Urdu question-and-answer session, 24 December 1985
- 1. (The actual question is not clearly audible. From the answer it is evident that it was asked how, in view of the many contradictory prophecies about the Imam Mahdi, one can recognise the true Imam Mahdi.)
- 2. I am not an Ahmadi Muslim. I want to ask a question and first make some introductory remarks. Firstly I am someone who has love, secondly someone who is very fond of Muslims. I myself grew up in Asia Minor, in Turkey. I find Muslims very good and I like these people very much, although I am convinced that at least 80% of them do not know true Islam, do not properly build the principles of Islam into their lives and do not show the genuine character one should expect from a true Muslim. Against this background, the most important thing today seems to me that in Pakistan incidents occur against Ahmadi Muslims that cannot be called not only un-Islamic but not even humane. I ask as a layman and would like the answer in a layman’s language, short and to the point: why does this hatred exist between Ahmadi Muslims and the other Muslims? There are certainly some matters on which they differ. With common sense the solution would be to reflect on these problems: what separates Ahmadi Muslims from other Muslims? Suppose that for all reasons the other Muslims are to blame, because we cannot interpret the Holy Qur’an correctly or cannot distinguish Arab customs from Islamic positions. Even then the Ahmadi Muslims would have the duty to consider how they can remove these misunderstandings among the other Muslims, even if the others are 100% to blame. One cannot say: you are stupid, you don’t understand, I have nothing to do with you. If one is convinced of one’s own cause, one must talk about it, not fear the problem, not put it aside, talk about externals and forget the main issue. Whoever does that is as far from his duty as the other side. A Muslim of good will should say clearly what the others do wrong, but the same people should also discuss among themselves what could be better on their side, whether the differing ideas should not be examined again, and whether one should not say: they understand this sentence completely differently from how we say it; they may not say that in our name. In this respect I miss an explanation in the writings and statements; a Muslim of good will cannot read between the lines the main reason for this inhuman behaviour. I would like to ask the community whether you also see the solution in this direction, or if not, where you see the main approaches to solve or at least prevent this problem.
- 3. (The question is not preserved in the recording. From the answer it concerns the persecution of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat in Pakistan and the ordinance issued there.)
- 4. Is Jesus Christ buried in Kashmir?
- 5. My question, the point I emphasised, has not been understood at all. I suppose it is my own fault because I wrote the question at length, but I emphasise something once more. I really wanted to hear where Ahmadis think differently from other Muslims. I saw the solution in talking about it and examining whether both sides consistently make mistakes and where these mistakes come from, so that one can tell the others: you burden us Ahmadis with such things and say we are not Muslims – and these things are certainly not true – but we only say this and that differently from you, and those are the reasons for calling us non-Muslims. That is what I want to hear about. The other stories had nothing to do with the emphasis of my question; I know them all. That other Muslims do not even want to hear the Kalima or As-salamu alaikum from Ahmadis are outward matters that have nothing to do with the basic issue. Why they have such an attitude towards Ahmadis – those are the other reasons where they think differently, perhaps rightly, I say nothing against it, for the most part I say rightly. One should focus on that, repeat some things and explain that one rightly interprets the Holy Qur’an somewhat differently, based on what one has heard and learned and what modern times have brought. That was the emphasis of my question. (The rest of the question is unintelligible.)
- 6. (The question is not contained in the recording; inferred from context:) Does the second coming of the Son of Mary (Ibn Maryam) mean the return of the same person Jesus (as), or is the name used metaphorically?
- 7. (Question not recorded; inferred:) Are the Imam Mahdi and the Messiah (Isa ibn Maryam) two different persons?
10 of 10 left today