Urdu question-and-answer session, 28 May 1993
- 1. (Question at the start inaudible; it apparently concerns the verses of Surah Al-Kahf about those who ascribed a son to God and took gods besides God, and how to address the materially advanced Western world.)
- 2. A small child asks: For whom do we offer the prayer (Namaz)?
- 3. Assalamu alaikum. The question is: were the Companions of the Cave prophets or not? For it is reported about them that they stayed long in the cave, and this is partly related to four centuries; were they ordinary believing people?
- 4. (Question inaudible; apparently about playing cards.)
- 6. Assalamu alaikum. Why is Allah the Exalted described in the Holy Qur’an as ‘Azim’ (great) and not as ‘A‘zam’ (the greatest)?
- 7. (Question barely audible) What is the meaning and wisdom of the Muqatta‘at, the abbreviated letters in the Holy Qur’an?
- 8. (The wording of the question is only fragmentarily preserved in the recording.) In essence it asks why the House of God (the Ka‘bah) was taken from the idolaters and whether this was interference in their religion. It is mentioned that the Holy Qur’an says: “Inna awwala baitin wudi‘a lin-nasi …” (Surely the first House founded for mankind …).
- 9. (Introduction partly unintelligible.) The reason is that the names of the Prophet … as reported in Herat. A research scholar from Oxford published a book (title unclear, something like “Among the …”), printed by Oxford Press; I have seen it myself. In it a scholar writes: In Herat, where we had gone to research …, we came upon a tribe called Musawi, the tribe of Moses. Its religion is “Christian-Muslim”. He writes: When I heard that they call themselves Christian Muslims, I was very surprised – one is either a Christian or a Muslim; how can both go together? In this quest I met their leader, named Aba Yahya. When I asked Aba Yahya, he said: We call ourselves Christian Muslims because Hazrat Isa (as) did us the favour of bringing us the true teaching, establishing the Unity of God, and training us so that we became fit to accept Islam. Earlier we were Christians, and because of his pure teaching we accepted Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw). To keep the name of our old benefactor alive, we chose to call ourselves Christian Muslims. He asked him: Which Isa are you talking about? He died through that event (the crucifixion). He replied to me: You are mistaken; Isa (as) survived, from there he migrated. We too were Children of Israel(?); through his preaching we became Christians. And the Bible he left with us they showed him; it is preserved with us in the form of scrolls. In this New Testament that Isa (as) left us there is no mention of a Trinity, no mention of a visible God or Son of God; it is a pure teaching. And because we accepted the true Isa and not an imaginary one, when the message of Islam arrived we became Muslims in accordance with the message of Isa (as). … either in Afghanistan or in Kashmir. Is that right or not? Their traditions, their names, their appearance, their customs, the names of their scholars – all these names appear twice, once in Afghanistan and once in Kashmir.
- 10. My question is: (… largely unintelligible …) In research there is one law of nature and another law … if someone is struck with a stick … (In essence: How is the rescue of Abraham (as) from the fire reconciled with the laws of nature?)
- 11. My question is: God says, whom Allah guides, no one can mislead, and whom Allah (lets go astray), no one can (guide). (Rest of the question unintelligible.)
- 12. The Holy Prophet (saw) has forbidden in a tradition that one should assume the guise of the opposite sex and imitate it. In this light the question to Huzur: In any cultural programme, when staging the romantic tale of Heer Ranjha, is it permissible for a girl (to play a male role)?
- 13. What did the Messiah (as) claim, and what does the second Messiah claim? … (Rest unintelligible; in essence: similarities with the time of the first Messiah.)
- 15. (Heavily garbled.) … An Allama has … a tradition, in which it says that … will happen in the latter days, and Hazrat Musleh Mau‘ud (ra) explained this … in the latter days … Can we say that, since now … has turned into wine/alcohol, this is the fulfilment?
10 of 10 left today