s Witnesses, an offshoot of Christianity. They have many wrong customs. We talk with them a lot in the course of Tabligh, but when it comes to reading, or a video or something like that, [they do not accept it].
- 9. Huzur, for six or seven years I have been studying Ahmadiyyat. By Allah’s grace everything has become clear, I have filled in the form and, God willing, will now take the Bai‘at. A small question: among the other, non-Ahmadi Muslims, are there pious people and Sufis who are close to God? If so, why do they not see the right path? What is the philosophy behind this?
- 10. (The question precedes this excerpt; only the end of the answer survives, apparently about the visible effect of prayer and relationship with God among Ahmadis.)
- 11. The second question is about Christianity and Islam. The Holy Qur’an states that Hazrat Abraham (as) offered Hazrat Ishmael (as) as a sacrifice before Allah the Exalted in accordance with His will, whereas the Christians – in the Bible, as I have read – have the name of Hazrat Isaac (as) written there. Whenever there is a discussion with these Christians, they present exactly this argument, that this is the very first difference between the Holy Qur’an and the Bible.
- 12. The third question: [Where are prophecies about] Hazrat Muhammad (saw)? – [Hazrat (rh): Is the Old or New Testament meant?] – The New; that is what I have read. – [Then say: in the Gospel.] – Yes, in the Gospel. In which part of the book is it, and which verses are they?
10 of 10 left today